Best Twilight film

[Noctis]

Twilight - C+New Moon - D+Eclipse - B+Breaking Dawn: Part 1 - C-So, Eclipse wins this very easily.

[Fakhir]

Eclipse by far.

[Kalderic]

There has yet to be a good one... But I would probably say eclipse by a tad... But it still sucked. And I don't see this final one being any good either.

[The Stingray]

Without having seen anyone of them I can comfortably say that they all suck.

Edited August 13, 2012 by Don Niam The Stingray

[Fanboy]

Eclipse was the only watchable one IMO. I could not bare sitting through any of the others again.

[Ajde]

None.

[75Live]

Not crazy about any of them really, but it is either Eclipse or the original and since the backstory of the family members were just useless to me in Eclipse, I will take the original.

Edited August 13, 2012 by 75live

[Hiccup]

Eclipse- C+Twilight- CBreaking Dawn Part 1- D+New Moon- D-

[cozmeesah]

Eclipse, easily. But even that had me WTF'ing a few times and the "fight" seemed a bit anti-climactic after all the buildup. But at least it wasn't boring.The first one isn't *bad* persay, just boring as all hell. An hour in I found myself wondering if anything was going to happen. Lots of unintentional funny parts though. Running up the mountain with Bella was all kinds of LOL. New Moon was irritating, stupid and almost completely unnecessary. How anyone can watch that and still think of Bella as a strong female protagonist is beyond me. Also beyond me is why everyone is so enamored with this chick. I'd want to smack her.BD1 wasn't bad either, but I couldn't help but think "That's it?" when it came to the wedding and the honeymoon. People were all excited waiting for that? Not even mentioning the logistics of a dead person with no blood flow being able to either have sex or impregnate someone. Plus it was rather zzzzz up until the birth scene. Not to mention the talking werewolves. Certainly didn't make me all excited to see the last one in theaters either. Will wait to redbox the DVD.Lautner also got worse and worse each movie. One question though... the pack is mindful of wasting shirts because they get torn when they change, yet they must be okay replenishing their seemingly endless supply of cargo shorts. Those would also get torn to shreds, correct? Not that it matters, it just makes me laugh.

[tommycruise]

This is like choosing between terminal cancer and the Ebola Virus.

[Phil in the Blank]

This one....by far.

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0086491/

[yads]

I liked the one where Kristen Stewart forgot about the annoying EMO boyfriend and went to work in a theme park. Twilight: Adventureland I think it was called.

[Gopher]

I loved the one where K-Stew falls in love with that college boy who's on his way to Alaska.

[baumer]

I think they're all pretty good films but they all have their problems. My main problem with them is that the Volturi are perhaps the most interesting characters in the books and the movies and when they are on screen, it's great, but they aren't enough.Twilight: 7/10NM: 9/10Eclipse: 9.5/10BD1: 8.5/10

[Letsuseournoggin]

I've only seen Twilight, NM and Eclipse.. and I can't differentiate NM and Eclipse. I think I liked NM more than any of the 3 I saw but I may be wrong though.

[CJohn]

Eclipse wins this easily. It is the only one that is decent and I truly enjoyed.

[RichWS]

Eclipse was crappy but watchable. I've only seen that and New Moon, which was DREADFUL.

Edited October 24, 2012 by RichWS

[Olive]

all crap

[Accursed Arachnid!™]

Here's my question. If you thought the first 3 were "crap", why watch the fourth? Hell, I would have stopped at the 1st if I thought it was horrible. This proves that the negativity toward this franchise is mostly hyperbole. The "negative nancies" are now only watching to ridicule. ;)Anyway, I think New Moon is the only one that can really be called crap. At worst, the others can be called mediocre, IMO.Twilight BNew Moon C-Eclipse B+Breaking Dawn Part 1 B-

[cozmeesah]

The "negative nancies" are now only watching to ridicule.

Not necessarily. Maybe some people don't want to bash them without first seeing them.