Highever
Free Account-
Posts
45 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Profile Information
-
Gender
Male
Recent Profile Visitors
The recent visitors block is disabled and is not being shown to other users.
Highever's Achievements
Straight-to-DVD (2/10)
26
Reputation
-
Out of course, but not bad kid.
-
I think it's important to note that I am not approaching this from a storytelling perspective. I am approaching this from a canonical or lore perspective. In terms of relevant experience, in what is currently canon, Luke in ESB had infinitely more than Rey in TFA. He did have some formal training with Yoda, but there was far more to his journey than that. He had a few duels with Vader beforehand, and fought others with a lightsaber. Practiced his lightsaber technique, and force abilities. Rey had only picked up a lightsaber once before, and not to wield it in combat. It would be axiomatically ludicrous to criticize Luke's path of development in ANH, as that is the event that sets the precedent. You can say that Luke's accomplishments are more impressive, but that is not what I am concerned with. Luke's major accomplishment before any significant investment of time in force training was in piloting. He was supposed to be a pilot, that was his character. The force aided him in making a shot the script claimed he made many times. If you claim this is more impressive, fine, but that is irrelevant. I will not stand to see Luke's piloting accomplishment compared, apples to apples, to Rey's dueling accomplishment. Rey is categorically the least experienced duelist ever to duel in a Saga movie. Even Finn had more experience than her. Infinitely more to be precise. You try to parallel Rey's path with others, but this is no parallel to be drawn. You make the argument that other feats are more impressive, but that is not what I am concerned with. I believe you highly underestimate Kylo Ren. He is a dark sided Skywalker. Descended from the most powerful force lineage the universe has ever seen. At least twice as many years in training as Luke when Luke 'beat' Vader in RoTJ. Hand picked by Snoke for his potential, called the killer of jedi because he canonically wiped the jedi out. Kylo Ren does not need to be Vader for the outcome to be questionable.
-
There is no desire on my part to rehash this. I only do what I must. I will discuss her ability as a duelist. I find her performance in that final confrontation with Kylo Ren to be the most egregious. Luke Skywalker, in canon, had years of experience with a lightsaber before being soundly beaten by Darth Vader at Cloud City. His first feat with a lightsaber that you highlight was in canon replicated by four year jedi younglings. I don't know of any lightsaber feats Anakin showed without training, but he did eventually lose to Count Dooku after a decade of experience in the Jedi Temple. Dooku's experience meant more than Anakin's potential (even with substantial training) as the greatest to ever live and so on. Three years later, Anakin would win. He claimed his powers had doubled. From 19-22. Rey is 19, and Kylo is 29. Luke demonstrably struggled with telekinesis months after being introduced to the force, but Rey would pull a lightsaber away from a telekinetic expert that minutes prior threw her in to a tree. With no experience doing so. Kylo is not as untrained as you might think. He, at the very latest it is possible in canon, would have entered training at 23. Giving him 6 years. As for Kylo's diminished capacity, let's discuss Rey's for once. It seems plausible that being thrown in to a tree and then falling 20 feet or so would impact performance in a duel. So would fighting in cold while being acclimated to a desert climate. Further, Kylo had shown that he could engage in swordsmanship prior to fighting Rey. That he could run, and that he could use the force. This is to say little of Rey having to transition from a staff to a lightsaber with absolutely no preparation. I think there are fans far more knowledgable regarding the SW universe than Kasdan, fans that disagree with the outcome of this duel. It is not my claim that Rey's performance is necessarily a problem. Only that it can become so. Defenders of this scene often highlight Kylo's diminished capacity in pursuit of discrediting the massive success of Rey, but in doing so they argue what is essentially the narrative finale of the film is meant to be... meaningless. This victory is either significant, or it isn't. What was it supposed to be? If it is significant, then Rey's ability requires address.
-
They both had their piloting accomplishments. In addition to Rey's piloting, she was a linguist *droid and wookiespeak*, a duelist *never handled a lightsaber*, a telekinetic practitioner *never done it* etc... In canon, if Rey were to have done what she had without training, she has far surpassed Luke. Heir to the Jedi portrays Luke struggling with abilities Rey picked up in moments.
-
In my opinion, they have to utilize a mind wipe. ...Questionable storytelling perhaps, but it preserves some Star War canon. I hope that they realize her force display is problematic. I know the internal continuity people at Lucasfilm do. We'll see how much of a say they have. I also know JJ Abrams wasn't thinking of continuity when Rey pulled that lightsaber away from a telekinetic expert.... never having performed telekinesis before.