BoxOffice.com's Top 10 Comic Book Movies Of All Time (2013) [Ranking thread]

[Jake Gittes]

1. A History of Violence

2. Sin City

3. The Dark Knight

4. V for Vendetta

5. Batman Returns

6. Superman

7. Batman (1966)

8. Spider-Man 2

9. Scott Pilgrim Vs. the World

10. Watchmen

[Hanamichi Sakuragi]

Dude, did you get my PM? Cause I sent it before the latest update, but my name isn't listed there. Also, it says you haven't read it.

[#ED]

Dude, did you get my PM? Cause I sent it before the latest update, but my name isn't listed there. Also, it says you haven't read it.

Sorry I read it now.

[Hanamichi Sakuragi]

Goddamn it, I just watched Blue is the Warmest Colour, and now I've got to change my list.

 

If it isn't too much trouble, could you make Blue is the Warmest Colour my number one comic book movie of 2013, and knocking my current three off the list? And likewise, making it my number six on the Top 10 Comic Book Movies of All Time list, knocking my current number ten off the list.

Edited December 13, 2013 by Bad Cap

[#ED]

Goddamn it, I just watched Blue is the Warmest Colour, and now I've got to change my list.  If it isn't too much trouble, could you make Blue is the Warmest Colour my number one comic book movie of 2013, and knocking my current three off the list? And likewise, making it my number six on the Top 10 Comic Book Movies of All Time list, knocking my current number ten off the list.

Resend the list.

[Hanamichi Sakuragi]

Done.

[Jussslic]

Ooo, I wanna play.

 

1. Scott Pilgrim

2. Avengers

3. Iron Man

4. Men in Black

5. TDK

6. Nausicaa

7. American Splendor

8. Sin City

9. Ghost World

10. Oblivion - This film is so flawed, but the production design is just beautiful.

 

I like all the Marvel stuff though, and it feels weird not having one of Rami's Spidey films.  Also, I'm totally ashamed to say I haven't seen Oldboy and Akira. Need to get on that.  And I haven't watched Blue is the Warmest Colour yet.

Edited December 14, 2013 by Jussslic

[#ED]

Extending the deadline.

[Olive]

Top 10 Comic Book Movies of All Time

10.Spider-man
9.Superman 
8.The Dark Knight
7.Iron Man 3
6.X-men:First Class
5.Batman Begins
4.Iron Man
3.X2: X-Men United
2.Spider-Man 2
1. The Avengers

Q. What makes a good comic book movie to you?(sticking to the the comics, special effects, story,etc)
A. -Great VFX and decent story, funny parts.

Top 5 Comic Book Movies based on Special Effects
5.Man of Steel
4.TDK
3.Spiderman 2
2.Iron Man 3
1.The Avengers

Top 5 Comic Book Movie Villains
5.Green Goblin
4.Loki
3.Joker
2.Doc Ock
1.Magneto

The Top 3 Comic Book Movies of 2013
3.The wolverine
2. Thor 2
1.Iron Man 3
 

[Squaremaster316]

1. The Dark KnightThe quality standard to which all CBM's are measured.Prodigious acting from everyone,a complex, rock solid, whip-smart script,and a grand scale of epicness that transcends the genre.2. Batman BeginsA revolutionary game-changer that perfected the blueprint for origin films.3. The Dark Knight Rises:A climactic trilogy closer that does justice to numerous characters that were mishandled in other installments to the genre and curb stomps the trilogy curse for CBM's into the ground.4. X2The best Marvel film that managed to tell a compelling story with numerous characters.5. Superman 2: Donner Cut.Tells a great story featuring one of the best villains of the genre, and manages to infuse it with more dramatic heft than the average CBM6. First Class7. Scott Pilgrim8. Sin City9. X-Men10. V for Vendetta

[Jessie]

Ooo, I wanna play.

 

1. Scott Pilgrim

2. Avengers

3. Iron Man

4. Men in Black

5. TDK

6. Nausicaa

7. American Splendor

8. Sin City

9. Ghost World

10. Oblivion - This film is so flawed, but the production design is just beautiful.

 

I like all the Marvel stuff though, and it feels weird not having one of Rami's Spidey films.  Also, I'm totally ashamed to say I haven't seen Oldboy and Akira. Need to get on that.  And I haven't watched Blue is the Warmest Colour yet.

 

How could anyone have Scott Pilgrim at the top of the list?? It just screams shitty taste...

[Dark 33Legend of the Sith]

1.The Dark Knight

2.Batman

3.Superman

4.The Dark Knight Rises

5. Superman II

6. Spider-Man 2

7. Batman Begins

8. The Avengers

9. The Incredibles

10.Man of Steel

Edited December 19, 2013 by 33Legend

[tonytr87]

The Dark Knight - A+

Spider-man 2 - A

Batman Begins - A-

Superman - A-

X-men 2 - A-

Batman - A-

Kick-Ass - A-

Watchmen - A-

The Avengers - A-

The Dark Knight Rises - B+

 

Honorable Mentions: Iron Man, Spider-man, Batman Returns, Superman II, X-men: First Class 

Edited December 22, 2013 by tonytr87

[Omario]

1) The Dark Knight

2) The Dark Knight Rises

3) Batman Begins

4)The Avengers

5) Spiderman 2

6) Xmen First Class

7)Superman 2

8)Man of Steel

9)Xmen 2

10)thor

 

that wasn't as easy as i thought it would be. I made a similar list in another thread but this one is updated i guess.

Edited December 26, 2013 by Omario

[ddddeeee]

1. Batman Returns

2. Spider-Man 2

3. The Avengers

4. The Dark Knight

5. Batman Begins

6. Spider-Man

7. Hellboy II: The Golden Army

8. Thor

9. Iron Man

10. Batman 1989

[Punishment]

Looking forward to this Ed, and I know you put Iron Man 3 number 1 on your list

[The Stingray]

Updated.

 

1. Batman (1989)

2. Oldboy

3. Batman Begins

4. Batman Returns

5. Sin City

6. X2

7. The Avengers

8. The Crow

9. Watchmen

10. Superman Returns

[Jussslic]

How could anyone have Scott Pilgrim at the top of the list?? It just screams shitty taste...

 

Says you.  Taste is subjective.

 

Anyway, Scott Pilgrim is everything I look for in a comedy.  Witty, playful, uniquely shot and edited, heartfelt.  It's fine if it's not your taste, but that doesn't really make it shitty.

Edited December 31, 2013 by Jussslic

[#ED]

Looking forward to this Ed, and I know you put Iron Man 3 number 1 on your list

 

My list this year:

 

1. The Dark Knight

2. The Dark Knight Rises

3. Batman Begins

4. The Avengers

5. Spider-Man

6. Spider-Man 2

7. Man Of Steel

8. Iron Man

9. X-2

10. Batman

[ecstasy]

1. Avengers

2. Iron Man 1

3. Iron Man 3

4. Spider Man 1

5. Spider Man 2

6. Xmen 2

7. Xmen First Class

8. The Dark Knight

9. Thor

10. TDW

Edited January 3, 2014 by ECSTASY