Attack of the Fangirls: The 69 Greatest Ships of All Time | AKA The Best Film Romances EVA List | CLOSED

[baumer]

Just to expand on the Duckie/Andi thing...as @Valonqar mentioned, they were never romantically involved.  Duckie was in love with her but she always felt noting but friendship towards him.  He even did the right thing at the end and let her go to a reformed and more mature Blaine (the toaster) before hooking up with the hot blond.

[TalismanRing]

3 hours ago, Valonqar said:

 

Andie/Duckie didn't happen, though. It was always strictly unrequited love on his part. She was never interested. Sharon/Steve = kiss. Katniss/Gale = kiss. Bruce/Talia = sex. Bella/Jacob = kiss. Andie/Duckie = nothing romantic/sexual. He was friendzoned through and through. It's understandable why they are popular fanon but they've never been canon.

 

Andy/Duckie were requited and the endgame before the test audiences hated the ending and they re-shot it. Poor Duckie.

 

https://www.usatoday.com/story/entertainment/movies/2021/02/26/pretty-pink-anniversary-35-changed-ending-andie-duckie-blane/4551885001/
 

[Tower]

Can I include a polyamorous relationship as one entry?

[Valonqar]

Oh that's interesting about Pretty In Pink. Test audience sucks.

[TalismanRing]

21 hours ago, Valonqar said:

Oh that's interesting about Pretty In Pink. Test audience sucks.

 

Molly agreed with them - said the romantic chemistry just wasn't there.  Said it would have been different if they'd hired RDJ instead.

 

 

[Valonqar]

1 hour ago, TalismanRing said:

 

Molly agreed with them - said the romantic chemistry just wasn't there.  Said it would have been different if they'd hired RDJ instead.

 

 

 

Now we are talking!

 

I agree about romantic chemsitry. None on her part. I do understand why fans shipped the two but I can see that, from her POV as an actress, they were more like siblings. Now RDJ would be something but then it would be hard to explain how come she fell for Blane when RDJ was right there. 

[Eric Atreides]

Put in my final changes and edits. Behold, the greatest list ever created

 

CANON LIST OF FORTY
Rank	Pts	Movie	Pairing
1	10	The Addams Family (1991)	Gomez & Morticia
2	9	Wall-E (2008)	Wall-E & Eve
3	9	Superman (1978)	Clark Kent & Lois Lane
4	8	Call Me By Your Name (2017)	Elio & Oliver
5	8	Aladdin (1991)	Aladdin & Jasmine
6	8	Life is Beautiful (1997)	Guido & Dora
7	7	West Side Story (1961)	Tony & Maria
8	7	The Birdcage (1996)	Albert and Armond
9	7	Before Sunset (2004)	Jesse & Celine
10	7	The Matrix (1999)	Neo & Trinity
11	6	Beauty & The Beast (1946)	Belle & Beast
12	6	Little Women (2019)	Jo & Laurie
13	6	When Harry Met Sally (1989)	Harry & Sally
14	6	Brokeback Mountain (2005)	Jack & Ennis
15	6	If Beale Street Could Talk (2018)	Tish & Fonny
16	5	In the Mood for Love (2000)	Su & Chow
17	5	Enchanted (2007)	Giselle & Robert
18	5	Casablanca (1942)	Rick Blaine & Ilsa Lund
19	5	Who Framed Roger Rabbit?	Roger & Jessica Rabbit
20	5	Moonlight (2016)	Chiron & Kevin
21	4	The Apartment (1960)	C. C. & Fran
22	4	Rocky (1978)	Rocky & Adrian
23	4	Pretty Woman (1990)	Vivian & Edward
24	4	West Side Story (2021)	Bernardo & Anita
25	4	Brooklyn (2015)	Ellis & Tony
26	3	Portrait of a Lady on Fire (2019)	Marianne & Heloise
27	3	It Happened One Night (1934)	Peter & Ellie
28	3	Dune (2021)	Paul & Chani
29	3	A Star is Born (2018)	Jackson Maine & Ally
30	3	A Star is Born (1954)	Esther & Norman
31	2	Up (2009)	Carl & Ellie
32	2	La La Land (2016)	Sebastian & Mia
33	2	The Philadelphia Story (1940)	Dexter & Tracy
34	2	The Incredibles (2004)	Bob & Helen Parr
35	2	The Umbrellas of Cherbourg (1964)	Genevieve & Guy
36	1	Dirty Dancing (1987)	Baby & Johnny
37	1	The Bodyguard (1992)	Frank & Rachel
38	1	Splendor in the Grass (1961)	Deanie & Bud
39	1	The Big Sick (2017)	Kumail & Emily
40	1	Captain America: The First Avenger (2011)	Steve & Peggy

 

FANON LIST OF TWENTY
Rank	Pts	Movie	Pairing
1	5	The Spongebob Squarepants Movie (2004)	Spongebob & Squidward
2	4.5	Star Wars: The Force Awakens (2015)	Finn & Poe
3	4.5	X-Men: First Class (2011)	Professor Xavier & Magneto
4	4	Zootopia (2016)	Nick & Judy
5	4	Harry Potter (2001-2011)	Harry & Hermione
6	4	Star Trek (1979-2016)	Kirk & Spock
7	3.5	Captain America: The Winter Soldier (2014)	Steve & Sam
8	3.5	Thelma & Louise (1991)	Thelma & Louise
9	3.5	Mary Poppins (1964)	Mary & Bert
10	3.5	Follow That Bird (1985)	Bert & Ernie
11	3	Kung Fu Panda (2008)	Po & Tigress
12	3	Zootopia (2016)	Chief Bogo & Clawhauser
13	2.5	Beauty & The Beast (1991)	Lumiere & Cogsworth
14	2.5	Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice (2016)	Batman & Wonder Woman
15	2	Pokemon: The First Movie (1999)	Ash & Misty
16	2	Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse (2018)	Miles & Gwen
17	1.5	Spider-Man: No Way Home (2021)	Green Goblin & Doc Ock
18	1.5	101 Dalmatians (1961)	Horace & Jasper
19	1	Cruella (2021)	Cruella & Jasper
20	1	My Little Pony: The Movie (2017)	Rainbow Dash & Applejack

[Daxtreme]

This is it folks. Today's last chance to send lists!

 

Love is in the air 

[Valonqar]

Very excited to see who made the cut. Especially fanon list. Hopefully unveiling the list won't take too long. 

 

EDIT: I hope we do this for TV next year cause there's much more shipping opportunities especially for fanon. 

Edited February 12, 2022 by Valonqar

[Tower]

Not really into fanons, but here's my canon list (in spoilers because I specify the relationship that I'm voting for):

Spoiler

Rank	Film	Pairing	Actors
1	The Apartment	C.C. & Fran	Jack Lemon & Shirley Mcclaine
2	Doctor Zhivago	Yuri & Lara	Omar Sharif & Julie Christie
3	Her	Theodore & Samantha	Joaquin Phoenix & Scarlett Johansson
4	Vertigo	Scottie & Judy	James Stewart & Kim Novak
5	Amour	Georges & Anne	Jean Louis Trintignant &Emmanuelle Riva
6	A Star Is Born	Vicki & Norman	Judy Garland & James Mason
7	Monster	Aileen & Selby	Charlize Theron & Christina Ricci
8	The Red Shoes	Vicky & Julian	Moira Shearer & Marius Goring
9	Brief Encounter	Laura & Alec	Celia Johnson & Trevor Howard
10	Dances With Wolves	Dances With Wolves & Stands With A Fist	Kevin Costner & Mary Mcdonnell
11	Sense And Sensibility	Marianne & Brandon	Kate Winslet & Alan Rickman
12	Hobson's Choice	Maggie & William	Brenda De Banzie & John Mills
13	The Curious Case Of Benjamin Button	Benjamin & Daisy	Bradd Pitt & Cate Blanchett
14	North By Northwest	Roger & Eve	Cary Grant & Eva Saint Marie
15	Tess	Tess & Angel	Nastassja Kinski & Peter Firth
16	If Beale Street Could Talk	Tish & Alonzo	Kiki Layne & Stephan James
17	Notorious	Devlin & Alicia	Cary Grant & Ingrid Bergman
18	Casino Royale	James & Vesper	Pierce Brosnan & Eva Green
19	The Fly	Seth & Veronica	Jeff Goldblum & Geena Davis
20	A Star Is Born	Ally & Jack	Lady Gaga & Bradley Cooper
21	The Bourne Identity	Jason & Marie	Matt Damon & Franka Potente
22	Sense And Sensibility	Elinor & Edward	Emma Thompson & Hugh Grant
23	The Illusionist	Eisenheim & Sophie	Edward Norton & Jessica Biel
24	Edward Scissorhands	Edward & Kim	Johnny Depp & Winona Ryder
25	Professor Marston & The Wonder Women	William & Elisabeth & Olive	Luke Evans & Rebecca Hall & Bella Heathcote
26	The Age Of Innocence	Newland & Ellen	Daniel Day Lewis & Michelle Pfeiffer
27	Portrait Of A Lady On Fire	Marianne & Heloise	Noemie Merlant & Adele Haenel
28	Batman Returns	Bruce & Selina	Michael Keaton & Michelle Pfeiffer
29	Laura	Laura & Mark	Gene Tierney & Dana Andrews
30	Pride & Prejudice	Elizabeth & Mr. Darcy	Keira Knightley & Matthew Macfadyen
31	Notting Hill	William & Anna	Hugh Grant & Julia Roberts
32	An American Werewolf In Paris	David & Alex	David Naughton & Jenny Agutter
33	Baby Driver	Baby & Debora	Ansel Elgort & Lilly James
34	Amelie	Amelie & Nino	Audrey Tautou & Mathieu Kassovitz
35	Who Framed Roger Rabbit	Roger & Jessica	Charles Fleischer & (3 different women)
36	Annie Hall	Alvin & Annie	Woody Allen & Diane Keaton
37	Batman: Mask Of The Phantasm	Batman & Andrea	Kevin Conroy & Dana Delany
38	Witness	John & Rachel	Harrison Ford & Kelly Mcgillis
39	Groundhog Day	Phil & Rita	Bill Murray & Andie Macdowell
40	Wall E	Wall E & EVE	Ben Burtt & Elissa Knight

 

[titanic2187]

I think I will sit this one out, collecting character names from the movie is a painful process. All in my head was jack and rose

[YM!]

On 1/4/2022 at 1:43 PM, Eric Poirot said:

FYC For Fanon

 

 

They were in a movie together, it counts.

 

[YM!]

Dropping my fanon list first, half are real and half are BS, I’ll let y’all decide which is which:

 

1. Spongebob x Squidward - The Spongebob Squarepants Movie

2. Batman x Joker - The Lego Movie franchise

3. Hermoine x Harry - Harry Potter

4. Rapunzel x Cassandra - Tangled Before Ever After 

5. Magneto x Xavier - X-Men

6. Nick x Judy - Zootopia

7. Dale x Saul - Pineapple Express

8. Seth x Jay - This is the End

9. Guy x Buddy - Free Guy

10. Satan x Mr Hat - South Park Bigger Longer and Uncut

11. Eggman x assistant - Sonic The Hedgehog

12. Peter 2 x Peter 3 - Spider-Man: No Way Home

13. Mike x The Mafia Bear that eat and kills him at the end - Sing

14. Peter x Karen - MCU Spider-Man 

15. Tony x Alcohol x Bad Decisions x Escaping Responsibility - MCU (the hottest foursome)

16. Venom x Eddie - Venom series 

17. Ant Man x Thanos - MCU

18. ET x Government - ET

19. Pixar x Bob Chapek - Luca, Soul

20. Jackie Legs x Jessie - Kangaroo Jack

 

[YM!]

Spoiler

1. Jack x Rose - Titantic
2. Jack x Ally - A Star is Born
3. Neo x Trinity - The Matrix series
4. Belle x Beast - Beauty and The Beast
5. Shrek x Fiona - Shrek series 
6. Rapunzel x Eugene - Tangled
7. Tish x Fonny - If Beale Street Could Talk
8. Steve x Peggy - MCU
9. Wall-E x EVE - Wall-E
10. Jo x Laurie - Little Women
11. Chiron x Kevin - Moonlight
12. Rachel x Nick - Crazy Rich Asians
13. Clark Kent x Lois Lane - Superman
14. Jamal x Latika - Slumdog Millionaire
15. Howl x Sophie - Howl’s Moving Castle
16. Hodaka x Hini - Weathering with You
17. Aragon x Arwen - Lord of The Rings
18. Jasmine x Aladdin - Aladdin
19. Giselle x Robert - Enchanted
20. Peter x Mary Jane - Raimi Spider-Man 
21. Diana x Steve - Wonder Woman 
22. Bob x Helen - The Incredibles
23. Gomez x Morticia - The Addams Family
24. Rocky x Adrien - Rocky
25. Roger Rabbit x Jessica Rabbit - Who Framed Roger Rabbit
26. John x Jane - Mr and Mrs Smith
27. Elizabeth x Will - Pirates of the Caribbean 
28. Katniss x Peeta - The Hunger Games
29. Leia x Solo - Star Wars
30. Bruce Wayne x Selina Kyle - Batman Returns
31. Benny x Nina - In The Heights
32. Woody x Bo - Toy Story
33. Jake x Neytiri - Avatar
34. Indiana Jones x Marion - Raiders of The Lost Ark
35. Fred x Charlotte - Long Shot
36. Megamind x Roxeanne - Megamind 
37. Troy x Gabriella - High School Musical
38. Gary x Mary - The Muppets
39. Makkari x Druig - Eternals
40. Bella x Edward - Twilight series (I’m drawing blanks y’all)

 

[Valonqar]

A day before Valentine's and the Ship List, I'd like to share some of my favorite romantic scenes ever:

 

 

My all time favorite, unsurpassed, just perfection - fight-dance choreography to die for, magnificent score, one of the best ever, Barbossa's character arc, good use of slo mo, Ragetti and Pintel reaction, just perfect perfect:

 

 

The dyad in the Force. There are so many Dyad Force Bond scenes to choose from, but the one that connected with me the most is passing of the lightsaber through the Force. It's sexy, badass and few steps above the usual Jedi/Sith dynamic:

 

 

The granddaddy of all sexy fights, they don't make them like this anymore which is why it will be even more cherished:

 

 

They didn't become canon but we all wished they did:

 

 

Though I'm Flying Jack and/or nude painting/To the stars would be more obvious choices, this scene is the power of true love:

 

 

Neo's is the One cause Trinity loves him:

 

 

Jakes takes his first flight on his ikran and Neytiri joins. The rest is pure movie magic:

 

 

I came across the time for you, Sarah. And then they made the savior of the world (that part isn't in the video, don't worry):

 

 

Nobody puts Baby in the corner:

 

 

It's all about reaction:

 

 

Rhett bids $150 in gold on Mrs Charles Hamilton who just wants to dance and dance:

 

 

Elephant medley:

 

 

[lorddemaxus]

My list. Kinda random order and a bit of recency bias involved I guess.

1. Robert and Francesca - Bridges of Madison County
2. Newland and Ellen - Age of Innocence
3. The Tramp and blind girl - City Lights
4. Maria and Tony - West Side Story (2021)
5. Angahard and Mr Gruyfford - How Green Was My Valley
6. Marie and George - Hereafter
7. Neo and Trinity - Matrix
8. Su li-zhen and Chow mo-wan - In the Mood for Love
9. Jerry and Dorothy - Jerry Maguire
10. Judy and Howard - What's up Doc?
11. Esther and Norman - A Star is Born (1954)
12. Bond and Vespa - Casino Royale
13. Maria and Tony - West Side Story (1961)
14. Keechie and Bowie - They Live by Night
15. Woodcock and Alma - Phantom Thread
16. Suri and Bobby - Rab Ne Da Jodi 
17. Indiana Jones and Marion - Raiders of the Lost Ark
18. Erica and Harry - Something's Gotta Give
19. Alfred and Klara - Shop Around the Corner
20. Barbara and Catcher - Down with Love
21. Dracula and Elisabeta - Dracula 1992
22. Isabel and Rusty - Oceans 12
23. Barry and Lena - Punch Drunk Love
24. Benjamin and Daisy - Benjamin Button
25. Jenny and Scott - Starman
26. Johnny Guitar and Vienna - Johnny Guitar
27. Alex and Kate - The Lake House
28. Aadi and Tara - Oh Kadhal Kanmani
29. Jack and Karen - Out of Sight
30. Jiro and Naoko - The Wind Rises
31. Jack and Kate - The Family Man
32. Raj and Simran - Dilwale Dulhania Le Jayenge
33. Danny and Beatrice - Oceans 11
34. Elizabeth and Will - POTC
35. Joe and Kathleen - You've Got Mail
36. Bronco Billy and Antionete - Bronco Billy
37. Graham and Amanda - The Holiday
38. Charlie and Yvonne - It Could Happen to You
39. Georges and Brontes - Green Card
40. Pete and Dorinda - Always
41. Joe and Patricia - Joe vs the Volcano

 

[Spidey Freak]

On 2/12/2022 at 7:54 AM, Daxtreme said:

This is it folks. Today's last chance to send lists!

 

Love is in the air 

 

...I mistook this as being posted just a few hours back so just sent in my lists to @Cap Hope they count! 😬

 

Didn't realize this but I have 2 ships in my Top 10 featuring a character played by Claire Danes. Her underrated impact!

 

Edited February 15, 2022 by Spidey Freak