BOT's Top 100 Comic Book Movies of All Time- Deadline: January 9th, 2025!

[YM!]

 

Hey all, as times grow dark - sometimes we need a good hero to save us from the doldrums of life. So, since it’s been a while since we did a comic book movie countdown, I decided to help kick it into high gear. We're going faster, higher, ladies and gents and non-binary friends! You what to know how I'll give us some further scarring, this will not be a mere top 50 but a full-on top 100 list! Yep, that is right! We are in the Endgame now!!!! And to further add some chaos to our lives, not just our traditional superhero movies count but any movies that came from comic books, graphic novels, comic strips and manga!
 
Rules for ballots:
 

• All movies must be over 40 minutes long. Theatrical, streaming or DTV doesn’t matter so long as the 40-minute criteria is met.
• All movies must originate from either comic books, graphic novels, comic strips or manga - so anywhere from your Marvel and DC movies, Akira, Addams Family, Diary of a Wimpy Kid and Old. Original movies inspired by superhero movies such as Unbreakable or Megamind sadly are ineligble.
• Movies released in 2024 are eligible if they debuted on or before November 10th, 2024, so Joker bros, WebHive and Deadpool crew rejoice as your movies are fair game. I wanted it to be a bit later but I realized with the holidays, it would be unfair to force it for Kraven The Hunter with how busy everyone is.
• Include both the title and release year of each movie on the ballot.
• DM your submissions, I will start to take submissions sometime on Saturday, November 16th, 2024 so feel free to start getting the list ready now.
• No cheating: Users suspected of being alts of other users will be reported. This has happened with some lists in the past.
• Once your ballot is sent, revisions are not able to be done. (Actually, going to be a bit lenient on this, you get one revision a person, but you must give me the revision within 48 hours of sending me your list originally.)
• Deadline is January 9th, 2025! So, you want to get nuts? C'mon! Let's get nuts!

 

Here is 2019's list for further references.

How the lists are scored based uses the lord and savior and kung fu master @The Panda as well as our friend @cannastop's method for configuring lists for both ease and it is a really good system!

For lists containing 100 movies: 
#1: 10 points
#2-5: 9 points
#6-10: 8 points
#11-15: 6 points
#16-25: 5 points
#26-35: 4 points
#36-50: 3 points
#51-75: 2 points
#76-100: 1 point
 
For lists containing 50-99 movies:
#1: 10 points
#2-5: 9 points
#6-10: 8 points
#11-15: 5 points
#16-20: 4 points
#21-30: 3 points
#31-40: 2 points
#41+: 1 point
 
For lists containing less than 50 movies:
#1: 10 points
#2-5: 9 points
#6-10: 8 points
#11-15: 4 points
#16-25: 2 poitns
#25+: 1 point
 

 

Edited November 15 by YM!

[cannastop]

For your consideration:

[YM!]

21C@35MM-18@3jp@4815162342@75Live@8wombi7@A Star is Orm@abra@abracadabra1998@AdrianL@Alex SciChannel@Alexdube@Amadeus@Anduin@AndyK@AndyLL@AnotherDayAnotherDollar@A Marvel Fanboy@A Star is Orm@a2k@aabattery@Agafin@AJG@ando@AN9815@Arlborn@ACSlater@andersonhoran@AnDr3s@Andreas@AniNate@Aristis@Ash Skywalker@Asyulus@Avatree@BadOlCatSylvester@Barnack@ban1o@belblazer@BestPicturePlutoNash@Blipsy@Blaze Heatnix@bleachella@BoxOfficeFangrl@Box Office Hit@Boxofficerules@BoxOfficeZ@baumer@BeastByTheBay@Biggestgeekever@Bigscrubnus@Brandon Gray@Borf the Borf@Bordlove@Borobudur@Bruce@BruiseCruise@B J@bcf26@BourneFan #1@Black Hawk@Black Panther@Blackout@Brainbug@Caboose@Carlangonz@cannastop@CaptNathanBrittles@catlover@Caesar@Caylu@cdsacken@Cedarpoint1111@cedec0@CJohn@Chaz@Cheddar Please@ChipDerby@cheesypoofs@Claudio@Coldbird@Coneilg93@Claire of Themyscira@Cmasterclay@cmbbox2390@Cap@Captain Craig@Cappoedameron@CrashBandicoot81@cruelintentionsisgoated@Cruel Summer@cookie@CoolioD1@CoolK@cax16@ChD@Catty@Chewy@cdsacken@DAJK@Dandeak2000@Danhjpn@DAR@darkelf@Darth Lehnsherr@Daxtreme@datpepper@Dbui8743@DC Rich@ddddeeee@DeeCee@Deep Wang@Deja23@DlAMONDZ@Doffy@Dominic Draper@Dragoncaine@druv10@Djsoke@DlAMONDZ@DMan7@DoctorWho@Dragon@dudalb@Durden@#ED@EarlyDeadlinePredictions@ecstasy@Eevin@efialtes76@El Gato@el sid@El Squibbonator@Elessar@elcaballero@ElsaRoc@Empire@Eric the Lion@Essem@Ethan Edwards@Ethan Hunt@european1992@excel1@exomassey@expensiveho@Ezen Baklattan@fabiopazzo2@Factcheck@Fancyarcher@FantasticBeasts@filmlover@filmnerdjamie@FilmFincher@Finnick@Firepower@Fielding@Flamengo81@fmpro@franfar@Fullbuster@Galactic Specter@Gamora@Gavin Feng@George Parr@Grebacio@Giesi@Goffe@Godzilla@Gokai Red@Goldenhour36@Gopher@GOXOG@Grebacio@grey ghost@grim22@Hades@harrisonisdead@Hatebox@Heretic@HeyMast@HesAPooka@Hilpkioy@HouseOfTheSun@Horner@hw64@IcarusReborn@IceFire9yt@IdahoJacket@iHeartJames@imbruglia@In XXR We Trust@Inceptionzq@Infernus@infamous5445@interiorgatordecorator@Ipickthiswhiterose@IronJimbo@Issac Newton@Ithil@Jack Nevada@Jake Gittes@Jake Lockley@James@Jamiem@Jandrew@Jason@Jay Beezy@Jayhawk the Hutt@jedijake@Jeight@jb007@JB33@Jiffy@Jim Shorts@JJ-8@jking123@Joel M@John Marston@john2000@John2015@johnfalkon@Johnny Tran@JonahVex@John Rambo@Julian1410@Juby@JustLurking@JWR@K1stpierre@Kalo@katnisscinnaplex@kayumanggi@kitik@KJsooner@Krissykins@Keanu@Knights of Ren@KP1025@krla@Kvikk Lunsj@lab276@Last Man Standing@Ledmonkey96@LegendaryBen@Legion By Night@LeoC@Lestranger@Liiviig 1998@lilmac@Lion Roar@ListenHunnyUrOver@LinksterAC@LonePirate@longleo90@lorddemaxus@lor15@Lothar@Lucas@LPLC@LVB@M37@m3racer123@Macleod@Madhuvan@MadGoose@Maggie@Mango@Mankatha@Manny G@Marek the Jedi@marveldcfox@MCKillswitch123@Marcos12@Mau@Mekanos@Menor Reborn@MG10@Michael Gary Scott@mikeymichael@MikeQ@Minnale101@misafeco@mmacader@Mojoguy@Momori@Moses@Morieris@MovieMan89@motionpic05@MOVIEGUY@Movie nerd@Movies4Life@MrGlass2@MrGamer@MrFanaticGuy34@MrPink@Mr Terrific@Ms Lady Hawk@Mulder@MyMovieCanBeatUpYourMovie@NamakFiskKa@Napoleon@narniadis@NCsoft@nerves@Nero@nevermore@newbie BO buff@nghtvsn@nguyenkhoi282@nick64@Nikostar@Noctis@Noiret Jak@noknobs@Noodlebug@Notthereverseflash24@Nova@Nublar7@Ohana@Olive@Omario@oMeriMombatti@Omni@OncomingStorm93@Orestes@Ozymandias@parkerthegreat@PanaMovie@PDC1987@peludo@PenguinHyphy@pepsa@PhilipJ2001@picores@Pinacolada@Plain Old Tele@PlatnumRoyce@PKMLover@PNF2187@Porthos@porginchina@Potiki@poweranimals@Purple Minion@Pypa94@Quigley@RamblinRed@raulbalarezo@RealLyre@Rebeccas@reddevil19@Reddroast@redfirebird2008@RexTheMan14@RichWS@ringedmortality@RJ 95@RobrtmanAStarWarsReference@RobinHood26@Ronin46@romeross@Rorschach@Royce@RRA@RthMav@rukaio101@Ryan Reynolds@Ryaner90@Samwise the Brave@Sandro Mazzola@Saul Goodman@Sam@ScareLol@SchumacherFTW@scoobysaurus@setna@Seto Kaiba@seduh7@Seth Irskens@sfran43@Shanks@Shawn@Sheikh@Simionski@Sindreee@Sir Tiki@Skim Beeble@SLAM!@snitch@snarkmachine@SnokesLegs@solaris@SoSaysI@Sophie@SpiderByte@Spidey Freak@Starphanluke@Steele131@stephanos13@Stewart@Sue Denim@TalismanRing@Talkie@Taruseth@tawasal@TerwillikerInst@terrestrial@TestPattern@That One Guy@ThatWaluigiDude@TheDarkKnightOfSteel@The Dark Alfred@The Dark Rock@The Fast and the Furiosa@The Horror of Lucas Films@The GOAT@The Panda@The Stingray@TheDude391@ThePhasmid@Thomas Beck@ThomasNicole@THUNDER BIRD@TigerPaw@TiagoRodrigues@Tinalera@titanic2187@TLK@TMP@Tokugennumataka@Torontofan@Tower@TwoMisfits@Valonqar@vale9001@Vanilla@VanillaSkies@vc2002@ViewerAnon@ViktorLosAngeles@Wadey Wilsoney@Walt Disney@Warhorse@watcher1232@water@Water Bottle@WayneBorg@Webslinger@WeThrones@WeneedtotalkaboutKevin@wildphantom@WittyUsername@Wonder89@WorkingonaName@Wormow@Wrath@WrathOfHan@Xavier@Xillix@xieh tie@XO21@Yandereprime101189@YLF@YM!@YSLDC@ZackM@Zakiyyah6@ZeeSoh@Zeiden16 @screambaby@Kyriacos@Sckathian@Willowra@TheFlatLannister@Clear Sky Master@todos@Sampath Kumar@oenri@StreamBO@danziger@froztking@UKBoxOffice@GOGODanca@adaros@Doffy@nerves@Flip@CaptNathanBrittles

@SLAM! @emoviefan@Bob Train @Eric Owns Mickey Mouse

 

•  

[grey ghost]

Never forget.

 

 

Edited November 15 by grey ghost

[grey ghost]

FYC

 

 

 

 

Edited November 15 by grey ghost

[Tower]

Some not obvious (not Marvel or DC superhero) FYC:

Snowpiercer

The Death Of Stalin

Nausicaa Of The Valley Of The Wind

Kingsman: The Secret Service

Ghost In The Shell

Road To Perdition

V For Vendetta

Edited November 15 by Tower

[Tower]

1 hour ago, grey ghost said:

FYC

 

 

 

Edge Of Tomorrow is based on a light novel, which I don't think is eligible. @YM!, can you make it clear? Because if it is eligible it will be on my list.

[YM!]

5 minutes ago, Tower said:

Edge Of Tomorrow is based on a light novel, which I don't think is eligible. @YM!, can you make it clear? Because if it is eligible it will be on my list.

Edge of Tomorrow was eligible in 2019, so I will count it as eligible here too.

[Flip]

Hopefully this is #1:

 

[Reddroast]

 

[Human]

I knew watching 116 Detective Comics Comics movies would come back to help me.

[YM!]

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_films_based_on_comic_strips

 

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_films_based_on_comics

 

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_films_based_on_manga

 

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_films_based_on_French-language_comics

 

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_films_based_on_English-language_comics

 

For those who are wondering about movie eligibility - all of these count. As for the graphic novel question, the book should follow the comic-book/manga format, so for instance Old and Nimona would count because their graphic novels it was based on followed this pattern. As for the case of Wimpy Kid and Captain Underpants if memory serves me correctly, pages would mostly be writing with an illustration on the bottom. I'm starting to lean against excluding them, but if someone can make the case for them, I will listen.

Edited November 15 by YM!

[YM!]

For your consideration:

 

 

 

 

 

 

[Jake Gittes]

Time to finally watch Blue Is the Warmest Color.

[The Panda]

1.      Oldboy

2.      Persepolis

3.      Addams Family Values

4.      Batman (1966)

5.      Akira

6.      Blue is the Warmest Color

7.      Superman (1978)

8.      Nausicaa of the Valley of the Wind

9.      Kill Bill Vol. 1

10.   The Death of Stalin

11.   Batman Returns

12.   Hulk (2003)

13.   Snowpiercer

14.   The Diary of a Teenage Girl

15.   Road to Perdition

16.   Spider-Man 2

17.   Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3

18.   Ghost World

19.   Whisper of the Heart

20.   The Rocketeer

21.   Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse

22.   A History of Violence

23.   Logan

24.   Black Panther

25.   The Peanuts Movie

26.   Spider-Man

27.   The Addams Family

28.   Ghost Rider

29.   Stardust

30.   Iron Man 3

31.   Blade II

32.   The Dark Knight

33.   Kill Bill: Vol. 2

34.   Edge of Tomorrow

35.   The Crow

36.   Hellboy II: The Golden Army

37.   Superman Returns

38.   Eternals

39.   DuckTales: The Movie – Treasure of the Lost Lamp

40.   Batman Begins

41.   Annie (1982)

42.   Kingsman: The Secret Service

43.   Spider-Man 3

44.   Men in Black

45.   Unbreakable

46.   Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2

47.   Guardians of the Galaxy

48.   Nimona

49.   Shang-Chi and the Legend of the Ten Rings

50.   I Kill Giants

[YM!]

8 minutes ago, The Panda said:

1.      Oldboy

2.      Persepolis

3.      Addams Family Values

4.      Batman (1966)

5.      Akira

6.      Blue is the Warmest Color

7.      Superman (1978)

8.      Nausicaa of the Valley of the Wind

9.      Kill Bill Vol. 1

10.   The Death of Stalin

11.   Batman Returns

12.   Hulk (2003)

13.   Snowpiercer

14.   The Diary of a Teenage Girl

15.   Road to Perdition

16.   Spider-Man 2

17.   Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3

18.   Ghost World

19.   Whisper of the Heart

20.   The Rocketeer

21.   Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse

22.   A History of Violence

23.   Logan

24.   Black Panther

25.   The Peanuts Movie

26.   Spider-Man

27.   The Addams Family

28.   Ghost Rider

29.   Stardust

30.   Iron Man 3

31.   Blade II

32.   The Dark Knight

33.   Kill Bill: Vol. 2

34.   Edge of Tomorrow

35.   The Crow

36.   Hellboy II: The Golden Army

37.   Superman Returns

38.   Eternals

39.   DuckTales: The Movie – Treasure of the Lost Lamp

40.   Batman Begins

41.   Annie (1982)

42.   Kingsman: The Secret Service

43.   Spider-Man 3

44.   Men in Black

45.   Unbreakable

46.   Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2

47.   Guardians of the Galaxy

48.   Nimona

49.   Shang-Chi and the Legend of the Ten Rings

50.   I Kill Giants

Hey, just letting you know both Unbreakable and Kill Bill are ineligible as both are original films. The movie must originate from comic books, graphic novels, manga or comic strips.

[cannastop]

27 minutes ago, YM! said:

Hey, just letting you know both Unbreakable and Kill Bill are ineligible as both are original films. The movie must originate from comic books, graphic novels, manga or comic strips.

yeah all of those movies have similarities to certain comic book works but they're not strictly adaptations of anything in particular.

[TalismanRing]

Lists to help people (me) out

 

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_films_based_on_English-language_comics

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_films_based_on_manga

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_films_based_on_French-language_comics

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_films_based_on_comics (Other languages)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_films_based_on_comic_strips

 

Edited November 15 by TalismanRing

[baumer]

Does Watchmen count?

[cannastop]

5 hours ago, baumer said:

Does Watchmen count?

Yes it does.