Jump to content
Impact

CAYOM Year 3-Oscar Tiebreakers *All cats picked except actress and art direction, check page 3*

    Recommended Posts

    Note: Voting is over in all of them except actress and art direction, check page 3.

    Okay here we go! I will have the for sure noms followed by the tiebreakers that we rank here.

    Picture:

    Noms:

    Black as Night

    Coming Storm

    Genesis

    Tiebreaker! 2 will move on!

    Dodge City

    Fatal Rendezvous

    The Summer Story

    The Morrow II

    Director:

    Noms:

    PT Anderson for Black as Night

    The Coen Brothers for Dodge City

    Steven Daldry for The Coming Storm

    Fernando Meirelles for El Libertador

    Christopher Nolan for Summer Story

    No tiebreaker needed!

    Best Actor:

    Noms:

    Paul Bettany for The Coming Storm

    Leonardo DiCaprio for Black as Night

    Robert Downey Jr. for Fatal Rendezvous

    Ben Foster for The Summer Story

    Tiebreaker! Rank all 3! 1 will move on:

    Colin Firth for Dead in the House

    Tom Cruise for Leitmotif

    Gary Oldman for Thane of the Flies

    Best Actress:

    Noms:

    Claire Forlani for Black as Night

    Chloe Mortez for Nadia: A Perfect 10

    Melissa Leo for Into the Breach

    Meryl Streep for Love in Poitiers

    Tiebreaker! Rank both, 1 will move on:

    Felicity Huffman for Dead in the House

    Saoirse Ronan for Divergent

    Best Supporting Actor:

    Noms:

    Aaron Eckheart for Fatal Rendezvous

    Frank Langella for Black as Night

    Tiebreaker! Rank all 4, 3 will move on:

    Ben Barnes for The Coming Storm

    Tommy Lee Jones for Dodge City

    Michael Sheen for Love in Poitiers

    Tom Hanks for Summer Story

    Best Supporting Actress:

    Noms:

    Glenn Close for Love in Poitiers

    Michelle Monaghan for Fatal Rendezvous

    Mila Kunis for The Summer Story

    Tilda Swinton for Thane of the Flies

    Olivia Wilde for Genesis

    No tiebreaker needed!

    Best Original Screenplay:

    Noms:

    Black as Night

    Dodge City

    Genesis

    The Summer Story

    Tiebreaker! Rank both, 1 will move on:

    The Coming Storm

    El Libertador

    Best Adapted Screenplay:

    Noms:

    Divergent

    Fatal Rendezvous

    Red Rabbit

    The Morrow II

    Thane of the Flies

    No tiebreaker needed!

    Best Ensemble:

    Noms:

    Black as Night

    The Coming Storm

    Tiebreaker! rank all 4, 3 will move on:

    Dodge City

    Love in Poitiers

    Genesis

    Fatal Rendezvous

    Best Animated Feature:

    Noms:

    Bobby

    Karate Kong

    Tiebreaker! Rank all of them, 3 will move on!

    Ag3nts

    Animal Farm

    Frosty the Snowman

    Sam and Max hit the Road

    Blue Heart

    Best Cinematography:

    Noms:

    Black as Night

    The Coming Storm

    Dodge City

    Genesis

    Red Rabbit

    No tiebreaker needed!

    Best Art Direction:

    Noms:

    The Comming Storm

    El Libertador

    Genesis

    Mega tiebreaker! 2 will move on! Rank 4 of them. (not going to rank all)

    Black as Night

    Dodge City

    Gregor the Overlander

    Love in Poiters

    Nadia: A Perfect 10

    Thane of the Flies

    Wrinkle in Time

    Man and his Hat

    Divergent

    Summer Story

    Best Costumes:

    Noms:

    Black as Night

    The Coming Storm

    Dodge City

    Fable

    Thane of the Flies

    No tiebreaker needed!

    Best Makeup:

    Noms:

    Black as Night

    Fable

    Genesis

    Another mega tiebreaker! Rank 4-2 will move on!

    Bartimaeus and the Golem's Eye

    SpellForce: Breath of Winter

    Love in Poitiers

    Into the Breach

    Planeswalkers

    Best Score:

    Noms:

    Black as Night-Angelo Badalamenti

    Genesis-James Newton Howard

    Leitmotif-Trent Reznor and Atticus Ross

    Red Rabbit-Michael Nyman

    Tiebreaker! Rank all 3, 1 will move on:

    The Coming Storm-Alberto Iglesias

    Dodge City-Marco Belltrami

    Planeswalkers-Howard Shore

    Best Song:

    Noms:

    "Winter Paradise" from Frosty the Snowman

    "The Coming Storm" from The Coming Storm

    "Our Moment" from Letifmotiff

    "Enchanted Journey" from Planeswalkers

    "They Live" from 8AM

    No tiebreaker!

    Best Film Editing:

    Noms:

    Black as Night

    Prodigy

    Red Rabbit

    Summer Story

    Tiebreaker! Rank both! 1 will move on.

    Fatal Rendezvous

    Genesis

    Best Sound:

    Noms:

    Dodge City

    Fable

    Genesis

    Prodigy

    Red Rabbit

    No tiebreaker needed!

    Best Sound Editing:

    Noms:

    The Coming Storm

    Dodge City

    Genesis

    Red Rabbit

    Tiebreaker! Rank both, 1 will move on!

    Divergent

    Prodigy

    Best Visual Effects:

    Bartimaeus and the Golem's Eye

    The Coming Storm

    Genesis

    SpellForce: Breath of Winter

    Tiebreaker! Rank all 3, 1 will move on!

    Divergent

    The Morrow II

    Voyage to Atlantis

    Best Use of Action:

    Noms:

    8AM 4

    The Morrow II 4

    Vault Break 4

    Tiebreaker! Rank 4, 2 will move on!

    The Coming Storm

    Divergent

    Fable

    Genesis

    Wolves of the Deep

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Mine!:

    Picture:

    Noms:

    1. Dodge City

    2. Fatal Rendezvous

    4. The Summer Story

    3. The Morrow II

    Best Actor:

    1. Colin Firth for Dead in the House

    2. Tom Cruise for Leitmotif

    3. Gary Oldman for Thane of the Flies

    Best Actress:

    1. Felicity Huffman for Dead in the House

    2. Saoirse Ronan for Divergent

    Best Supporting Actor:

    2. Ben Barnes for The Coming Storm

    1. Tommy Lee Jones for Dodge City

    3. Michael Sheen for Love in Poitiers

    4. Tom Hanks for Summer Story

    Best Original Screenplay:

    1. The Coming Storm

    2. El Libertador

    Best Ensemble:

    1. Dodge City

    2. Love in Poitiers

    4. Genesis

    3. Fatal Rendezvous

    Best Animated Feature:

    1. Ag3nts

    3. Animal Farm

    2. Frosty the Snowman

    4. Sam and Max hit the Road

    5. Blue Heart

    Best Art Direction:

    2. Black as Night

    1. Dodge City

    4. Nadia: A Perfect 10

    3. Wrinkle in Time

    Best Makeup:

    1. Bartimaeus and the Golem's Eye

    2. SpellForce: Breath of Winter

    4. Love in Poitiers

    3. Planeswalkers

    Best Score:

    2. The Coming Storm-Alberto Iglesias

    1. Dodge City-Marco Belltrami

    3. Planeswalkers-Howard Shore

    Best Film Editing:

    1. Fatal Rendezvous

    2. Genesis

    Best Sound Editing

    2. Divergent

    1. Prodigy

    Best Visual Effects:

    3. Divergent

    2, The Morrow II

    1. Voyage to Atlantis

    Best Use of Action:

    3. Divergent

    4. Fable

    2. Genesis

    1. Wolves of the Deep

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Picture:1. The Summer Story2. Dodge City3. The Morrow II4. Fatal RendezvousBest Actor:1. Gary Oldman for Thane of the Flies2. Tom Cruise for Leitmotif3. Colin Firth for Dead in the HouseBest Actress:1. Felicity Huffman for Dead in the House2. Saoirse Ronan for Divergent.Best Supporting Actor:1. Ben Barnes for The Coming Storm2. Michael Sheen for Love in Poitiers3. Tommy Lee Jones for Dodge City4. Tom Hanks for Summer SotryBest Original Screenplay:1. The Coming Storm2. El LibertadorBest Ensemble:1. Love in Poitiers2. Genesis3. Dodge City4. Fatal RendezvousBest Animated Feature:1. Frosty the Snowman2. Animal Farm3. Ag3nts4. Sam and Max hit the Road5. Blue HeartBest Art Direction:1. Love in Poitiers2. Thane of the Flies3. Divergent4. Gregor the OverlanderBest Makeup:1. Love in Poitiers2. Bartimaeus and the Golem's Eye3. Planeswalkers4. SpellForce: Breath of WinterBest Score:1. The Coming Storm - Alberto Iglesias2. Planeswalker - Howard Shore3. Marco Belltrami - Dodge CityBest Film Editing:1. Genesis2. Fatal RendezvousBest Sound Editing:1. Divergent2. ProdigyBest Visual Effects:1. Divergent2. The Morrow II3. Voyage to AtlantisBest Use of Action:1. The Coming Storm2. Divergent3. Genesis4. Wolves of the Deep

    Edited by riczhang
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Picture:1. Fatal Rendezvous2. The Morrow II3. The Summer Story4. Dodge CityBest Actor:1. Colin Firth for Dead in the House2. Gary Oldman for Thane of the Flies3. Tom Cruise for LeitmotifBest Actress:1. Felicity Huffman for Dead in the House2. Saoirse Ronan for DivergentBest Supporting Actor:1. Tommy Lee Jones for Dodge City2. Michael Sheen for Love in Poitiers3. Tom Hanks for Summer Story4. Ben Barnes for The Coming StormBest Original Screenplay:1. El Libertador2. The Coming StormBest Ensemble:1. Fatal Rendezvous2. Dodge City3. Love in Poitiers4. GenesisBest Animated Feature:1. Blue Heart2. Sam and Max hit the Road3. Animal Farm4. Ag3nts5. Frosty the SnowmanBest Art Direction:1. Love in Poiters 2. Thane of the Flies3. Dodge City4. Gregor the OverlanderBest Makeup:1. SpellForce: Breath of Winter2. Love in Poitiers3. Into the Breach4. Bartimaeus and the Golem's EyeBest Score:1. Dodge City-Marco Belltrami2. The Coming Storm-Alberto Iglesias3. Planeswalkers-Howard ShoreBest Film Editing:1. Fatal Rendezvous2. GenesisBest Sound Editing:1. Prodigy2. DivergentBest Visual Effects:1. The Morrow II2. Voyage to Atlantis3. DivergentBest Use of Action:1. Wolves of the Deep2. Fable3. The Coming Storm4. Genesis

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Some nomination counts:Black as Night- 12 nominations, +1 possibleThe Coming Storm- 10 nominations, +4 possibleGenesis- 10 nominations, +3 possibleDodge City- 6 nominations, +5 possibleRed Rabbit- 6 nominationsThe Summer Story- 5 nominations, +3 possibleFatal Rendezvous- 4 nominations, +3 possibleGO AWAY GENESIS!!!!!! Man, my opinion of that film is just decreasing more and more.

    Edited by 4815162342
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    I don't think we've ever had (at least since I've been playing) a year where we need two films from the tie-breaker to make it into BP. We've always had either all 5 picks straight out or 4 of them with a two- or three-way tiebreaker for the fifth. Now we have a four-way tiebreaker for the 4th and 5th slots.

    Best Picture

    1. The Summer Story

    2. Fatal Rendezvous

    3. Dodge City

    4. The Morrow II

    Best Actor

    1. Colin Firth (The Dead in the House)

    2. Gary Oldman (Thane of the Flies)

    3. Tom Cruise (Leitmotif)

    Best Actress

    1. Felicity Huffman (The Dead in the House)

    2. Saoirse Ronan (Divergent)

    Best Supporting Actor

    1. Michael Sheen (Love in Poitiers)

    2. Ben Barnes (The Coming Storm)

    3. Tommy Lee Jones (Dodge City)

    4. Tom Hanks (The Summer Story)

    Best Original Screenplay

    1. The Coming Storm

    2. El Libertador

    Best Ensemble

    1. Love in Poitiers

    2. Fatal Rendezvous

    3. Dodge City

    4. Genesis

    Best Animated Feature

    1. Blue Heart

    2. Animal Farm

    3. Sam and Max Hit the Road

    4. Ag3nts

    5. Frost the Snowman

    Best Art Direction

    1. Love in Poitiers

    2. Dodge City

    3. Black as Night

    4. Thane of the Flies

    Best Make Up

    1. Love in Poitiers

    2. Planeswalkers

    3. Into the Breach

    4. Spellforce: Breath of the Winter

    Best Score

    1. Dodge City - Marco Belltrami

    2. The Coming Storm - Alberto Iglesias

    3. Planeswalkers - Howard Shore

    Best Film Editing

    1. Fatal Rendezvous

    2. Genesis

    Best Sound Editing

    1. Prodigy

    2. Divergent

    Best Visual Effects

    1. The Morrow II

    2. Divergent

    3. Voyage to Atlantis

    Best Use of Action

    1. Genesis

    2. The Coming Storm

    3. Wolves of the Deep

    4. Fable

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Guest
    This topic is now closed to further replies.


    • Recently Browsing   0 members

      • No registered users viewing this page.
    ×
    ×
    • Create New...

    Important Information

    By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Guidelines. Feel free to read our Privacy Policy as well.