4815162342 Posted September 25, 2012 Share Posted September 25, 2012 It's that wonderful time of the year where we pick what we want to be nominated for the Oscars. A refresher for how this thread works: For each category, list five nominees. Do not rank the nominees, they can be in any order, though alphabetical order is preferred. Also remember that in the two new voice actress categories, men and women can be nominated together. We'll say that this thread will be open for about a week, by the end of Sunday night. On Monday I will move on to the tiebreakers. These are the categories: Best Picture Best Animated Feature Best Director Best Ensemble Best Actor Best Actress Best Supporting Actor Best Supporting Actress Best Voice Actor/Actress in a Leading Role Best Voice Actor/Actress in a Supporting Role Best Original Screenplay Best Adapted Screenplay Best Original Score Best Original Song Best Cinematography Best Film Editing Best Art Direction Best Costumes Best Makeup Best Sound Mixing Best Sound Editing Best Visual Effects Best Use of Action Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
4815162342 Posted September 25, 2012 Author Share Posted September 25, 2012 (edited) Best PictureAlesiaThe Glass CastleThe Good Die YoungNever Say GoodbyeWenanBest Animated FeatureBone - Vernal EquinoxIsland of the Blue DolphinsOur CitySparkSylvariusBest DirectorWoody Allen for Never Say GoodbyePaul Thomas Anderson for WenanGus Van Sant for The Road HomeMartin Scorsese for The Good Die YoungPeter Weir for AlesiaBest EnsembleAlesiaThe Good Die YoungNever Say GoodbyeThe Road HomeWenanBest ActorJim Carrey for Citizen HughesLeonardo DiCaprio for Never Say GoodbyeEmilie Hirsch for The Good Die YoungClive Owen for AlesiaJohn C. Reilly for The Road HomeBest ActressEllen Burstyn for The Road HomeKeira Knightley for Love BytesJennifer Lawrence for The Good Die YoungChloe Moretz for The Glass CastleKate Winslet for Never Say GoodbyeBest Supporting ActorPaul Bettany for The Glass CastleMichael Caine for Never Say GoodbyeTom Hardy for AlesiaShia LaBeouf for The Good Die YoungAlexander Skarsgard for The Flowers of ArvikaBest Supporting ActressMarion Cotillard for Citizen HughesJulianne Moore for The Road HomeEllora Patnaik for WenanLéa Seydoux for AlesiaRobin Wright Penn for The Glass CastleBest Voice Actor/Actress in a Leading RoleDavid Faustino for SparkBryce Dallas Howard for SparkGina Torres for NirvanaEmma Watson for SylvariusElijah Wood for Bone - Vernal EquinoxBest Voice Actor/Actress in a Supporting RoleKathy Bates for Bone - Vernal EquinoxBenedict Cumberbatch for SparkAlexis Denisof for SylvariusStephen Dillane for SylvariusMeryl Streep for Our CityBest Original ScreenplayAlesiaThe Good Die YoungLove BytesNever Say GoodbyeThe Road HomeBest Adapted ScreenplayCall of Duty: Of Their Own AccordCitzen HughesDeath of a SalesmanThe Glass CastleReady Player OneBest Original ScorePatrick Doyle for AlesiaThomas Newman for The Glass CastleAtticus Ross for The SimulationHoward Shore for WenanJeremy Soule for SylvariusBest Original Song"Man of Valor" from Lord Madship"Miracle" from Miracle Kids"Ode to Ultra-Loose" from Grunge"Save Me In Every Way" from Dawn of Souls II: Rebirth"When That Day Comes" from SparkBest CinematographyAlesiaThe Good Die YoungThe SimulationThe Triple NickelsWenanBest Film EditingAlesiaThe Glass CastleThe Good Die YoungThe Road HomeWenanBest Art DirectionAlesiaThe Bellringer of Notre DameBohemianCitizen HughesNirvanaBest CostumesAlesiaThe Bellringer of Notre DameDawn of Souls II: RebirthDivisionsWenanBest MakeupAlesiaThe Bellringer of Notre DameCall of Duty: Of Their Own AccordCitizen HughesThe Last SixBest Sound MixingAlesiaCall of Duty: Of Their Own AccordNirvanaSylvariusWenanBest Sound EditingAlesiaLord MadshipMartian ManhunterNirvanaSylvariusBest Visual EffectsCall of Duty: Of Their Own AccordDivisionsThe Last SixMartian ManhunterNirvanaBest Use of ActionAlesiaCall of Duty: Of Their Own AccordThe Last SixNirvanaThe Triple Nickels Edited October 1, 2012 by 4815162342 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
riczhang Posted September 25, 2012 Share Posted September 25, 2012 (edited) Best Picture:AlesiaWenanThe Class CastleThe Flowers of ArvikaThe Road HomeBest Animated Feature:SparkOur CitySylvariusIsland of the Blue DolphinsBone – Vernal EquinoxBest Director:Peter Weir for AlesiaPaul Thomas Anderson for WenanLukas Moodysson for The Flowers of ArvikaGus Van Sant for The Road HomeWoody Allen for Never Say GoodbyeBest Ensemble:AlesiaWenanThe Glass CastleDeath of a SalesmanNever Say GoodbyeBest Actor:Clive Owen for AlesiaJim Carrey for Citizen HughesEmile Hirsch for The Good Die YoungPhillip Seymour Hoffman for Death of a SalesmanJoseph Gordon-Levitt for The SimulationBest Actress:Chloe Moretz for The Glass CastleJennifer Lawrence for The Good Die YoungCate Blanchett for In the Line of ServiceEllen Burstyn for The Road HomeMeryl Streep for Death of a SalesmanBest Supporting Actor:Tom Hardy for AlesiaGeoffery Rush for WenanPaul Bettany for The Glass CastleAlexander Skarsgard for The Flowers of ArvikaSam Elliott for The Road HomeBest Supporting Actress:Lea Seydoux for AlesiaEllora Patnaik for WenanRobin Wright Penn for The Glass CastleJulianne Moore for The Road HomeAngelina Jolie for Never Say GoodbyeBest Voice Actor/Actress in a Leading Role:N/ABest Voice Actor/Actress in a Supporting Role:N/ABest Original Screenplay:AlesiaWenanSparkOur CityDivisionsBest Adapted Screenplay:The Glass CastleCitizen HughesDeath of a SalesmanIsland of the Blue DolphinsInsurgentBest Original Score:Patrick Doyle for AlesiaHoward Shore for WenanJohn Powell for SparkThomas Newman for The Glass CastleJohnny Greenwood for The Vast Dark: ExecutionBest Original Song:"Man of Valor" from Lord Madship"Miracle" from Miracle Kids"Ode to Ultra-Loose" from Grunge"Save Me In Every Way" from Dawn of Souls II: Rebirth"When That Day Comes" from SparkBest Cinematography:AlesiaWenanThe Good Die YoungThe SimulationDivisionsBest Film Editing:AlesiaWenanThe Glass CastleThe Road HomeDivisionsBest Art Direction:AlesiaWenanCitizen HughesReady, Player OneDivisionsBest Costumes:AlesiaWenanNever Say GoodbyeDivisionsNirvanaBest Makeup:AlesiaWenanThe Glass CastleIn the Line of ServiceDivisionsBest Sound Mixing:AlesiaWenanCall of Duty: On Their Own AccordDivisionsNirvanaBest Sound Editing:AlesiaThe Good Die YoungLord MadshipCall of duty: On Their Own AccordDivisionsBest Visual Effects:The FlashCall of Duty: On Their Own AccordDivisionsNirvanaThe Last SixBest Use of Action:AlesiaThe FlashCall of Duty: Of Their Own AccordNirvanaThe Last Six Edited October 1, 2012 by riczhang Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Blankments Posted September 25, 2012 Share Posted September 25, 2012 (edited) Best Picture Citizen Hughes Divisions The Good Die Young The Road Home Spark Best Animated Film Bone - Vernal Equinox Knights of the Lunch Table Our City Spark Sylvarius Best Director Christopher Nolan, Citizen Hughes Martin Scorcese, The Good Die Young Oliver Stone, Miracle Kids Gus Van Sant, The Road Home Peter Weir, Alesia Best Actor Jim Carrey, Citizen Hughes Joseph Gordon-Levitt, The Simulation Terrence Howard, The Triple Nickels Emile Hirsch, The Good Die Young John C. Reilly, The Road Home Best Actress Cate Blanchett, In the Line of Service Jennifer Lawrence, The Good Die Young Keira Knightley, LoveBytes Mandy Moore, Once Upon a Mattress Chloe Moretz, The Glass Castle Best Supporting Actor Michael Caine, Never Say Goodbye Tom Cruise, Comedians Christopher Lee, The Bellringer of Notre Dame Matthew Modine, Citizen Hughes Alexander Skasard, The Flowers of Arvika Best Supporting Actress Elizabeth Gillies, The Road Home Anne Hathaway, The Bellringer of Notre Dame Julianne Moore, The Road Home AnnaSophia Robb, Best Friends Forever Michelle Williams, The Simulation Best Voice Actor/Actress in a Leading Role Bryce Dallas Howard, Spark Jason Ritter, Knights of the Lunch Table Gina Torres, Nirvana Emma Watson, Sylvarius Elijah Wood, Bone - Vernal Equinox Best Voice Actor/Actress in a Supporting Role Benedict Cumberbatch, Spark Grey DeLisle, Knights of the Lunch Table Stephen Dillane, Sylvarius Christopher Lee, Chuck Norris and Liam Neeson vs. the Abominable Snowman Hugo Weaving, Spark Best Ensemble Citizen Hughes Death of a Salesman Miracle Kids The Party Party The Road Home Best Original Screenplay The Good Die Young The Last Six Miracle Kids The Road Home Spark Best Adapted Screenplay Booster Gold Citizen Hughes The Glass Castle Lord Madship Ready Player One Best Original Score Patrick Doyle, Alesia Wyclef Jean, Miracle Kids John Powell, Spark Howard Shore, Wenan Jeremy Soule, Sylvarius Best Original Song "Man of Valor," Lord Madship "Never Say Goodbye," Never Say Goodbye "Miracle," Miracle Kids "This Is Not A Happy Ending," A Series of Unfortunate Events "When That Day Comes," Spark Best Cinematography Citizen Hughes Divisions The Good Die Young The Last Six Wenan Best Film Editing Bohemian Divisions The Good Die Young The Road Home Wenan Best Art Direction Alesia The Bellringer of Notre Dame The Last Six Once Upon a Mattress Ready Player One Best Costumes Alesia Citizen Hughes The Last Six Once Upon a Mattress Wenan Best Makeup Citizen Hughes The Glass Castle The Last Six Martian Manhunter Wenan Best Sound Mixing The Good Die Young The Last Six Lord Madship Ready Player One Spark Best Sound Editing Call of Duty: Of Their Own Accord The Good Die Young The Last Six The Simulation Spark Best Visual Effects Call of Duty: Of Their Own Accord Dawn of Souls II: Rebirth Divisions The Last Six Martian Manhunter Best Use of Action Alesia Call of Duty: Of Their Own Accord Chuck Norris and Liam Neeson vs. the Abominable Snowman The Last Six Martian Manhunter Edited September 28, 2012 by Blankments Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Ezen Baklattan Posted September 25, 2012 Share Posted September 25, 2012 (edited) Best Picture Alesia The Glass Castle The Good Die Young The Road Home Wenan Best Animated Feature Knights Of The Lunch Table Island Of The Blue Dolphins Our City Spark Sylvarius Best Director Peter Weir (Alesia) Paul Thomas Anderson (Wenan) Gus Van Sant (The Road Home) Martin Scorcese (The Good Die Young) Lukas Moodyson (The Flowers Of Arkiva) Best Ensemble The Glass Castle The Road Home Alesia The Good Die Young Never Say Goodbye Best Actor Jim Carrey (Citizen Hughes) Clive Owen (Alesia) Philip Seymour Hoffman (Death Of A Salesman) John C. Reilly (The Road Home) Emile Hirsch (The Good Die Young) Best Actress Michelle Williams (The Flowers Of Arkiva) Ellen Burstyn (The Road Home) Chloe Moretz (The Glass Castle) Jennifer Lawrence (The Good Die Young) Cate Blanchett (In The Line Of Service) Best Supporting Actor Paul Bettany (The Glass Castle) Geoffery Rush (Wenan) Sam Elliott (The Road Home) Tom Hardy (Alesia) David Tennant (Lord Madship) Best Supporting Actress Julianne Moore (The Road Home) Elizabeth Gilles (The Road Home) Marion Cotillard (Citizen Hughes) Lea Seydoux (Alesia) Robin Wright Penn (The Glass Castle) Best Voice Actor/Actress in a Leading Role David Faustino (Spark) Emma Watson (Sylvarius) Bryce Dallas Howard (Spark) Freida Pinto (Island Of The Blue Dolphins) Elijah Wood (Bone: Vernal Equinox) Best Voice Actor/Actress in a Supporting Role Alexis Denisof (Sylvarius) Stephen Dillane (Sylvarius) Benedict Cumberbatch (Spark) Hugo Weaving (Spark) Gina Torres (Nirvana) Best Original Screenplay Alesia Wenan The Good Die Young The Road Home Spark Best Adapted Screenplay Citizen Hughes Ready, Player One The Glass Castle Call Of Duty: On Their Own Accord Death Of A Salesman Best Original Score Wylef Jean (Miracle Kids) John Powell (Spark) Hans Zimmer (Nirvana) Howard Shore (Wenan) Patrick Doyle (Alesia) Best Original Song When That Day Comes (Spark) This Is Not A Happy Ending (A Series Of Unfortunate Events) Man Of Valor (Lord Madship) Miracle (Miracle Kids) Never Say Goodbye (Never Say Goodbye) Best Cinematography Alesia The Simulation The Road Home Wenan The Good Die Young Best Film Editing Alesia The Road Home Wenan The Good Die Young The Glass Castle Best Art Direction Alesia Citizen Hughes Nirvana Ready, Player One Wenan Best Costumes Citizen Hughes Alesia Nirvana In The Line Of Service The Last Six Best Makeup Alesia Citizen Hughes Nirvana The Bellringer Of Notre Dame Wenan Best Sound Mixing Call Of Duty: On Their Own Accord Alesia Divisions The Triple Nickels Nirvana Best Sound Editing Call Of Duty: On Their Own Accord Alesia Spark Ready, Player One Nirvana Best Visual Effects Nirvana Call Of Duty: On Their Own Accord Divisions The Last Six Ready, Player One Best Use of Action Alesia Call Of Duty: On Their Own Accord Nirvana Ready, Player One The Triple Nickels Edited September 26, 2012 by Wreck It Spaghetti Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Impact Posted September 25, 2012 Share Posted September 25, 2012 I will get to mine Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Electric Posted September 25, 2012 Share Posted September 25, 2012 Best Picture Best Animated Feature Best Director Best Ensemble Best Actor Best Actress Best Supporting Actor Best Supporting Actress Best Voice Actor/Actress in a Leading Role Best Voice Actor/Actress in a Supporting Role Best Original Screenplay Best Adapted Screenplay Best Original Score Best Original Song Best Cinematography Best Film Editing Best Art Direction Best Costumes Best Makeup Best Sound Mixing Best Sound Editing Best Visual Effects Best Use of Action Wait for it... Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Impact Posted September 25, 2012 Share Posted September 25, 2012 (edited) Mine:Best Picture:AlesiaCitizen HughesMiracle KidsSparkTripple NickelsBest Animated Feature:Island of the Blue DolphinsSparkSylvariusBest Director:Taylor Hackford for Tripple NickelsChristopher Nolan for Citizen HughesMartin Scorsese for The Good Die YoungOliver Stone for Miracle KidsPeter Weir for AlesiaBest Ensemble:AlesiaThe Glass CastleMiracle KidsTripple NicklesBest Actor:Jim Carrey for Citizen HughesEmile Hirsch for The Good Die YoungLiam Hemsworth for ColumbineTerrence Howard for Tripple NickelsClive Owen for AlesiaBest Actress: Cate Blanchett for In the Line of ServiceJennifer Lawrence for The Good Die YoungRachel McAdams for DefianceBest Supporting Actor:Paul Bettany for The Glass CastleTom Hardy for AlesiaShia LaBeouf for The Good Die YoungBest Supporting Actress:Robin Write for The Glass CastleBest Voice Actor/Actress in a Leading Role:David Faustino for SparkZach Galafankis for Duck in SpaceFreida Pinto for Island of the Blue DolphinsEmma Watson for SylvariusBest Voice Actor/Actress in a Supporting Role:Anton Yelchin for SparkBest Original Screenplay:AlesiaThe Good Die YoungMiracle KidsSparkTripple NickelsBest Adapted Screenplay: The Bellringer of Notre DameCall of Duty of Their Own AccordCitizen HughesIsland of the Blue DolphinsBest Original Score:Alesia (Patrick Doyle)Citizen Hughes (Hans Zimmer)Miracle Kids (Wylef Jean)Spark (John Powell)Tripple Nickels (Craig Armstrong)Best Original Song:When that day Comes from SparkMiracle from Miracle KidsMan of Valor from Lord MadshipBest Cinematography:AlesiaCall of Duty of Their Own AccordCitizen HughesMiracle KidsTripple NickelsBest Film Editing:AlesiaCitizen HughesThe Good Die YoungMiracle KidsTripple NickelsBest Art Direction:AlesiaThe Bellringer of Notre DameCitizen HughesTripple NickelsBest Costumes:AlesiaThe Bellringer of Notre DameCitizen HughesTripple NickelsBest Makeup:AlesiaCall of Duty: Of Their Own AccordThe Last SixBest Sound Mixing:AlesiaCall of Duty of Their Own AccordDefianceSylvariusTripple NickelsBest Sound Editing:AlesiaCall of Duty of Their Own AccordThe Last SixSparkTripple NickelsBest Visual Effects: Dawn of Souls 2DivisionsInsurgentNirvanaBest Use of Action:Call of Duty of Their Own AccordDefianceThe Last SixLord MadshipTripple Nickels Edited October 1, 2012 by Impact Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
4815162342 Posted September 26, 2012 Author Share Posted September 26, 2012 With 3 full ballots completed it's shaping up to be a very spread out year in many categories, though as more lists come in things will get more refined.Impact I won't be adding yours into my document yet since I want to wait until a ballot is completed or is as completed as possible before the deadline. No rush obviously, you have far bigger things on your plate right now. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Impact Posted September 26, 2012 Share Posted September 26, 2012 Yeah thanks. My other grandma's dead earlier this year caused me to miss out on almost all of year 2. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
4815162342 Posted September 26, 2012 Author Share Posted September 26, 2012 Just for people's reference, once I see a ballot is full I immediately add it to my compilation document. If you had posted a full ballot but then later edited it to change some picks around, please post that you did so and what you changed so I can make the necessary alterations. I don't check to see if people fiddle around with previously completed ballots since that is very time-consuming. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Impact Posted September 26, 2012 Share Posted September 26, 2012 I may get a few more in 48. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Impact Posted September 27, 2012 Share Posted September 27, 2012 I think I'll add in more in a bit. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
The Dark Alfred Posted September 28, 2012 Share Posted September 28, 2012 (edited) Best Picture Never Say Goodbye Alesia The Triple Nickels The Road Home Miracle Kids Best Animated Film Bone - Vernal Equinox Decker Our City Spark Sylvarius Best Director Christopher Nolan, Citizen Hughes Lukas Moodysson, Flowers of Arvika Oliver Stone, Miracle Kids Gus Van Sant, The Road Home Peter Weir, Alesia Best Actor Jim Carrey, Citizen Hughes Joseph Gordon-Levitt, The Simulation Terrence Howard, The Triple Nickels Emile Hirsch, The Good Die Young John C. Reilly, The Road Home Best Actress Ellen Burstyn, The Road Home Jennifer Lawrence, The Good Die Young Michelle Williams, The Flowers of Arvika Kate Winslet, Never Say Goodbye Chloe Moretz, The Glass Castle Best Supporting Actor Michael Caine, Never Say Goodbye Tom Cruise, Comedians Sam Elliot, The Road Home Tom Hardy, Alesia Alexander Skasgard, The Flowers of Arvika Best Supporting Actress Elizabeth Gillies, The Road Home Anne Hathaway, The Bellringer of Notre Dame Julianne Moore, The Road Home Marion Cotillard, Citizen Hughes Michelle Williams, The Simulation Best Voice Actor/Actress in a Leading Role Bryce Dallas Howard, Spark Jason Ritter, Knights of the Lunch Table Gina Torres, Nirvana Emma Watson, Sylvarius Elijah Wood, Bone - Vernal Equinox Best Voice Actor/Actress in a Supporting Role Benedict Cumberbatch, Spark Michael Caine, Decker Stephen Dillane, Sylvarius Christopher Lee, Chuck Norris and Liam Neeson vs. the Abominable Snowman Hugo Weaving, Spark Best Ensemble Citizen Hughes Death of a Salesman Miracle Kids Never Say Goodbye The Road Home Best Original Screenplay The Good Die Young The Flowers of Arvika Miracle Kids The Road Home Alesia Best Adapted Screenplay Booster Gold Citizen Hughes The Glass Castle Martian Manhunter Ready Player One Best Original Score Patrick Doyle, Alesia Wyclef Jean, Miracle Kids Craig Armstrong, The Triple Nickels John Powell, Spark Howard Shore, Wenan Best Original Song "Man of Valor," Lord Madship "Never Say Goodbye," Never Say Goodbye "Miracle," Miracle Kids "Ode To Ultra-Loose" Grunge "When That Day Comes," Spark Best Cinematography Citizen Hughes The Triple Nickels The Good Die Young The Road Home Wenan Best Film Editing Nirvana The Triple Nickels The Good Die Young The Road Home Wenan Best Art Direction Alesia Nirvana Never Say Goodbye The Triple Nickels Ready Player One Best Costumes Alesia Citizen Hughes The Last Six Once Upon a Mattress The Triple Nickels Best Makeup Citizen Hughes The Triple Nickels The Last Six Martian Manhunter Wenan Best Sound Mixing The Good Die Young The Last Six Lord Madship Sylvarius The Triple Nickels Best Sound Editing Call of Duty: Of Their Own Accord The Good Die Young The Last Six The Triple Nickels Sylvarius Best Visual Effects Call of Duty: Of Their Own Accord Dawn of Souls II: Rebirth Divisions Nirvana Martian Manhunter Best Use of Action Alesia Call of Duty: Of Their Own Accord The Triple Nickels The Last Six Martian Manhunter Edited September 28, 2012 by The Dark Alfred Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
4815162342 Posted September 28, 2012 Author Share Posted September 28, 2012 (edited) 4 full lists in (thanks riczhang) and some things are getting clear while some are still very muddled.However I have to say I am disappointed so far by the lack of appreciation for Jeremy Soule as a composer. I mean people in this game have nominated people like Anthony Partos (Year 1) and Angelo Badalamenti (Year 3) for Best Score and I guarantee that the people who nominated them actually had no idea who either of them were (in fact I found no IMDB listing for Partos at all). They were only picked because the films they were nominated were BP nominees. Just me grumbling over people ignoring the best video game music composer of all time.Edit: See that Alfred has posted his list. Will take care of that addition momentarily...and no Soule mention there either. BLARGH. Edited September 28, 2012 by 4815162342 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Impact Posted September 28, 2012 Share Posted September 28, 2012 (edited) 48-I was thinking-should we have after year 5 a best of the first 5 years Oscars? Edited September 28, 2012 by Impact Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
The Dark Alfred Posted September 28, 2012 Share Posted September 28, 2012 Well people putting BP films for score is pretty much in line with the methods of the AMPAS. Not good. My picks weren't based on that. I even regret leaving Atticus Ross out. I had to choose between Spark and Sylvarius and I went with Shore. Sylvarius got the sound noms however. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Impact Posted September 28, 2012 Share Posted September 28, 2012 I almost had him for score-though I'm not sure who that is. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Blankments Posted September 28, 2012 Share Posted September 28, 2012 Just switched out Michael Giacchino for Jeremy Soule, who I just looked up, and saw his rather interesting discography.I'm disappointed by Last Six not being mentioned much under Cinematography. Whether you like the movie or not, it's the first movie ever in this game to be completely filmed in IMAX, and I feel as though that technical merit alone deserves nomination. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
4815162342 Posted September 28, 2012 Author Share Posted September 28, 2012 48-I was thinking-should we have after year 5 a best of the first 5 years Oscars?I don't know, I'm not sure how much involvement there'll be since some people would have to go back to look at Years they didn't play in. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
