Favorite & Best Star Wars Film!

[CloneWars]

I vote ANH for both.

[CoolioD1]

Same.

[Noctis]

Revenge of the Sith, easily. Great film. The Phantom Menace - DAttack of the Clones - CRevenge of the Sith - A-/AA New Hope - CEmpire Strikes Back - B+/A-Return of the Jedi - B- (would have been an A- if it had not been for the Ewoks which RUINED it for me)

[Water Bottle]

The Phantom Menace: BAttack of the Clones: B-Revenge of the Sith: B+A New Hope: A+Empire Strikes Back: A (It's My favorite though)Return of the Jedi: A-

[Noctis]

I genuinely question peoples' sanity when they give TPM a B.

[ddddeeee]

Favourite is probably ROTJ, best being ESB.

[Water Bottle]

I genuinely question peoples' sanity when they give TPM a B.

Other than some acting issues and Jar Jar Binks, it's actually a pretty good story.

[pinocchio]

The Phantom Menace: BAttack of the Clones: B-Revenge of the Sith: B+A New Hope: A+Empire Strikes Back: A (It's My favorite though)Return of the Jedi: A-

Sorry, I'm not english speaking. Is A better than A+ or vice versa?

[Water Bottle]

Sorry, I'm not english speaking. Is A better than A+ or vice versa?

A+ is better. I think A New Hope is the best film, but my favorite is Empire Strikes Back.

[4815162342]

Empire for both

[pinocchio]

Ah, okay, thanks.Since I am a huge Star Wars fan I probably have to watch the whole saga again to make a decision.That's the curse with movies you have watched at least a dozen times...

[Kvikk Lunsj]

Star Wars: ESB 10/10Star Wars: ANH 10/10Star Wars: ROTJ 9.5/10Star Wars: ROTS 6.5/10Star Wars: AOTC 3/10Star Wars: TPM 3/10

Edited November 10, 2011 by Dexter of Suburbia

[CramaG12]

The Phantom Menace- D (thought an F would be too harsh)Attack of the Clones- C-Revenge of the Sith- A-A new hope- B-Empire Strikes Back- B+/A-Return of the Jedi- B-TPM and AOTC are the absolute worst for obvious reasons. Revenge of the Sith is my favorite of all and really saved the second trilogy. Enjoyed all of the original trilogy, but Empire Strikes Back is without question the best. As far as ROTJ, I agree with Noctis, the Ewoks really hurt that film for me.

Edited November 10, 2011 by CramaG12

[Phil in the Blank]

Empire for both

[MasterDodsen]

The Empire Strikes Back isn't just the best Star Wars movie, it is the best Movie ever.Plus its my favorite.

[Phil in the Blank]

Phantom = C-Clones = C-Sith = B+Hope = AEmpire = A+Return = B+

[75Live]

TESB as the best, but I went with ANH for my favorite

[JamesFord92]

Like ESB the best like most people do. The last 45 minutes or so of ROTJ is probably my favourite sequence in any of the movies though.

[Phil in the Blank]

I love the last 45 minutes of ROTJ although the damn ewok battle, while enjoyable enough, pales in-comparison to the light sabre duel and the space battle.

Plus, it makes the storm troopers even more of a complete joke when a 'whole legion of my finest troops' can be taken out by 4 foot tall teddy bears who don't blink.

[4815162342]

If I could change 1 thing about ROTJ, it would be to change Endor to Kashyyyk, with the Wookiees being used as slave labor for building Death Star II (because Wookiees had been enslaved by the Empire for manual labor). Epic Wookiee guerilla warfare = Epic Win for All (plus it could give Chewbacca more to do other than growl at bad guys because he'd have to take on a leadership role for his people).

Edited February 23, 2012 by 4815162342