Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer

[baumer]

Discuss

[The Stingray]

Terrible movie.

[Punishment]

I was so looking forward to seeing my favorite super hero on the big screen (Silver Surfer) only to be disappointed :(I will say that some of the scenes with the Surfer were pretty good but the overall movie left me wanting more. C-

[druv10]

F. unmitigated disaster.

Edited December 7, 2012 by druv10

[IndustriousAngel]

I give it a C.There were few scenes that actually hurt, but many that disappointed. And I don't talk the wedding scenes here; those were actually funny nods to the original FF's soap-opera-like comics run in my opinion.I agree with Punishment; the Silver Surfer was a completely wasted opportunity, as was Galactus. Why do it at all if you can't do it right? I'm keeping my fingers crossed that somebody tackles those two again - not necessarily in an FF context, mind you.

[Olive]

6/10it's not that bad!not bad as Ghost rider 2

[Goffe]

delete

Edited December 12, 2013 by Goffe Luvs 1D

[Accursed Arachnid!™]

This one has not held up as well as the first. It's too short for one thing. 90 min for something as epic as Galactus and Silver Surfer? Unforgivable. Plus Alba as Sue is so much more irritating this go around. And royally screwing the pooch with Galactus makes Dr. Doom in the first film look like Heath Ledger as the Joker. C+

[John Marston]

Horrible movie! Worse than the first if you can believe it.

[CJohn]

Bring the reboot. These movies were terrible.

[Accursed Arachnid!™]

Yeah, the grading curve is always there. If they rebooted FF with Whedon, I'd probably look back at the originals and drop them at least one full grade.

[Squaremaster316]

Blech movie... but at least Evans was more entertaining in this comic film series

[John Marston]

I don't understand how people think this was better than the first. It made the first look like a masterpiece

[Sam]

Well, Galactus is a cloud, and not a pretty one either. That says a lot about the movie.Chris Evans continued to be the best thing about this franchise. He nailed Johnny Storm. The Thing was pretty good too, but yeah, rubber suit, not really a strong point.There were a few bright spots in actions and character arcs, but too few and far in between to make any big impact.Silver Surfer, well, LOL.C-

[tawasal]

One of the reasons that is making me avoid the next one coming.

[Goffe]

Enjoyable and better than the first one C+ (60)

[John Marston]

Enjoyable and better than the first one C+ (60)

 

 

I don't get how it is better. First one at least had a few clever moments. This one was just a disaster from start to finish

[Goffe]

I don't get how it is better. First one at least had a few clever moments. This one was just a disaster from start to finish

first: Silver Surfer

second: Doom is much less prominent than he was in the first FF (that's a good thing because Doom is one of those typical "muahahaha" villains)

third: it is actually funny sometimes

fourth: amazing score

[John Marston]

 I like how "Dr. Doom" spends most of his screentime is civilian clothing, with no mask,  or messed up face or anything, for like 95% of his screentime. And he's not a dictator or anything like that, or a genius, or a commanding presence, or really very impressive at all. 

[Sam]

I like how "Dr. Doom" spends most of his screentime is civilian clothing, with no mask, or messed up face or anything, for like 95% of his screentime. And he's not a dictator or anything like that, or a genius, or a commanding presence, or really very impressive at all.

That's the biggest offender, worst thing Fox has done to their Marvel properties for me yet. Just ugh!