Jump to content

Aristis

Free Account+
  • Posts

    1,492
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Aristis

  1. 5 hours ago, TalismanRing said:

     

    After the first w/e the narrative by the press was "do critics matter".  Then after the plummet they went back to maybe they do - but at that point they didn't   Opening weekend it sold $420m+ worth of tickets - about 50 million tickets.  The WOM from 50 million people who saw the film >>>>> critics or any pre release press or even at that point marketing.  Some people liked it of course, hell some loved it but a lot of people disliked it, hated it or were indifferent to it otherwise they would have spread much better WOM and recommended to it all their friends and family.   A film does not plummet 70% it's 2nd w/e and then another 60% it's third because of press. 

    1. I still believe in my fans-on-first-weekend-theory B) (It partly explains the big drops)

    2. Frontloadness isn't inevitably a sign for a bad movie - could also follow a big hype (But if drops are that big you could argue that it does not appeal) But that leads to 3.

    3. I'm not a psychologist but maybe the bad ratings by critics have an bad influence on "normal" moviegoers (would not explain why sometimes movies that are worse rated appeal to the audience) Could be wrong expectations. If you watch Transformers you know what you get. Maybe many expected something else.

    4. But maybe, because I don't understand why it is that disliked because I liked it, I try to find explanations to me that are - maybe - unrealistic.

     

    But I think this movie can't be that bad that it explains the drops.

  2. 10 hours ago, jb007 said:

     

     

    +1

     

    The problem with BvS is not negative media buzz but awful quality. I cannot remember a highly anticipated tent pole movie that pretty much failed in all ares of film making like BvS has done.

     

    This movie opened big even with bad reviews. So that rules out the huge impact of bad reviews. What did BvS in was the terrible WOM.

     

    OS it dropped 68% in the second weekend and 60% in the third weekend. That is just about as bad as I have seen for a big movie. No amount of laughable defense makes it any better. This may be the first big movie to probably end up with a less than 2 multiplier (Dom) or barely squeak past it.

     

    These kind of drops are unheard of and it is not so because of some ridiculous conspiracy. Quality does matter, at least to some extent. 

     

     

    To open huge and fall quickly can happen when fans watch it at the first weekend and others are restrained from watching it because of its bad reviews. And are you sure that the movie is bad or is that only your (own) opinion? (Because there are people who liked it, me too ;))

     

    Maybe some think it's bad because critics say it's bad (so they are movie-experts) or they really think it's bad and this movie divides. Nevertheless $850M is huge even if it's quite disappointing especially after its OW. They will make profit when all is over but less than expected. Some here seem to be exorbitant.

  3. 27 minutes ago, IndustriousAngel said:

     

    Nice list ... had no idea "League of Extraordinary Gentlemen" had that many admissions, but I guess few people here knew this was a comic book. And if you look at DC and Marvel adaptions combined, it seems that 3mil total is a kind of ceiling for SH movies; only Batman on the DC side and Spiderman on Marvel's were ever able to break that barrier (except for the original Superman which was a bit of a media phenomenon in its days, but Supie got grounded fast with part 2)

    I wouldn't have known that movies like Constantine or RED are Comics, too.

     

    The jump from Batman Begins tho The Dark Knight is great!

  4. BvS is guaranteed to reach the 6th place. Will probably not reach 5th. Could end with 1.6M to 1.7M admissions ($20M to $22M)

     

    Biggest DC movies in admissions:

    1 79 4,2M Superman
    2 12 3,3M The Dark Knight Rises
    3 08 2,8M The Dark Knight
    4 89 1,8M Batman
    5 03 1,8M The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen
    6 81 1,4M Superman II
    7 95 1,3M Batman Forever
    8 97 1,3M Batman & Robin
    9 05 1,1M Constantine
    10 16 1,1M Batman v Superman - Dawn of Justice
    11 02 1,0M Road to Perdition
    12 92 1,0M Batman Returns
    13 05 0,9M Batman Begins
    14 10 0,9M RED
    15 13 0,8M Man of Steel
    • Like 4
  5. 52 minutes ago, Quigley said:

    Furious 7's drops last year were:

    52.5% OS (excluding openers)

    59.5% NA

     

    so BvS's drops are clearly not just because of its opening falling on Easter weekend.

     

    [EDIT]

    HP&:P2 dropped 65.3% WW

    Spider-Man 3 dropped 62.7% WW

    Only HP6 dropped more (73.7%) but it opened on a Wednesday in NA and some other countries (which normally open on Fridays) so it's understandable

    F7 was supported by critics...

  6. 2 minutes ago, TalismanRing said:

     

    On the bright side it's doing much better than in in most of the other large markets around the world.

    I think in Germany there are seldom drops above 50% on the second weekend and if it's so then because of the weather. But Zoomania can hold much better and is a family movie so weather is not the issue. But yeah, in comparison to other countries it's good.

  7. I think the only bad thing about it is the excessive Action (Batman vs Superman fight; All against the Monster). These scenes took too long. But the idea of the movie, to show which results such powers can have and if it's allowed to use them without a democratic legitimisation, is more than good. It's lost sometimes a bit though... Less fight scenes and more story would have been better sometimes. So I hope the Extended cut doesn't show even more action and fight scenes.

    The music was just perfect. Hans Zimmer is a genius! Beautiful Lie and the Lex Luthor theme are really powerful and wonderful pieces of music.

    Sometimes it was a bit confusing but maybe that's intended (or it's just me :D)

    I really really like Henry's Superman even if (sometimes) he seems a bit too sorrowful, maybe it's his character. I did not really like Batman (he appears very unlikeable to me). He led to one of the worst scenes in the movie when Superman wanted to talk to him and he did not hear until he was said Martha was Supermans mother, too. A bit unlikely. As a character I liked Alfred but as Alfred... Maybe after Michael Caine that was to different to me. Wonderwoman was cool and she wears such cool dresses! Lex Luthor was great to me even if others don't think so.

     

    All in all it was a good movie, not a masterpiece though. But good enough to have at least 70% and A- . The rather subtle ending was pretty good. I liked it more than both Avengers (I really don't know why the first one was so well-liked <_<) Unfortunately it isn't strict with its issue which makes it a bit worse...

    • Like 1
  8. But don't forget that ER in 2011 was extremely favorable. I don't know where DH2 is when it's calculated with todays ER.

    If China and Japan make big amounts of money the movie is safe. But Japans DH2 gross would be about $35M less, GB $15M, Ger again $15M less and so on...

     

    It really has potential to be big. But $1B is much even today. I think $250M/$600M/$850M should be safe unless it's totally crap. But it won't gross more than $300M/$850M/$1150M. I think Fantasy isn't as big as it was nowadays :(

     

    But I could be wrong as many were with JW or SW :D

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Guidelines. Feel free to read our Privacy Policy as well.