12. The Curious Case of Benjamin Button (46 points, 5 lists)
Okay, so Benjamin Button was a visually nifty movie, and had some noteworthy moments. But Fincher wasn't the right guy to direct this. He's a dark, cynical, mysanthropic filmmaker, and something like this required a director with more fantastic, wondrous ideas. These two don't fit together, and the result is a movie that just kind of meanders, without any style or tone. I'll ask you this- would you have cared about Benjamin Button if he wasn't aging backwards? I didn't think so.