By now, we're used to the Spielberg one-two punch of a summer blockbuster followed by a prestige film for the holidays. Sometimes it works spectacularly (Jurassic Park and Schindler's List) and sometimes it fizzles (Lost World and Amistad). Sometimes the themes of the films blend together despite the vast differences in premises, budget and audience appeal (War of the Worlds and Munich are equally harrowing ruminations on post-9/11 anxieties)
Last year's double-bill was different, mainly because the crowdpleaser (Tintin) and the prestige film (War Horse) were scheduled within the same week in December. However, I personally suspect Spielberg had a much different dichotomy of passion for this particular set. He clearly had much more passion for Tintin than he ever did for Jurassic Park or War of the Worlds, and it showed in the fact he spent 30 years trying to make it. On the other hand, War Horse had one of the quickest turnovers I can think out of any Spielberg film -- he finds out about the novel/play in 2009, cast announced in 2010, finished film out in 2011 -- which makes me feel he doesn't have the same level of passion for this material that he did for the life stories of Oskar Schindler or even Frank Abagnale Jr.
Don't get me wrong, it is superb from a pure filmmaking standpoint. Everyone delivers a fine performance, the cinematography is gorgeous, the war sequences are intense and harrowing despite the lack of gore, and unlike many, I had zero issues with the level of unabashed sentiment on display. The fatal flaw is Richard Curtis' screenplay which, I'm sorry to say, fails miserably at sustaining an engaging narrative structure. There are some great scenes in the beginning and ending, but I found myself zoning out too much during the middle portions where the horse traveled from one doomed owner to another.
I honestly feel Spielberg just wanted a relatively simple project to thaw off some live-action filmmaking rust after working with mo-cap and a CGI-heavy Indiana Jones installment. He obviously loved the novel/play and identifies with the themes, but he doesn't explore them with the verve that defines classics such as Schindler's List or Private Ryan. I expect his next film Lincoln to be much better.
B-