Thank you! Lurker since the start of the Star Wars run and finally decided to get involved.
I think it's weaker than most recent years have been though.
IIRC Selma also suffered from a botched release to the Academy members, DuVernay hadn't finished the film and so last minute sent quite a rough copy to the members which I think annoyed them, then a botched campaign added to its misfortunes. I think that, while it wouldn't necessarily win anything, I definitely think Oyelowo would've been nominated this year, maybe DuVernay too.
Indeed, his was a real snub last year, as was DuVernay's, but I do think a bad campaign killed off its chances. And thank you! I thought their performances were good, but not on that level frankly, each year there's a controversy like this people go overboard and claim every good POC performance that year is worthy of Oscars.
Elba was good, and I maybe would've swapped Bale out for him. Then again I think Tremblay was even better than Elba so there's that. But I agree, like last year Gyllenhall got snubbed alongside Oyelowo (as did Fiennes).