Well the original Willy Wonka was considered a box office disaster but became a cult classic. Charlie and the Chocolate Factory made $475 million because it had a ton of hype and at that time everything Johnny Depp touched turned to gold even if the film wasn’t that good (Hence Alice in Wonderland, which critics pummeled) but it still made a killing at the box office. The films that you mentioned like Jumanji, Night at The Museum, Puss in Boots all had huge box office stars carrying the film, I’m not sure Timothee is at that level yet… but I could be wrong.