Jeremy Renner is not " a house hold name" or "superstar" by any means...
He is solid B List
A List
Brad Pitt
Johnny Depp
Angelina Jolie
Bruce Willis
Julia Roberts
Jim Carey
Robin Williams
Natalie Portman
Robert Downy Jr.
Denzell Washington
Halle Berry
Russel Crowe
Meryl Streep
Matt Damon
B List
Jeremy Renner
Jennifer Garner
Chris Pine
Jessica Chastain
Chris Evans
Olivia Wilde
Rose Byrne
John Krasinski
Kristen Bell
Chris Hemsworth
Josh Duhamel
Jeremy Renner def belongs on list two... He may graduate to list A someday maybe even within 2 years or so, but he is not there yet.