CAYOM Review Aggregate Y1 (CAYOM's Metacritic)

[cookie]

2 minutes ago, spaghetti! said:

I legit wanna push Al Pacino too, lol

[Ethan Hunt]

2 minutes ago, spaghetti! said:

I legit wanna push Al Pacino too, lol

could happen tbh the category feels pretty open and the film certainly has its fans

[cookie]

Forgot to say that Tywin Lannister is getting a hard push for Frollo

Edited October 4, 2017 by cookie

[cookie]

November updated

[cookie]

December updated

[cookie]

The top 10:

 

1. Flowers for Algernon - 96
2. Seeing Her - 91
3. White Hurricane - 90
4. The Hunchback of Notre Dame - 88
5. TIE: Me and My Shadow / Spark Rising - 87
6. The Truth About The Harry Quebert Affair - 86
7. The Adventures of Scrooge McDuck - 83
8. The Curse of Monkey Island - 82
9. Faces & Voices: The True Story of Milli Vanilli - 81
10. The SCP Foundation - 80

[Rorschach]

The scoreboard has been updated. I will finalize the positions once Numbers and Electric finish their reviews. 

[Rorschach]

Congratulations to the following films that have received the designation of "Certified Fresh". This designation goes to the films that have been positively received all around and have, at the most, 2 mixed reviews. The films are:

 

The SCP Foundation- 80

BraveStarr- 65

Seance- 70

Seeing Her- 91

Second to Singapore- 73

He-Man- 68

A Love to Die For- 74

The Adventures of Scrooge McDuck- 83

Mara, Daughter of the Nile- 78

Blood and Fur- 75

Voltron: Defenders of the Universe- 79

Me and My Shadow- 87

The Curse of Monkey Island- 82

Spark: Rising- 87

Flowers for Algernon- 96

White Hurricane- 90

The Provider- 66

Amulet- 79

The Truth About the Harry Quebert Affair- 86

Faces & Voices: The True Story of Milli Vanilli- 81

The Hunchback of Notre Dame- 88

ReBoot- 74

 

Extra congrats to the films that received all positive reviews:

Seeing Her, Mara, Daughter of the Nile, Me and My Shadow, The Curse of Monkey Island, Spark Rising, Flowers for Algernon, White Hurricane, The Truth About the Harry Quebert Affair, and The Hunchback of Notre Dame

[cookie]

The following films received perfect scores (a grade worth 100 points) from at least one outlet:

 

The SCP Foundation (Bastien's Twitter Reviews) [Final score: 80]

Seeing Her (Alpha's Reviews, Bastien's Twitter Reviews, Ethan Hunt Reviews, Rorschach's Reviews) [Final score: 91]

The Adventures of Scrooge McDuck (Bastien's Twitter Reviews, Spaghetti Kitchen) [Final score: 83]

Me and My Shadow (Bastien's Twitter Reviews, Rorschach's Reviews) [Final score: 87]

Spark: Rising (Ethan Hunt Reviews, Hiccup's Critical Review) [Final score: 87]

Public Eye (Hiccup's Critical Review) [Final score: 61]

Flowers for Algernon (Ethan Hunt Reviews, Bastien's Twitter Reviews, Spaghetti Kitchen, Rorschach's Reviews) [Final score: 96]

White Hurricane (Ethan Hunt Reviews, Hiccup's Critical Review) [Final score: 90]

Life is Strange (Hiccup's Critical Review, Spaghetti Kitchen) [Final score: 70]

The Whale (Ethan Hunt Reviews) [Final score: 60]

The Truth about the Harry Quebert Affair (Hiccup's Critical Review, Ethan Hunt Reviews) [Final score: 86]

The Hunchback of Notre Dame (Hiccup's Critical Review, Rorschach's Reviews) [Final score: 88]

Touching Spirit Bear (Bastien's Twitter Reviews) [Final score: 68]

Edited October 12, 2017 by cookie

[Ezen Baklattan]

I like how @cookie and @Xillix didn't give out a single perfect score.

[Xillix]

41 minutes ago, spaghetti! said:

I like how @cookie and @Xillix didn't give out a single perfect score.

I'm extremely stingy with five-star ratings even in real life because I don't want to "cheapen" it. I've been rating all the films I see theatrically on Letterboxd since last year and not counting re-releases I've only given out one 5-star rating.

[cookie]

The Review Aggregate Versus the Awards

 

Flowers for Algernon- 96 - 12 nominations (including Best Picture)

Seeing Her- 91 - 6 nominations (including Best Picture)

White Hurricane- 90 - 14 nominations (including Best Picture)

The Hunchback of Notre Dame- 88 - 15 nominations

Me and My Shadow- 87 - 6 nominations

Spark Rising- 87 - 15 nominations

The Truth About the Harry Quebert Affair- 86 - 5 nominations

The Adventures of Scrooge McDuck- 83 - 6 nominations (including Best Picture)

The Curse of Monkey Island- 82 - 4 nominations

Faces & Voices: The True Story of Milli Vanilli- 81 - 4 nominations (including Best Picture)

The SCP Foundation- 80 - 2 nominations

Voltron: Defenders of the Universe- 79 - 5 nominations

Amulet- 79 - 5 nominations

Mara, Daughter of the Nile- 78 - 3 nominations

Blood and Fur- 75 - 2 nominations

ReBoot- 74 - 1 nomination

Life is Strange- 70 - 4 nominations

He-Man- 68 - 1 nomination

SOMA- 68 - 1 nomination

The Yellow Wallpaper- 67 - 1 nomination

The Provider- 66 - 1 nomination

America!- 66 - 1 nomination

SWAT Kats: The Radical Squadron- 63 - 1 nomination

Jungles- 62 - 1 nomination

Rendezvous with Rama- 59 - 1 nomination

Trump's America- 41 - 1 nomination

 

 

Average score of the Best Picture nominees: 88

 

Average score of all nominees: 76

Edited October 17, 2017 by cookie