Yeah, almost every scene in the last half hour was a necessity. Sure the movie could have ended just fine with the ships sailing off, since that scene does indeed have a very definitive feel to it, but that wouldn't be true to the book ending which I think was important to PJ to stay true to. Plus it adds that nice "come full circle" from beginning to end touch.
The complaints of the ROTK ending dragging would be nowhere near as big as the complaints if the movie had just ended without resolution of all three main protagonist's arcs (Aragorn, Sam, and Frodo). And that's exactly what the movie took care of. When those 3 arcs were fully finished, it ended.
And that's where the trying too hard comes in. Also why not bring up the lack of marketing instead? Geez, does no one in the industry realize the importance of creating awareness anymore?
They may be trying a bit too hard but "threequelitis" (lol I'm totally calling it that now) is real though. That's why LOTR's still the ONLY franchise in history to not come down with it.
And let's just take this moment to bow in awe of that trilogy's masterful presence while we're all at it. Because it sure as hell bows to no one.
I thought it went pretty fast, especially since there really is under 15 minutes of action stuff. It went lightyears faster than reading the first half of that book. That was like a miserable 3 months process for me.
Speaking of Capote and since this thread can always use more derailment, I just watched Breakfast at Tiffany's for the first time the other day. Mickey Rooney... dear lord that was rough to watch.
That could be a factor, but the books themselves have to be factors too. THG is one of the franchises where virtually the whole fanbase agrees on what the best book is (CF) and what the worst book is (MJ). And then of course there's the part 1 effect too and that terrible lack of marketing. But I still thought this could hit 400 given we had no real movie "event" the whole year. Guess that's just the year it is though.
On an aside, LOTR will remain the only franchise in history to have its first three movies increase in admission. Pretty cool achievement to have to itself. Though there could be a chance Toy Story has done it too, but it's almost impossible to tell without knowing an exact 3D share for its entire run.
She was in TASM2!? Not ringing a bell at all. I guess that proves your point about how wasted she was.
Or was I just too wasted attempting to get through that movie? Hmm.