Who Gave Selina Kyle the better theme?

[pmoore]

Both are so gorgeous and effective, but I'd like y'alls opinion.

Batman Returns:

The Dark Knight Rises:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VfFNT97Lhyo

Edited July 21, 2012 by pmoore

[ddddeeee]

Zimmer's is nice and ambiguous, but he quite literally wrote three minutes of material for her, which is insulting.Elfman's manages to be tragic, insane and even sexy at the same time. One of his best.

[acsc1312]

Zimmer. It rivaled the joker's theme as one of the best character themes ever

[Darth Homer]

I haven't seen TDKR yet, but I doubt anything Catwoman-related in it will rival this:

Just the perfect marriage of visuals and music, telling a complete story with virtually no dialogue. Elfman and Burton both at their best. Edited July 22, 2012 by Darth Homer

[CoolioD1]

^ That's definitely the case. Nolan's catwoman is undoubtedly a great character but isn't nearly as great as Burton's Catwoman.Oh, and Zimmer's catwoman theme is effective for the character, but Elfman's is amazing. Gives me chills every time.

[JackO]

While it would have been easy to pick Zimmer, Elfmans theme brings up a ton more emotion and complexity then Zimmers. I think it is Elfman's by far.

[ddddeeee]

Zimmer's theme sounds like Elfman's Wolfman theme.http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-be3DFik_n8&feature=related