Very Good: B+
SPOILERS AHEAD
As an avid fan of the book trilogy (obsessively so) I found the film to be a reasonable reflection of the book and quite entertaining.
Things I really liked:
[*]Jennifer Lawrence. In the absence of the 1st person narrative she did a fantastic job of conveying Katniss’ vulnerability, distrust and outright rock solid determination.
[*]The reaping – my favorite scene in the movie.
[*]Snow's conversations with Crane and Crane's ultimate demise.
[*]Woody – didn’t think I’d like him but he really did a great job.
[*]Jennifer Lawrence (worth a second mention!)
Things I didn’t like:
[*]No explanation of the Mockingjay
[*]The arena is much easier on Katniss than in the book. In the book she nearly dies of dehydration, starvation, her injuries from the fire are more severe and she loses hearing in one ear from the blast. She also has to discern Haymitch’s messages without the aid of little paper notes.
[*]The 2nd rule change. In the book, the second they rescind the rule change allowing 2 victors, Katniss has an arrow trained on Peeta, showing her intense distrust.
[*]The end. In the book, Katniss reveals that she was just playing the game when pretending to be in love with Peeta. Not so in the movie. I suppose they want to cater to the “love triangle” crowd.
I could probably nitpick endlessly about the changes and omissions but they are inevitable; otherwise you’d need a mini-series, not a feature length film. I do, however, think a lot of the movie could be confusing and/or misunderstood if the viewer hasn't read the book.
Despite the nit-picking I still really enjoyed the movie (as did my wife) and look forward to what the director change and bigger budget can bring to Catching Fire.