BoxOffice.com's Top 10 Comic Book Movies Of All Time (2013) [Ranking thread]

[#ED]

THIS HAS NOW BEEN CHANGED TO A PRIVATE MESSAGE RESPONSE THREAD

I did this last year and it went well. I would like more users to participate this time around. Many users here have different taste when it comes to comic book movies. In 2013, we have seen several comic book movies which were not necessarily reviewed well but comic book movie viewers on this website enjoyed the films and praised some of them. Are they good enough to add to this list? We will find out.

I have changed the point system to make it much easier to score.

Top 10
10. 1 Pt
9. 2 Pts
8. 3 Pts
7. 4 Pts
6. 5 Pts
5. 6 Pts
4. 7 Pts
3. 8 Pts
2. 9 Pts
1. 10 Pts

As always, I prefer comments about your top 5 movies at least (you can do all 10).

Now to add some flavor to this topic this year we will add in a question(survey) and other small rankings.

Q. What makes a good comic book movie to you?(sticking to the the comics, special effects, story,etc)

Comic Book Movie Rankings:

List The Top 5 Comic Book Movies based on Special Effects
List The Top 5 Comic Book Movie Villains
List The Top 3 Comic Book Movies of 2013!

I have changed this to a Private Message thread so the ranks aren't easily figured out like last year. To make it easy, Just copy + Paste the format below. YOU CAN POST YOUR RANKINGS HERE IF YOU WISH BUT I WOULD PREFER A PM

Last Years List -
http://forums.boxoffice.com/index.php?/topic/7436-the-top-10-comic-book-movies-of-all-time-2012ranked-by-the-boxoffice-forums/
_______________________________________

Private Message Heading: Top 10 Comic Book Movies of All Time (2013)

Top 10 Comic Book Movies of All Time

10.

9.

8.

7.

6.

5.
-
-

4.
-
-

3.
-
-

2.
-
-

1.
-
-

Q. What makes a good comic book movie to you?(sticking to the the comics, special effects, story,etc)
A. -

Top 5 Comic Book Movies based on Special Effects
5.
4.
3.
2.
1.

Top 5 Comic Book Movie Villains
5.
4.
3.
2.
1.

The Top 3 Comic Book Movies of 2013
3.
2.
1.




DEADLINE: January 4th 12PM EST

USERS PARTICIPATED:
ChristmasFilms (change made)
Goffe
Telemachos
Walt Disney (change made)
Accursed Architect
The Stingray
Numbers
chasmmi
rukaio101
Punishment
Simionski
Blankments
Tarzan
Grey Ghost
B J
Crispylips
Druv10
Shantal
Panda
Bob Violence
Iceroll
WileECoyote
Dexter
Bob Violence
Fancyarcher
Algren
Ed
Jake Gittes
Bad cap
Johnny
Squaremaster
Jusssilic
Olive
Omario

Ecstacy

Spidey Freak

Empire

Letsuseournoggin

grim22

cory

Edited January 4, 2014 by #ED

[grim22]

I don't foresee anything going wrong in this thread. Not one thing. No sir, all fine here.

 

 

[The Stingray]

There aren't even 10 good comic book movies out there.

[Kvikk Lunsj]

Can graphic novels count?

[Sam]

My Top 10:

 

10. The Incredible Hulk

9. X-Men: The Last Stand

8. Ghostrider

7. X-Men Origins: Wolverine

6. Jonah Hex 

5. Daredevil

4. Elektra

3. Catwoman

2. Green Lantern

1. Batman and Robin

[The Stingray]

1. Batman (1989)

2. Oldboy

3. Batman Begins

4. Batman Returns

5. Sin City

6. X2

7. The Avengers

8. The Crow

9. Watchmen

10. Timecop

[rukaio101]

My Top 10:

 

10. The Incredible Hulk

9. X-Men: The Last Stand

8. Ghostrider

7. X-Men Origins: Wolverine

6. Jonah Hex 

5. Daredevil

4. Elektra

3. Catwoman

2. Green Lantern

1. Batman and Robin

Hey! The Incredible Hulk isn't that bad.... good.... good/bad..... It's a good movie, damn it!

Edited November 14, 2013 by rukaio101

[Sam]

Hey! The Incredible Hulk isn't that bad.... good.... good/bad..... It's a good movie, damn it!

But but... I put it in my Top 10, what more do you want? 

 

Just personal taste, I don't like it, I'm not a fan of either Bruce Banner or Hulk. And Ed Norton's portrayal don't do anything for me either. The only thing I like from the movie is Bruce/Betty relationship, that's pretty much it. 

 

It's definitely better than a lot more other comic book adaptations though but I didn't remember to list them then. It's better than the FF movies for examples. 

[DAR]

I just received exclusive access to the Squaremaster's list

 

1. The first five minutes of TDKR

2. The first five minutes of TDK

3. The first five minutes of BB

4. The middle hour of TDKR

5. The middle hour of TDK

6. The middle hour of BB

7. The final hour of TDKR

8. The final hour of TDK

9. The final hour of BB

10.The end credits of TDKR TDK and BB

[baumer]

That's a lot of work ED.  What, are we getting paid for this?  

[Dementeleus]

I'm going to avoid the usual titles, since they're gonna be over-represented here anyway. Here's my list:

 

1. Akira

2. Oldboy

3. Ghost World

4. The Crow

5. A History of Violence

6. V for Vendetta

7. The Rocketeer

8. The Mask

[#ED]

That's a lot of work ED.  What, are we getting paid for this?  

 

It's community work! 

[#ED]

I don't foresee anything going wrong in this thread. Not one thing. No sir, all fine here.

 

 

 

Ah yes. So the "PMs" are also meant to keep the fanboy troll fest away.

Edited November 14, 2013 by #ED

[#ED]

My Top 10:

 

10. The Incredible Hulk

9. X-Men: The Last Stand

8. Ghostrider

7. X-Men Origins: Wolverine

6. Jonah Hex 

5. Daredevil

4. Elektra

3. Catwoman

2. Green Lantern

1. Batman and Robin

 

Thanks for taking this serious Sam. 

[DAR]

I'll get a list later on.

[Walt Disney]

This is very complicated with all of the requirements. However, I am going to try to complete this.

 

Edit: I just did it and I was wrong. It was actually pretty easy to complete and it didn't take that much time.

Edited November 14, 2013 by Walt Disney

[rukaio101]

Are we counting Animated DC films and films based on manga (like Akira)?

[Walt Disney]

My Vote:

 

Top 10 Comic Book Movies of All Time

 

Please Note that I have a tie at number 3. I can not choose between those 2 movies despite seeing each of them between 20-30 times. Divide the points up any way that you wish.

 

10. Iron Man 3

 

9. Thor: The Dark World

 

8. Men In Black 2

 

7. Men in Black

 

6. Superman II

 

5. Iron Man

- A fun movie that was enjoyable

- A solid villain

 

3 tie. Iron Man 2

- Excellent comedy

- Lots of plots that all worked perfectly together

 

3 tie. Captain America: The First Avenger

- A fantastic Score.

-A superhero that was easy to relate to

 

2. The Dark Knight

- A wonderfully evil villain in The Joker

-A strong superhero finally defeating the powerful villain

 

1. The Avengers

- Had an epic feel with so many star superheroes in one movie

-Jam packed with action

 

Q. What makes a good comic book movie to you?(sticking to the the comics, special effects, story,etc)

A. – A good comic book movie has a strong superhero, a strong villain, is colorful like the comics, stays true to the spirit of the comics, is packed with comedy and action, has an epic Score with great theme music, and ends with the superhero suiting up and defeating the villain. It may seem like a lot of elements, but it’s a simple formula that can be repeated for a great comic book movie every time.

 

Top 5 Comic Book Movies based on Special Effects

5. Captain America: The First Avenger

4. Iron Man 2

3. Iron Man 3

2. Thor: The Dark World

1. The Avengers

 

Top 5 Comic Book Movie Villains

5. Whiplash

4. The Red Skull

3. Loki

2. General Zod (Terrence Stamp)

1. The Joker (Ledger)

 

The Top 3 Comic Book Movies of 2013

3. The Wolverine

2. Iron Man 3

1. Thor: The Dark World

Edited November 17, 2013 by Walt Disney

[CaptainJackSparrow]

I love your top four Disney!

[Accursed Arachnid!™]

Sent.