A good write-up on CinemaSins, Everything Wrong With... etc

[Jandrew]

I don t care if it is satire or not, all I hear is bored geeks nitpicking everything to death for their own demented pleasure.They must think of themselves as being so cool and edgy.

Solution: dont type in "Cinemasins" on youtube. I have no idea how thats so hard?

[Goffe]

Honest Trailers are funny, Cinemasins starts get boring after one video, but I don't mind them, they're harmless

 

I really like Honest Trailers and its Youtube channel, their videos are great and Hal Rudnick is very charismatic. Cinemasins is not fun or funny at all, but it's harmless, so who cares?

[Feracious]

I don't mind Cinemasins. They're not giving serious reviews, just a bunch of nitpicks that most people don't care about. I don't find them that funny but they're not offensive either. 

[Phil in the Blank]

I'm on the love Honest Trailers but don't really care for CinemaSins bandwagon. I'm also on the, it's not a problem with those videos but with people taking those videos as actual valid criticism bandwagon. And finally I'm on the if you don't find either channel funny then good for you but no need to critisize what other people enjoy bandwagon. 

Edited August 31, 2014 by Spottswoode

[John Marston]

I don't really have a problem with Honest Trailers as it is just for fun but sadly I know many people who are sheep who go like "I really liked that movie but after I watched the Honest Trailer I realized it actually sucks!" 

[ShouldIBeHere]

What I dislike about these videos is when they - more than just making fun - suggest whether a movie is actually good or not and venture into a weird form of reviewing.

 

But that article isn't much better by also calling out "definite" bad movies and movies which either deserve or don't deserve such videos.

 

 

After all, it is basically harmless stuff meant for fun... and some of them are indeed quite funny. Not enough to care for them, though.

[AniNate]

I think Game of Thrones is a great show, but its Honest Trailer is still the best so far. The series is at its best when it taps into relatable reactions that go beyond the overall quality of the product (ie catchy theme, the hatred of Joffrey, the overstuffed characters) For short, when it's actually HONEST, not just nitpicky

Edited June 1, 2015 by tribefan695

[ddddeeee]

My friend had me watch the 'Everything Wrong with' on Nightmare Before Christmas because he knows I love it and they were talking about how Jack and Sally couldn't have sex as if it were some huge flaw. This is a children's movie! These people actively look for things to nitpick.

[CoolioD1]

Yes, I'm sure that was indeed something they thought was a huge flaw in that movie. It is, after all, a very serious channel.

[CoolioD1]

I think there are legitimate complaints about these things, which can be pretty bad, but just about how they're kinda lame and not the funny, cool, post-modern takes that they think they are. The article is just kinda embarrassing and I usually like the dissolve.

[AniNate]

My friend had me watch the 'Everything Wrong with' on Nightmare Before Christmas because he knows I love it and they were talking about how Jack and Sally couldn't have sex as if it were some huge flaw. This is a children's movie! These people actively look for things to nitpick.

 

Even if it wasn't a kids movie, you don't have to come up with an explanation for everything; leave that to the fanfics.

Edited June 1, 2015 by tribefan695

[John Marston]

Honest Trailers is pretty funny. I laughed at a lot of them even if I liked the movie

 

however, what the hell are those "Everything Wrong With" videos about? Is it just some guy reading the IMDB's goof's list for a movie or something? What's the point? That sounds dumb as hell