Jump to content
Blankments

Y5 - Critical Consensus (Updated with Numbers' List!)

    Recommended Posts

    Here, we tabulate all the top 25 lists and put them into a general consensus.

    THE LISTS

    THE RANKINGS

    1. The Shark Mutiny – 166

    2. Dawn of Oblivion – 165

    3. Empty Hearth – 163

    4. The Eccentric Minds of Belmond Lane – 158

    5. Past Tense – 156

    6. The Dogs of Babel – 130

    7. Oro – 126

    8. The Next Dimension – 113

    9. Hindenburg – 105

    10. Celia, A Slave – 81

    11. StarCraft: The Fury of the Swarm – 78

    12. TIE: Dragon Age: Onslaught / Shiverin’ Gulch – 77

    14. Corso – 72

    15. Killer Husband – 68

    16. Khanh Bernarda Alba – 66

    17. Worlds Apart – 61

    18. Santa Claus: Ultimate Badass – 55

    19. Lucid – 54

    20. Nonexistence – 52

    21. Psychonauts – 49

    22. The Affair – 48

    23. SpellForce: Shadow of the Phoenix – 42

    24. The 39 Clues: Maze of Bones – 41

    25. Stories From Eden – 34

    26. Catharsis – 33

    27. The Fault in Our Stars – 32

    28. Paradise Lost – 31

    29. TIE: The Very Last First Time / Some Assembly Required – 27

    31. The Career Buster – 26

    32. Unbalanced 2 – 22

    33. The Once and Future King: The Sword in the Stone - 19

    34. The Penny Press – 16

    35. Edward Tulane – 14

    36. TIE: Chris Smith and the Island of Dinosaurs / Chuck Norris and Liam Neeson vs. Bigfoot – 12

    38. Summer Wars – 9

    39. TIE: Against All Odds / Everyman / Warcraft: The Cataclysm – 8

    42. TIE: Blue Beetle / Countdown / Rise of the Dead – 7

    45. TIE: Espionage Project / House of the Scorpion – 6

    47. Time Lapse – 5

    48. TIE: Candlelight / The Monster Mash – 4

    50. 4Chan: The Truth / The Red Pyramid / The Men of the Night - 2

    TOP 5 TRACKING

    In this part, we track the number of times a certain film has appeared in a top 5 list. This may be an interesting indiciator of what's playing for a best picture nomination. Note that these are making the assumption that people vote for their top 5 choices as BP nominees.

    6 Lists (Locked for a Nomination)

      [*]Dawn of Oblivion

    5 Lists (Should Be Nominated)

      [*]The Eccentric Minds of Belmond Lane

      [*]Past Tense

      [*]The Shark Mutiny

    4 Lists (The Odds Are Looking Good)

      [*]Empty Hearth

    3 Lists (Battling For The Final Spots)

    2 Lists (Unlikely, But Not Impossible)

      [*]Corso

      [*]The Dogs of Babel

      [*]Hindenburg

      [*]Oro

      [*]Santa Claus: Ultimate Badass

    1 List (One Nod Is Better Than None)

      [*]Catharsis

      [*]Killer Husband

      [*]Stories From Eden

      [*]Worlds Apart

    FUN FACTS

      [*]Most Points Without a #1: The Shark Mutiny

      [*]Least Points With A #1: Santa Claus: Ultimate Badass

      [*]Most Points For A Comedy: The Eccentric Minds of Belmond Lane

      [*]Most Points For An Animated Film: Shiverin' Gulch

      [*]Most Points For A Major Blockbuster: Dawn of Oblivion

      [*]Earliest Release To Recieve Points: Rise of the Dead

    Edited by Break-It Blank
    • Like 3
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Spaghetti's Haiku Reviews

      [*]Dawn Of Oblivion

      [*]Past Tense

      [*]The Shark Mutiny

      [*]The Eccentric Minds Of Belmond Lane

      [*]Empty Hearth

      [*]Worlds Apart

      [*]Shiverin’ Gulch

      [*]The Dogs Of Babel

      [*]The Next Dimension

      [*]Oro

      [*]The Very Last First Time

      [*]Kahn Bernarda Alba

      [*]Dragon Age: Awakening

      [*]Psychonauts

      [*]Starcraft: Fury Of The Swarm

      [*]The Affair

      [*]Summer Wars

      [*]Everyman

      [*]Corso

      [*]Celia, A Slave

      [*]The Fault In Our Stars

      [*]Hindenberg

      [*]Stories From Eden

      [*]Lucid

      [*]Nonexistence

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    The critical consensus seems to get more ambitious every year. :lol:

    I find winning the CC is about as rewarding as winning BP. When you win both, though, you know you have a truly great film. Like Black as Night did in Y3, and I think Good Die Young did it last year.
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    25. Red Pyramid24. Shivering Gulch23. Nonexistence22. The Career Buster21. Killer Husband20. Countdown19. Rise of the Dead18. Starcraft: The Fury of the Swarm16. Celia, A Slave17. SpellForce – Shadow of the Phoenix15. Unbalanced 214. Corso13. Dragon Age: Onslaught 12. Lucid11. The Affair10. Oro9. The Next Dimension8. Empty HearthTHE ECCENTRIC MINDS7. -----------of-------------------BELMOND LANE6. Past Tense5. Hindenburg4. Santa Claus: Ultimate Badass3. Catharsis2. The Shark Mutiny1. Dawn of Oblivion

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites



    • Recently Browsing   0 members

      • No registered users viewing this page.
    ×
    ×
    • Create New...

    Important Information

    By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Guidelines. Feel free to read our Privacy Policy as well.