When Harry Met Sally

[baumer]

Discuss

[Dark 33Legend of the Sith]

The greatest romantic comedy of all time.

A

[baumer]

I love a lot of Rob Reiner films, but none more than this."You made a woman meow?"10/10

[A Marvel Fanboy]

I need to see this ...

[baumer]

I need to see this ...

It's not even dated. Good scripts transcend the year they were made. This is one of them.

[A Marvel Fanboy]

"I will have what she is having" ... :lol:Great love romance. 10/10

Edited January 1, 2014 by firedeep

[DAR]

A great film. A

[Dementeleus]

One of the best romantic comedies in the last few decades. Often imitated but never equalled.

A

[Joel M]

Best romantic comedy of all time

[Noctis]

Forgettable, aside from the iconic diner scene. Was never invested in the characters and found the journey boring.

C

[baumer]

Forgettable, aside from the iconic diner scene. Was never invested in the characters and found the journey boring.

C

LOL, why does this not surprise me. I don't even know why, I just knew you wouldn't like this for some reason.

[Blankments]

I watched this movie tonight for the first time (I'm going to cut it for a duo for speech) and it was so great. Loved it, and I didn't know Billy Crystal could act honestly. Great movie. A+

[The Movie Man]

I watched this movie tonight for the first time (I'm going to cut it for a duo for speech) and it was so great. Loved it, and I didn't know Billy Crystal could act honestly. Great movie. A+

 

He really wasn't acting. That was the real him???

 

PS. The real name of the Movie, for your presentation to be actually correct is, when Harry Met and Fu*ked Sally Many Times 

Edited July 30, 2013 by West Hollywood

[ladyevenstar22]

Indeed best romantic comedy ever they don't do them like this ,the dialogue and acting flows flawlessly for me A+++++The first time I saw it , I was intrigued by idea of men and women not being able to be friends , I love that debate I thought the movie was really smart on all levels , the feel and look of it! I love how they grow as persons first apart then together as friends then more

[A Marvel Fanboy]

10/10 now for me

 

Best rom-com in Hollywood history.

[RobinHood26]

Fucking fantastic, superbly well written and hilarious, yet endearing at the same time.

 

Classic, it really is timeless. I can watch this movie 20 years later for the first time and it doesn't feel outdated. 

 

A- (92)

[baumer]

An incredibly sweet film.  This is one of the reasons Rob Reiner is one of the best directors of all time imo.  He took the beautiful script by Nora Ephron and made a stunningly realistic film based on his own pain.  Ephron wrote a lot of the script based on her experiences, but Reiner added a lot of subtle touches, like the setting of the football game when they discuss Mr. Zero, he coached Ryan on how to do the orgasm scene properly and he cast some very good actors in different roles.  This is certainly one of my favourite films of all time.

[Dark 33Legend of the Sith]

It's not even dated. Good scripts transcend the year they were made. This is one of them.

 

Totally agree.  Outside of the clothes they were, the movie will always be relevant and something people can relate to.

[Jake Gittes]

One of the great romantic comedies. I almost waited for it to go off the rails at some point, because I wasn't sure it would stick the landing, but it remained funny and intelligent right up until the last frames. Sure, the desperate run Crystal does in the end is a cliché, but this is one of the few movies that actually earns it. And it's hardly dated at all, which is really remarkable the more you think about it, and has to be the result of Ephron's and Reiner's honesty. I mean, it's a glossy and polished movie, but there's practically no bullshit in it, it's not manufactured studio crap, it's not naive or pandering. Its take on gender relations is actually more honest, healthy and smart than that of most romcoms being produced right now.

Edited July 14, 2014 by Jake Gittes

[baumer]

You made a woman meow?