When I was younger, I think I felt movie magic more often. I've seen some art films from the Criteron Collection that affected me deeply, but I'm not sure if I count that as movie magic.
I will say that I definitely felt it when I saw the train sequence from Zootopia for the first time. I'm not even going to say which specific parts, in case someone want to be surprised.
Hell, I even saw a lot of those scenes on youtube, but it's a new experience altogether to see it on a cinema screen, even a small one.