OK, guys, performers, underperformers and overperformers are not based on budget only. I get that when overhyped movie doesn`t meet xpectations, fans like to throw the "but the budget wasn`t big" card to show their favorite is a success although industry doesn`t perceive it as such. Every movie is individual case so individual situation has to be taken into consideration. It goes beyond budget and hype. There`s also accessibility. Just because Johnny Depp is in it, it doesn`t mean that Sweeney Todd is expected to post POTC numbers. Another one is awards potential. Some movies are made for awards and studios know they may lose money (which they`ll cover with some tentpole, no problem). Another big one is merchnadise, the sole reason why narnia keeps churning out movies. Etc.