BOF's Top 100 Animated Films of All Time (Tabulating scores, you can still PM me why you included some movies)

[BadAtGender]

Can I get a scoring scheme clarification?

 

11-15:   25

16-20:   22

26-30:   20

31-35:   18

36-40:   1545-50:   13

 

What are 21-25 and 41-44 worth?

Edited August 3, 2014 by DamienRoc

[iceroll]

 

Can I get a scoring scheme clarification?

 

 

What are 21-25 and 41-44 worth?

 

Whoops, 21 and 14 respectively.

[iceroll]

Any new lists? Could this be pinned soon?

[Spidey Freak]

Let's see how big my list turns out to be.1. Aladdin2. Frozen/Princess Mononoke tie (can't choose. If a tie is not allowed then give Anna and Elsa the edge over Ashitaka)4. Toy Story 35. Toy Story6. The Little Mermaid7. The Incredibles8. ParaNorman9. Mulan10. Shrek11. Toy Story 212. Whisper of the Heart13. The Nightmare Before Christmas14. Wreck-It Ralph15. Ratatouille16. Batman: Under the Red Hood17. Finding Nemo18. Lilo and Stitch19. Shrek 220. The Iron Giant21. Monsters Inc.22. Mary and Max23. How to Train Your Dragon24. Akira25. Spirited Away26. Pinocchio27. The Emperor's New Groove28. My Neighbour Totoro29. Waking Life30. Coraline31. The Lion King32. Batman: Mask of Phantasm33. Beauty and the Beast34. Corpse Bride35. Rango36. Grave of the Fireflies37. Tangled38. Wall-E39. Kiki's Delivery Service40. The Hunchback of Notre Dame41. Batman Beyond: Return of the Joker42. Sleeping Beauty43. 101 Dalmatians44. The Land Before Time45. Snow White and the Seven Dwarves46. Mary Poppins47. Justice League: The Flashpoint Paradox48. Who Framed Roger Rabbit?49. Alice in Wonderland50. The Jungle Book51. The Simpsons Movie52. Anastasia53. Bambi54. Kung Fu Panda55. Prince of Egypt56. The Lego Movie57. Hercules58. Cinderella59. Dumbo60. Space Jam61. Lady and the Tramp62. All Dogs Go To Heaven63. How to Train Your Dragon 264. Mr. Peabody and Sherman65. Arthur Christmas66. Bolt67. The Croods68. Enchanted69. Atlantis: The Lost Empire70. Rama: Prince of Light71: The Princess and the Frog72. The Rescuers Down Under73. Tarzan74. The Last Unicorn75. The Halloween Tree76. Ferngully: The Last Rainforest77. Treasure Planet78. Fantasia 200079. Up80. Fantasia81. Justice League: The New Frontier82. Peter Pan83. Kung Fu Panda 284. Meet the Robinsons85. Batman/Superman: World's Finest86: Batman: The Dark Knight Returns Pt. I87. Cloudy With a Chance of Meatballs88. Despicable Me89. Monster House90. Spirit: Stallion of the Cimarron91. A Bug's Life92. Monsters University93. James and the Giant Peach94. Batman: Subzero95. Wonder Woman96. Batman: The Dark Knight Returns Pt. II97. Madagascar 398. Batman: Year One99. Rise of the Guardians100. Epic101. Ice Age102. The Lion King 2: Simba's Pride (what? Joss Whedon's co-written the villainess song in the movie).103. Megamind104. Guardians of Ga'Hoole (Legend of the Guardians/Owl movie)

Edited August 17, 2014 by Spidey Freak

[Omni]

1.   Alice in Wonderland (1951)2.   Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs (1937)3.   Pinocchio (1940)

4.   Aladdin (1992)5.   Beauty and the Beast (1991)6.   The Lion King (1994)7.   Toy Story 3 (2010)8.   Cinderella (1950)9.   Monsters, Inc. (2001)10.   101 Dalmatians (1961)11.   Nightmare Before Christmas (1994)

12.   Tarzan (1999)13.   The Hunchback of Notre-Dame (1996)14.   The Little Mermaid (1989)15.   Monsters vs Aliens (2009)16.   Wall-E (2008)17.   Ratatouille (2007)18.   Frozen (2013)19.   The Secret of Nimh (1982)20.   The Incredibles (2004)21.   Toy Story 2 (1999)

22.   The Rescuers (1977)23.   Finding Nemo (2003)24.   Toy Story (1995)25.   Hercules (1997)26.   Brave (2012)27.   A Bug’s Life (1998)28.   Mulan (1998)29.   The Great Mouse Detective (1986)30.   The Sword in the Stone (1963)31.   Wreck-it Ralph! (2012)32.   Rapunzel (2010) 

[Feracious]

[*]Spirited Away

[*]Up

[*]Monster's Inc

[*]The Incredibles

[*]Beauty and the Beast

[*]Aladdin

[*]Coraline

[*]Wallace and Gromit: Curse of the Were-Rabbit

[*]Shrek

[*]Lion King

[*]The Little Mermaid

[*]Kung Fu Panda

[*]Toy Story

[*]Shrek 2

[*]Wall-E

[*]The LEGO Movie

[*]Toy Story 3

[*]Kung Fu Panda 2

[*]The Nightmare Before Christmas

[*]Tangled

[*]Mulan

[*]Toy Story 2

[*]Ratatouille

[*]Frozen

[*]Princess Mononoke

[*]Tarzan

[*]FrankenWeenie

[*]ParaNorman

[*]The Jungle Book

[*]Pinocchio

[iceroll]

12 Days left!

[Empire]

I updated my list of top 50 on the first page. 

[Wrath]

1. Finding Nemo
2. Incredibles

3. Up

4. Shrek
5. Toy Story 3
6. Spirited Away

7. Lego Movie
8. Kung Fu Panda

9. South Park:  Bigger, Longer

10. Toy Story
11. Iron Giant
12. Aladdin

13. Who Framed Roger Rabbit
14. Tangled

15. Wallace and Grommit: Were Rabbit
16. Toy Story 2
17. Monsters Inc

18. The Triplets of Belleville
19. Frozen
20. Lion King

21. Little Mermaid

22. Wreck-It Ralph

23. Coraline
24. Chicken Run
25. Wall-E
26. Shrek 2

27. Madagascar
28. Princess and the Frog

29. All Dogs go to Heaven

30. Brave

31. Polar Express

32. How to Train your Dragon

33. Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs

34. Mary Poppins

35. Despicable Me

36. Mulan

37. Cinderella

38. Akira

39. Hercules

40. Howl's Moving Castle

41. Rescuers

42. Enchanted

43. Sleeping Beauty

44. Tintin

45. Snow White

46. Cars

47. Black Cauldron

48. Ratatouile

49. Peter Pan

50. Happy Feet

 

There, that's enough.

 

 

 

 

 

21. Monsters Inc.
22. Mary and Max
23. How to Train Your Dragon
24. Akira
25. Spirited Away
26. Pinocchio
27. The Emperor's New Groove
28. My Neighbour Totoro
29. Waking Life
30. Coraline

31. The Lion King
32. Batman: Mask of Phantasm
33. Beauty and the Beast
34. Corpse Bride
35. Rango
36. Grave of the Fireflies
37. Tangled
38. Wall-E
39. Kiki's Delivery Service
40. The Hunchback of Notre Dame

41. Batman Beyond: Return of the Joker
42. Sleeping Beauty
43. 101 Dalmatians
44. The Land Before Time
45. Snow White and the Seven Dwarves
46. Mary Poppins
47. Justice League: The Flashpoint Paradox
48. Who Framed Roger Rabbit?
49. Alice in Wonderland
50. The Jungle Book

51. The Simpsons Movie
52. Anastasia
53. Bambi
54. Kung Fu Panda
55. Prince of Egypt
56. The Lego Movie
57. Hercules
58. Cinderella
59. Dumbo
60. Space Jam

61. Lady and the Tramp
62. All Dogs Go To Heaven
63. How to Train Your Dragon 2
64. Mr. Peabody and Sherman
65. Arthur Christmas
66. Bolt
67. The Croods
68. Enchanted 
69. Atlantis: The Lost Empire
70. Rama: Prince of Light

71: The Princess and the Frog
72. The Rescuers Down Under
73. Tarzan
74. The Last Unicorn
75. The Halloween Tree
76. Treasure Planet
77. Fantasia 2000
78. Up
79. Fantasia
80. Justice League: The New Frontier

81. Peter Pan
82. Kung Fu Panda 2
83. Brave
84. Batman/Superman: World's Finest
85: Batman: The Dark Knight Returns Pt. I
86. Despicable Me
87. A Bug's Life
88. Monsters University
89. James and the Giant Peach
90. Batman: Subzero

91: Wonder Woman
92: Batman: The Dark Knight Returns Pt. II
93. Madagascar 3
94. Batman: Year One
95: Epic
96: Ice Age 
97. Megamind
98. Son of Batman
99. Batman/Superman: Public Enemies
100. The Lion King 2: Simba's Pride (what? Joss Whedon's co-written the villainess song in the movie). 

[mahnamahna]

[*]Toy Story 2

[*]Beauty and the Beast

[*]Toy Story 3

[*]Aladdin

[*]Toy Story

[*]Dumbo

[*]Finding Nemo

[*]The Lion King

[*]Shrek

[*]The Incredibles

[*]The LEGO Movie

[*]Frozen

[*]Monsters Inc

[*]Wreck it Ralph

[*]Wallace and Gromit - The Curse of the Wererabbit

[*]Shrek 2

[*]Who Framed Roger Rabbit?

[*]Mary Poppins

[*]Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs

[*]The Little Mermaid

[*]The SpongeBob SquarePants Movie

[*]Up

[*]Enchanted 

[*]South Park: Bigger, Longer and Uncut 

[*]A Bug's Life

[*]The Simpsons Movie

[*]Rango

[*]Kiki's Delivery Service

[*]Horton Hears a Who

[*]Tangled

[*]Chicken Run

[*]My Neighbor Totoro

[*]Peter Pan

[*]The Iron Giant

[*]Lady and the Tramp

[*]The Land Before Time

[*]The Jungle Book

[*]Cinderella 

[*]Despicable Me

[*]WALL-E

[*]Cars 

[*]Coraline 

[*]The Rugrats Movie

[*]The Nightmare Before Christmas 

[*]101 Dalmatians

[*]Rugrats in Paris

[*]How to Train Your Dragon

[*]Despicable Me 2

[*]Kung Fu Panda

[*]Madagascar

[*]The Prince of Egypt

[*]Oliver and Company

[*]Lilo and Stitch 

[*]Meet the Robinsons

[*]The Great Mouse Detective

[*]Ratatouille

[*]The Rescuers

[*]Madagascar 2

[*]The Aristocats

[*]Flushed Away

[*]The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh

[*]Bolt

[*]Winnie the Pooh

[*]An American Tail

[*]Pokemon 3

[*]Jimmy Neutron - Boy Genius

[*]Monster House

[*]The Sword in the Stone

[*]Charlotte's Web

[*]The Fox and the Hound

[*]Pokemon 4Ever

[*]The Rescuers Down Under

[*]Bee Movie

[*]Surf's Up

[*]Monsters University 

[*]Ice Age - The Meltdown

[*]Cars 2

[*]Hotel Transylvania

[*]Space Jam

[*]Hercules

[*]The Hunchback of Notre Dame 

[*]Tarzan

[*]Over the Hedge 

[*]Scooby-Doo on Zombie Island

[*]The Care Bears Movie 

[*]ParaNorman

[*]Corpse Bride

[*]Chicken Little

[*]The Croods

[*]Open Season

[*]Arthur Christmas

[*]Rise of the Guardians

[*]Looney Tunes - Back in Action 

[*]Pokemon - The First Movie 

[*]Spirit - Stallion of the Cimarron 

[*]Rugrats Go Wild 

[*]The Wild Thornberry Movie 

[*]Brave

[*]Shrek the Third 

[*]Happy Feet 

I'll finish later

 

Still have an embarrassing amount of animated films I haven't seen

 

Spirited Away

Howl's Moving Castle

Princess Mononoke 

Whisper of the Heart

Porco Russo

The Cat Returns

Ponyo

Ghost in the Shell

Batman - Mask of the Phantasm

Akira

The Secret World of Arriety

The Wind Rises

Grave of the Fireflies

Castle in the Sky

Naussica and the Valley of the Wind

The Last Unicorn

The Secret of Nimh 

Fantasia 

The Adventures of Ichabod and Mr. Toad

Alice in Wonderland

Watership Down

Fritz the Cat

The Lord of the Rings

Wizards 

The Black Cauldron 

Mulan

The Princess and the Frog 

The Pirates - Band of Misfits 

Frankenweenie 

How to Train Your Dragon 2

Mr. Peabody and Sherman 

Edited August 6, 2014 by mahnamahna

[Spidey Freak]

Damn, I completely forgot about Meet The Robinsons and Ferngully. Updated my list. 

[iceroll]

1. Finding Nemo

2. Incredibles

3. Up

4. Shrek

5. Toy Story 3

6. Spirited Away

7. Lego Movie

8. Kung Fu Panda

9. South Park: Bigger, Longer

10. Toy Story

11. Iron Giant

12. Aladdin

13. Who Framed Roger Rabbit

14. Tangled

15. Wallace and Grommit: Were Rabbit

16. Toy Story 2

17. Monsters Inc

18. The Triplets of Belleville

19. Frozen

20. Lion King

21. Little Mermaid

22. Wreck-It Ralph

23. Coraline

24. Chicken Run

25. Wall-E

26. Shrek 2

27. Madagascar

28. Princess and the Frog

29. All Dogs go to Heaven

30. Brave

31. Polar Express

32. How to Train your Dragon

33. Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs

34. Mary Poppins

35. Despicable Me

36. Mulan

37. Cinderella

38. Akira

39. Hercules

40. Howl's Moving Castle

41. Rescuers

42. Enchanted

43. Sleeping Beauty

44. Tintin

45. Snow White

46. Cars

47. Black Cauldron

48. Ratatouile

49. Peter Pan

50. Happy Feet

There, that's enough.

21. Monsters Inc.

22. Mary and Max

23. How to Train Your Dragon

24. Akira

25. Spirited Away

26. Pinocchio

27. The Emperor's New Groove

28. My Neighbour Totoro

29. Waking Life

30. Coraline

31. The Lion King

32. Batman: Mask of Phantasm

33. Beauty and the Beast

34. Corpse Bride

35. Rango

36. Grave of the Fireflies

37. Tangled

38. Wall-E

39. Kiki's Delivery Service

40. The Hunchback of Notre Dame

41. Batman Beyond: Return of the Joker

42. Sleeping Beauty

43. 101 Dalmatians

44. The Land Before Time

45. Snow White and the Seven Dwarves

46. Mary Poppins

47. Justice League: The Flashpoint Paradox

48. Who Framed Roger Rabbit?

49. Alice in Wonderland

50. The Jungle Book

51. The Simpsons Movie

52. Anastasia

53. Bambi

54. Kung Fu Panda

55. Prince of Egypt

56. The Lego Movie

57. Hercules

58. Cinderella

59. Dumbo

60. Space Jam

61. Lady and the Tramp

62. All Dogs Go To Heaven

63. How to Train Your Dragon 2

64. Mr. Peabody and Sherman

65. Arthur Christmas

66. Bolt

67. The Croods

68. Enchanted

69. Atlantis: The Lost Empire

70. Rama: Prince of Light

71: The Princess and the Frog

72. The Rescuers Down Under

73. Tarzan

74. The Last Unicorn

75. The Halloween Tree

76. Treasure Planet

77. Fantasia 2000

78. Up

79. Fantasia

80. Justice League: The New Frontier

81. Peter Pan

82. Kung Fu Panda 2

83. Brave

84. Batman/Superman: World's Finest

85: Batman: The Dark Knight Returns Pt. I

86. Despicable Me

87. A Bug's Life

88. Monsters University

89. James and the Giant Peach

90. Batman: Subzero

91: Wonder Woman

92: Batman: The Dark Knight Returns Pt. II

93. Madagascar 3

94. Batman: Year One

95: Epic

96: Ice Age

97. Megamind

98. Son of Batman

99. Batman/Superman: Public Enemies

100. The Lion King 2: Simba's Pride (what? Joss Whedon's co-written the villainess song in the movie).

Wait how does your list work? You go to 50 then start at 20 again.

[grey ghost]

1) Transformer The Movie

2) Redline

3) Over the Hedge

4) Aladdin

5) Ratatouille

6) Pinocchio

7) Wreck-It-Ralph

8) Akira

9) The Little Mermaid

10) The Incredibles

11) Fantasia (1940)

12) Ponyo

13) Who Framed Roger Rabbits

14) Waking Life

15) Spirited Away

[Wrath]

Wait how does your list work? You go to 50 then start at 20 again.

 

Oops, my bad.  I copy-pasted Spidey Freak's format to get myself started and then failed to delete a big chunk of it after I was done. I meant to delete everything after "There, that's enough."

[iceroll]

10 more days!

[DAJK]

1. Tarzan

2. The Lion King

3. Beauty and the Beast

4. Dinosaur

5. Incredibles

6. Nemo

7. Snow White

8. Toy Story

9. Wreck it Ralph

10. Bugs Life

11. How to Train Your Dragon

12. Arthur Christmas

13. Spirit

14. Up

15. Kung Fu Panda

16. Spirited Away

17. The Simpsons Movie

18. The SpongeBob Squarepants Movie

19. The LEGO Movie

20. Aladdin

21. Bambi

22. Ratatouille

23. Toy Story 3

24. Monsters Inc.

25. Wall-E

26. Frozen

27. Shrek

28. Shrek 2

29. Toy Story 2

30. Ice Age

31. Ice Age 3

32. Madagascar

33. Tangled

34. Little Mermaid

35. Tigger Movie

36. Jungle Book

37. Cloudy With a Chance of Meatballs

38. Monsters University

39. Despicable Me

40. Puss In Boots

41. Madagascar 2

42. Kung Fu Panda 2

43. How to Train Your Dragon 2

44. Bother Bear

45. The Land Before Time

46. The Lorax

47. Cinderella

48. Pinocchio 

49. The Croods

50. Surfs Up

51. Polar Express

52. Para Norman

53. Lilo and Stitch

54. MegaMind

55. Despicable Me 2

56. Over the Hedge

57. Madagascar 3

58. Shrek 3

59. Lion King 2

60. Shark Tale

[iceroll]

I think I have around 30 lists so far, that's pretty good and the pin to this subforum helped a lot.  Let's see if we can get to 50!

 

Here are some good lists for inspiration:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_highest-grossing_animated_filmshttp://www.film4.com/special-features/top-lists/top-25-animated-filmshttp://uk.ign.com/articles/2010/06/25/top-25-animated-movies-of-all-timehttp://www.totalfilm.com/features/50-greatest-animated-movieshttp://www.timeout.com/newyork/film/the-100-best-animated-movieshttp://www.imdb.com/search/title?genres=animation&num_votes=1000,&sort=user_rating,desc&title_type=featurehttp://www.rottentomatoes.com/top/bestofrt/top_100_animation_movies/?category=2

[celticmoon]

Well, that was hard. Did a lot of cutting. While making the list, I realized there are a lot of movies I need to re-watch and films that are on my list to watch that I haven't gotten around to yet (some are actually in my DVD/BD collection waiting to be watched). So this is surely an incomplete list, and one that will definitely be quite different whenever I compile it.... And I'm sure I've missed something, but here it is:

 

1. Pinocchio

2. Toy Story

3. Princess Mononoke

4. The Incredibles

5. My Neighbor Totoro

6. Fantasia

7. Who Framed Rogger Rabbit

8. Aladdin

9. Ratatouille

10. Grave of the Fireflies

 

11. The Lion King

12. Beauty and the Beast

13. Bambi

14. The King and the Mockingbird

15. Mind Game

16. Lilo & Stitch

17. Toy Story 2

18. Toy Story 3

19. Wolf Children

20. Castle in the Sky

 

21. How to Train Your Dragon 2

22. Shrek

23. Fantastic Mr. Fox

24. The LEGO Movie

25. Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs

26. Evangelion 2.0 You Can (Not) Advance

27. Ernest & Celestine

28. The Triplets of Belleville

29. The Nightmare Before Christmas

30. Mary Poppins

 

31. Tangled

32. Wreck-It Ralph

33. Spirited Away

34. Monsters, Inc.

35. Puella Magi Madoka Magica The Movie Part III: The Rebellion Story

36. Enchanted

37. How to Train Your Dragon

38. Nausicaa of the Valley of the Wind

39. Kirikou and the Sorceress

40. Night on the Galactic Railroad

 

41. The End of Evangelion

42. Only Yesterday

43. Porco Rosso

44. One Piece The Movie: Baron Omatsuri and the Secret Island

45. The Girl Who Leapt Through Time

46. The Painting

47. My Neighbors the Yamadas

48. Mary and Max

49. When the Wind Blows

50. Tokyo Godfathers

 

51. ParaNorman

52. 101 Dalmatians

53. Shrek 2

54. Sleeping Beauty

55. The Illusionist

56. The Prince of Egypt

57. Whisper of the Heart

58. WALL-E

59. Finding Nemo

60. The Little Mermaid

 

61. Kiki’s Delivery Service

62. The Hunchback of Notre Dame

63. Kung-Fu Panda 2

64. The Emperor’s New Groove

65. Wallace and Gromit: The Curse of the Were-Rabbit

66. Kung-Fu Panda

67. Millennium Actress

68. Angel’s Egg

69. Alice in Wonderland

70. Cinderella

 

71. The Jungle Book

72. Evangelion 1.0 You Are (Not) Alone

73. Coraline

74. Ponyo

75. The Secret World of Arietty

76. Tarzan

77. Doraemon Movie: Nobita and the Steel Troops

78. A Cat in Paris

79. The Princess and the Frog

80. The Croods

 

81. Frozen

82. Up

83. Pom Poko

84. Chicken Run

85. Persepolis

86. Yellow Submarine

87. The Iron Giant

88. The Secret of Kells

89. Peter Pan

90. Rango

 

91. Mulan

92. The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh

93. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs

94. Dumbo

95. Winnie the Pooh (2011)

96. The Wind Rises

97. Howl’s Moving Castle

98. Gulliver’s Travels

99. Azur & Asmar

100. Mr. Bug Goes to Town

[Breakspear]

1. WALL-E

2. Up

3. Spirited Away

4. Toy Story 3

5. The Lion King

6. Finding Nemo

7. Toy Story 2

8. The Incredibles

9. Ratatouille 

10. South Park: Bigger, Longer and Uncut

11. Toy Story

12. Frozen

13. Princess Mononoke 

14. Shrek 2

15. How to Train your Dragon

16. The Lego Movie

17. The Little Mermaid

18. Mulan

19. The Jungle Book

20. Monsters Inc. 

21. Brave

22. Wreck it Ralph

23. Tangled

24. Akira

25. The Iron Giant

26. Aladdin

27. Snow White

28. Sleeping Beauty

29. Bambi

30. Shrek

 

I could update this more. 

[narniadis]

If I can come up with some time I will submit mine tomorrow