Overall, not bad, but its still far from being anything memorable.
PROS:
-Unsurprisingly, Del Toro's visual style. Costumes & set are fucking great.
-Acting is great. loved Chastain & Wasikowska were standouts for me.
CONS:
-I know how Del Toro's said "its not a ghost story, but a story with ghosts" but still, the ghosts here aren't scary at all. They're clearly cgi, and not very convincing cgi at that. Their scenes were too brief to have any real impact on me.
-Emotionally, it didn't really connect to me either. I can't put it exactly into words.
-For me it was slow..3rd act was kinda worth it though.
Audience response:
Some people left in the middle. Clearly some were expecting all-out horror, and that may affect its box-office dearly.
Anyway, at least it looks good and the actors work with what they have. But its a step down from Del toro's past works, IMO.
2/4