I'll be doing th e major blockbusters.
Too high:
DMC: 54% is nothing to write home about, but DMC is by far the worst of the Pirates and so utterly boring. Aside from a few scenes + Davy Jones, this film was a gigantic mess (the cannibal island sequence was appalling). It deserved somewhere around 30-40%.
TPM/AoTC: They both have 61% and 65% on RT (but, thankfully, 40% each with the Top Critics). The first is one of the worst blockbusters ever made and so mind-boggingly childish and stupid. Terrible acting, horrible dialogue, and a ridiculous storyline. The latter is an improvement, but it features one of the worst acting I've ever seen on film. Plus, massive WTF at how calm Padme was and justified Anakin's actions when he murdered everyone on wherever his mother was. TPM deserved maybe 10% and AoTC around 40%.
ANH: Boring, bland, and forgettable. Deserved 60%.
RoTK: Trust me, I do enjoy this film, but it is pales badly when compared to its two predecessors. It's still a good film, but it didn't deserve the acclaim it got. Deserved 80%.
Will continue later, but I have to go.