James' Top 50 Of The Decade So Far (It all ends here...)

[Avatree]

i'm done with this stupid argument. It doesn't matter how much of a fan anyone is - if you think that it's a "fact" that one movie is better than another, then you can't be reasoned with.

[Empire]

Yeah, I also agree with him to some extent, but I was referring to this

 

 

it's almost like James level of wrong.

I actually agreed with that part.

[Dementeleus]

Congrats to James for generating 15 pages of discussion, certainly!

[Avatree]

20% of what?

Deathly Hallows 2 made 960M overseas

Star Wars: The Clone Wars made 33M overseas

 

That's 3.4%! Not even close to 20%! Can't you see how much bigger Harry Potter is, Tele?! DUH.

[James]

Congrats to James for generating 15 pages of discussion, certainly!

My thread is more controversial than Noctis'.

[4815162342]

This is an important discussion. apparently when we figure out which is more popular the other will be taken away forever.

There can be only one

[Empire]

No. I know for a fact that Potter is better.

There is no fact as it's all opinion. Harry Potter is way better than the PT though.

[Dementeleus]

My thread is more controversial than Noctis'.

 

Then again, Noctis' list is totally stalled at the moment.

[James]

There can be only one

 

[James]

Then again, Noctis' list is totally stalled at the moment.

Maybe, but just wait for my comment on POTC4 being better than all SW movies together We we'll have WAAAAARRRR....

[Empire]

Maybe, but just wait for my comment on POTC4 being better than all SW movies together We we'll have WAAAAARRRR....

[The Futurist]

[Goffe]

I actually agreed with that part.

Even if you don't like what Zimmer wrote, there is still the wonderful stuff written by James Newton Howard, that alone makes TDK music better than the average generic action score.

Besides, I don't think Nolan would bring Zimmer back, for TDK and TDKR (ditching JNH in the process), if the scores were so generic like Dash is saying.

[The Futurist]

George Lucas is wealthier than J. K. Rowling.

 

Take that Potter heads !!!

[dashrendar44]

Even if you don't like what Zimmer wrote, there is still the wonderful stuff written by James Newton Howard, that alone makes TDK music better than the average generic action score.

Besides, I don't think Nolan would bring Zimmer back, for TDK and TDKR (ditching JNH in the process), if the scores were so generic like Dash is saying.

 

Maybe Nolan is also as tone-deaf as he is colorblind...JNH circles all around Zimmer in terms of musical knowledge and composition wise, no contest.

Edited February 19, 2015 by Red Room of Dash

[Goffe]

There is no fact as it's all opinion. Harry Potter is way better than the PT though.

HP is better because they're all fresh on RT, SW has one rotten movie. 

 

that settles it!   

[The Futurist]

Harry Potter : Foreshadowing : The Saga

[Empire]

Even if you don't like what Zimmer wrote, there is still the wonderful stuff written by James Newton Howard, that alone makes TDK music better than the average generic action score.

Besides, I don't think Nolan would bring Zimmer back, for TDK and TDKR (ditching JNH in the process), if the scores were so generic like Dash is saying.

I like what he wrote, but I feel it could have fit & worked in a number of films. All of Williams work only works in the movie he wrote the scores for.

[James]

Maybe Nolan is also as tone-deaf as he is colorblind...JNH circles all around Zimmer in terms of musical knowledge and composition wise, no contest.

Zimmer's score on Pirates is pretty much better than everything Williams ever did in terms of greatness. It just gets stuck in your head.

[dashrendar44]

Zimmer's score on Pirates is pretty much better than everything Williams ever did in terms of greatness. It just gets stuck in your head.