BOT Top 100 Animated Films of all time - 24hours left to get votes in...

[cannastop]

Honestly, one of the reasons why I wanted to do a short list at first was so I could hide the movies I haven't watched.

[chasmmi]

20 minutes ago, cannastop said:

Honestly, one of the reasons why I wanted to do a short list at first was so I could hide the movies I haven't watched.

 

There will always be something you've never seen that you should have though. Even if it's a style genre you love.

 

In animation for me, there are still 16 Official WDAS films I have not seen out of 55 (they come in three blocks: everything from Saludos Amigos to Ichabod and toad, Black Cauldron and Basil and finally Brother Bear to Princess and the Frog (oh throw in Fantasia 2000 and dinosaur too)

 

There are one or two DreamWorks I missed.

 

A whole bunch of Other USA stuff and let's not even get started on Japan... I have seen 5 films from Ghibli and despite really liking to loving 4 of them (and hating the 5th), I haven't got round to watching any others.

 

 

 

 

 

[Jason]

1 hour ago, cannastop said:

Honestly, one of the reasons why I wanted to do a short list at first was so I could hide the movies I haven't watched.

 

You've watched more than me, I'm at 49 total. (Not all of which I'm sure all include on a final list.) Going to try to watch as many as I can of the reputably good ones I've missed by the end of September though.

[cannastop]

Just now, Jason said:

 

You've watched more than me, I'm at 49 total. (Not all of which I'm sure all include on a final list.) Going to try to watch as many as I can of the reputably good ones I've missed by the end of September though.

Well, the list I have isn't a complete list of all the animated features I've seen.

[Jason]

Just now, cannastop said:

Well, the list I have isn't a complete list of all the animated features I've seen.

Mhmm, I figured since at a very minimum HTTYD2 isn't on that list. Weird coincidence that the number you happen to have felt worthy of a list (thus far) happens to be the total number I've watched (thus far).

[chasmmi]

For easier to find animations, Book of Life is surprisingly excellent and really recommendable. I actually doubt that even Pixar will be able to pull off Day of the Dead better with Coco.

[cannastop]

5 minutes ago, Jason said:

Mhmm, I figured since at a very minimum HTTYD2 isn't on that list. Weird coincidence that the number you happen to have felt worthy of a list (thus far) happens to be the total number I've watched (thus far).

I don't know if I could even give an exact number of all the animated features I've watched.

As for the list itself, I'm doing an informal calculation between how much lasting impact a movie has and how recently I've seen it. For example, I haven't seen Pinocchio since I was 7, but I feel strongly that it deserves a top 10 spot. On the other hand, I'm pretty sure I've watched Bambi on DVD in the past 5 years, but it still doesn't stay with me as much as Pinocchio.

Edited August 31, 2016 by cannastop

[chasmmi]

1 hour ago, cannastop said:

I don't know if I could even give an exact number of all the animated features I've watched.

 

 For example, I haven't seen Pinocchio since I was 7, but I feel strongly that it deserves a top 10 spot. 

 

I have that but the exact opposite with Beauty and the beast. 11 year old boy me thought it was a decent but girl animation. 32 Year old me would likely find it genius and top 10 worthy if I could just make myself watch it again. 

[cannastop]

Just now, chasmmi said:

 

I have that but the exact opposite with Beauty and the beast. 11 year old boy me thought it was a decent but girl animation. 32 Year old me would likely find it genius and top 10 worthy if I could just make myself watch it again. 

How could you possibly know that?

[Ethan Hunt]

1 hour ago, chasmmi said:

For easier to find animations, Book of Life is surprisingly excellent and really recommendable. I actually doubt that even Pixar will be able to pull off Day of the Dead better with Coco.

Totally agree. The Book of Life was the best animation of 2014

Edited September 1, 2016 by Ethan Hunt

[chasmmi]

1 hour ago, cannastop said:

How could you possibly know that?

 

Because looking at the clips,  songs, and so forth, it feels like the kind of film that i really respond to now.

 

I did also rewatch little Mermaid last year and that shot up in my estimations compared to before. 

 

Obviously i can't know for sure,  but in my old age i have started to find good story and plot as important as wisecracking genies or talking animals. 

[chasmmi]

44 minutes ago, Ethan Hunt said:

Totally agree. The Book of Life was the best animation of 2014

 

I look forward to seeing it on your expanded last

[cannastop]

17 minutes ago, chasmmi said:

 

Because looking at the clips,  songs, and so forth, it feels like the kind of film that i really respond to now.

 

I did also rewatch little Mermaid last year and that shot up in my estimations compared to before. 

 

Invisible i can't know for sure,  but in my old age i have started to find good story and plot as important as wisecracking genies or talking animals. 

OK, that makes sense. I thought you were changing your mind just by remembering the movie, which wouldn't make sense to me.

Edited September 1, 2016 by cannastop

[Walt Disney]

My Vote:

1.      Peter Pan

2.      101 Dalmatians

3.      Pinocchio

4.      Aladdin

5.      Robin Hood (Disney)

6.      The Nightmare Before Christmas

7.      Tangled

8.      The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh

9.      Dumbo

10.  Fun and Fancy Free

11.  Beauty and the Beast

12.  Ducktales The Movie: Treasure of the Lost Lamp

13.  Cinderella

14.  Lady and the Tramp

15.  Sleeping Beauty

16.  Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs

17.  The Princess and the Frog

18.  Wreck-It Ralph

19.  The Fox and the Hound

20.  Bambi

21.  The Lion King

22.  The Little Mermaid

23.  Frozen

24.  Toy Story

25.  Monsters Inc.

26.  Toy Story 3

27.  The Jungle Book

28.  Finding Nemo

29.  Fantasia

30.  The Incredibles

31.  Toy Story 2

32.  Monsters University

33.  Up

34.  Zootopia

35.  Wall-E

36.  Ratatouille

37.  Brave

38.  Alice in Wonderland

39.  The Sword in the Stone

40.  The Great Mouse Detective

41.  The Rescuers

42.  Winnie the Pooh (2011)

43.  Cars

44.  The Rescuers Down Under

45.  Big Hero 6

46.  Inside Out

47.  Finding Dory

48.  The Tigger Movie

49.  Piglet’s Big Movie

50.  Pooh’s Heffalump Movie

51.  Frankenweenie

52.  A Goofy Movie

53.  Lilo and Stitch

54.  Mulan

55.  Pocahontas

56.  The Hunchback of Notre Dame

57.  Make Mine Music

58.  Shrek Forever After

59.  An American Tale: Fievel Goes West

60.  The Simpsons Movie

61.  Jetsons: The Movie

62.  Transformers: The Movie

63.  The Land Before Time

64.  South Park: Bigger, Longer, Uncut

65.  An American Tale

66.  Tarzan

67.  Oliver and Company

68.  A Bug’s Life

69.  The Aristocats

70.  The Adventures of Ichabod and Mr. Toad

71.  Planes

72.  The Three Caballeros

73.  Saludos Amigos

74.  Cars 2

75.  Fantasia 2000

76.  Hercules

77.  The Emperor’s New Groove

78.  Planes: Fire and Rescue

79.  The Good Dinosaur

80.  Bolt

81.  Chicken Little

82.  Treasure Planet

83.  Atlantis: The Lost Empire

84.  Dinosaur

85.  Meet the Robinsons

86.  The Black Cauldron

87.  Brother Bear

88.  Home on the Range

89.  Strange Magic

90.  Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs

91.  The Peanuts Movie

92.  Bebe’s Kids

93.  Beavis and Butthead Do America

94.  Team America: World Police

95.  Hotel Transylvania

96.  The Polar Express

97.  Hotel Transylvania 2

98.  Mr. Peabody and Sherman

99. Shrek

100.  Shrek 2

 

Edited September 5, 2016 by Walt Disney

[cannastop]

@Walt Disney

 

Yay, the first complete 100 movie list!

 

[cannastop]

Shortened my list to 30, now that I'm 99% certain there are at least 100 unique and eligible movies voted for. A short list is what I wanted anyways.

[BadAtGender]

On 8/29/2016 at 6:54 PM, chasmmi said:

Also if 40 mins is the requisite for a feature them that is fine. 

 

What i didnt want is things like feast or paperman getting in. (As great as they are),

 

 

 

I've been wanting to do a best animated shorts listing, so I may try to organize it at some point after you finish this one up.

 

 

Is The Thief and the Cobbler eligible? Arabian Knight got a theatrical release, IIRC, but TatC itself didn't (which, uh, is understandable given its incomplete nature.) Is the Arabian Knight release sufficient, or would a vote have to be for that specifically?

 

Also, while World of Tomorrow isn't eligible, as a short, Hertzfeldt's It's Such a Beautiful Day did get a limited theatrical release and is (as much as I've seen) also very good, so take that into consideration. It's currently on Netflix, if you want to take a watch.

 

 

 

 

[RandomCat]

That was surprisingly easy, had a good to trim off the back end. And some I couldn't add because I remembered there were prolonged live action bits. Also, I like some cheesy animated films.

 

1.) ParaNorman

2.) The Brave Little Toaster

3.) Aladdin

4.) Detective Conan: Skyscraper on a Timer

5.) Kubo and the Two Strings

6.) Ghost in the Shell

7.) The Little Prince

8.) The Great Mouse Detective

9.) The Lego Movie

10.) The Land Before Time

11.) Mulan

12.) The Incredibles

13.) Rango

14.) Duck Tales the Movie

15.) Bolt

16.) Flushed Away

17.) Titan A.E.

18.) 9

19.) Rise of the Guardians

20.) An American Tail: Fievel Goes West

21.) A Bug's Life

22.) Kung Fu Panda

23.) Anastasia

24.) Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs

25.) Detective Conan: Strategy Above the Depths

26.) Beauty and the Beast

27.) Spirted Away

28.) Big Hero 6

29.) Zootopia

30.) The Iron Giant

31.) Wreck-It Ralph

32.) Book of Life

33.) Toy Story

34.) Shrek 2

35.) We're Back

36.) Brave

37.) Toy Story 3

38.) From Up on Poppy Hill

39.) Coraline

40.) Corpse Bride

41.) Boxtrolls

42.) Howl's Moving Castle

43.) Despicaple Me

44.) Detective Conan: The Phantom of Baker Street

45.) Fantastic Mr. Fox

46.) Emperor's New Groove

47.) Finding Dory

48.) Pokemon the Movie

49.) Finding Nemo

50.) Frozen

51.) Ice Age

52.) Porco Rosso

53.) Frakenweenie

54.) Robin Hood (1973)

55.) Final Fantasy

56.) Up

57.) Hercules

58.) How to Train your Dragon  

59.) Pocahontas

60.) Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs 2

61.) Inside Out

62.) James and the Giant Peach

63.) Kung Fu Panda 2

64.) Lilo and Stitch

65.) Lion King

66.) Megamind

67.) Metropolis (2001)

68.) Monsters Inc

69.) Nightmare Before Christmas

70.) Pompoko

71.) Ponyo

72.) Princess Monoke

73.) Hunchback of Notredame

74.) Dragon Ball Z: Battle of Gods

75.) Secret life of Pets

76.) Shrek

77.) Tangled

78.) The Adventures of TinTin

79.) The Pirates

80.) The Secret World of Arietty

81.) Toy Story 2

82.) Wallace & Gromit: The Curse of the Were Rabbit

83.) Wall-E

84.) Whisper of the Heart

85.) Madagascar

86.) Meet the Robinsons

87.) Monster House

88.) The Tales of Desperaoux

89.) Ratotouille

90.) Ice Age 2

91.) Hoodwinked  

92.) Puss in Boots

93.) Rio

94.) How to train your Dragon 2

95.) Princess and the Frog

96.) Simpson Movie

97.) Yellow Submarine

98.) Beowulf

99.) Balto

100.) Mr. Peabody & Sherman

Edited September 7, 2016 by RandomJC

[JohnnY]

20 hours ago, chasmmi said:

 

I must say I find it odd to see a Ghibli heavy list that doesn't contain Fireflies... I do need to eventually see more of these myself though too  

I'll probably rank Fireflies in the 20~30 range of the list.

[Blankments]

Will make a list of 100 likely in the last week of submissions being open