Rank the Best Picture nominees

[Ezen Baklattan]

Shape of water

get out

phantom thread

dunkirk

call me by your name

lady bird

the post

three billboards

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

darkest hour 

[filmlover]

lol at every movie having at least one vote in the poll except Darkest Hour and The Post. I almost feel sorry for them (not really in the case of the former).

[titanic2187]

1) Lady bird, 9.0/10: consistently awesome but less-thought provoking, proving that a coming-of-age story in an ordinary life can be engaging, not something like boyhood, utterly pointless..... 

2) Three Billboard, 8.5/10: Some significant flaw that too hard to ignore, unstable/less-cohesive plot; plenty of scene in the film are way too awesome!!! In a dark comedy that so emotional and full of subtle surprising twist! Another showcase of post-modernism in visual art.

3) The shape of water 8.5/10: Beautiful, romantic, and highly symbolic film, and engaging!! 

4) Dunkirk, 8.0/10: Top 3 Nolan's film as a director, bottom 3 nolan's film as a screenwriter. A pure directorship showcase that show a new direction for war film and so brilliantly visualized in a most sophisticated way yet emotional unsatisfying .

5) The post, 7.0/10: Way too oscar-bait but at least is a decent film, which turn a docu-drama into a thrilling drama.

6) Get out, 6.5/10: Smart west-wing racism concept in an unthrilling yet well-written thriller. 

7) Darkest Hour 6.0/10: Basically is a gary oldman solo showcase, he is too good, is a kind of make you speechless acting performance. 

I didnt watch phantom thread and call me by ur name 

[Jake Gittes]

1. Call Me by Your Name

2. Dunkirk

3. Lady Bird

4. Get Out

5. Darkest Hour

6. Three Billboards

7. The Shape of Water

 

No idea when I'll get to see Phantom Thread and The Post, but I expect the former will make the top 2 at the very least and the latter will be right around the middle, #5 or #6. 

[WrathOfHan]

2 hours ago, Jake Gittes said:

1. Call Me by Your Name

2. Dunkirk

3. Lady Bird

4. Get Out

5. Darkest Hour

6. Three Billboards

7. The Shape of Water

 

No idea when I'll get to see Phantom Thread and The Post, but I expect the former will make the top 2 at the very least and the latter will be right around the middle, #5 or #6. 

Darkest Hour over SOW and 3B? Hells no

[Jake Gittes]

19 minutes ago, WrathOfHan said:

Darkest Hour over SOW and 3B? Hells no

It's not good but I'd pick Joe Wright's superficially fun flashy theatrics over the sensibilities of McDonagh and GDT, both of which I actively resisted. 

[Rorschach]

1. Get Out  9/10

2. The Shape of Water  9/10

3. Dunkirk  8/10

4. Lady Bird  8/10

5. Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri  7.5/10 (can't decide on a 7 or 8)

Edited March 3, 2018 by Rorschach

[The Panda]

Get Out

Three Billboards

Lady Bird

Dunkirk

Call Me By Your Name

Phantom Thread

The Shape of Water

The Post

Darkest Hour

[Blankments]

Actor:

 

1. Chalamet

2. Day-Lewis

3. Kaluuya

4. Oldman

 

Didn't see Washington.

 

Actress:

 

1. Hawkins

2. Ronan

3. Streep

4. Robbie

5. McDormand

 

Supporting Actor:

 

1. Dafoe

2. Jenkins

3. Plummer

4-5. Harrelson/Rockwell (they're both nothing)

 

Supporting Actress:

 

1. Metcalf

2. Manville

(huge gap)

3. Janney

4. Spencer

5. Blige

[Webslinger]

Ranking acting nominees too? I dig it.

 

Actress

1. McDormand

2. Ronan

3. Hawkins

4. Robbie

5. Streep

 

Actor

1. Chalamet

2. Kaluuya

3. Day-Lewis

4. Oldman

5. Washington

 

Supporting Actress

1. Metcalf

2. Janney

3. Blige

4. Manville

5. Spencer

 

Supporting Actor

1. Rockwell

2. Dafoe

3. Harrelson

4. Plummer

5. Jenkins