Fantastic Beasts: The Secrets of Dumbledore | April 15, 2022 | Final Trailer on Page 75

[Samwise the Brave]

Lucas or whoever it was made me aware it can still be average based on reviews but i'm starting to get a good feeling about this

[Noctis]

Liking these reactions...hope the film keeps this up.

 

So now we have 2 more RT critics praising the film and one 7x Emmy Winner saying it's the 3rd best in the entire WWU.

 

Is Kevin Maher a top critic too? 

[Lucas]

7 minutes ago, Felipe said:

RT top critic

For some context, here's her CoG review on RT:

Of course it's also completely possible the film can have gone down in her estimations since she wrote this review.

[Felipe]

1 minute ago, Samwise the Brave said:

Lucas or whoever it was made me aware it can still be average based on reviews but i'm starting to get a good feeling about this

~71% so far (15 probably fresh/6 probably rotten).

 

2 minutes ago, Noctis said:

Liking these reactions...hope the film keeps this up.

 

So now we have 2 more RT critics praising the film and one 7x Emmy Winner saying it's the 3rd best in the entire WWU.

 

Is Kevin Maher a top critic too? 

He is!

[Heretic]

Would be happy with 60% on RT, but at this point, regardless of the score this gets on RT, I think it’s almost assured that the majority of people will far prefer this to CoG, and likely FB1 too.

 

4 days! 
 

 

[Noctis]

So we have the reactions of THREE top crirics and two are highly positive and the other seemingly positive. 

 

 

[Noctis]

3 minutes ago, Lucas said:

For some context, here's her CoG review on RT:

Of course it's also completely possible the film can have gone down in her estimations since she wrote this review.

 

There's a scene in The Dictator where someone doesn't know whether to smile or be upset in front of the dictator and ends up smiling and frowning in a continuous loop...

 

I feel like everyone has that reaction when reading your posts.

[Lucas]

3 minutes ago, Noctis said:

 

There's a scene in The Dictator where someone doesn't know whether to smile or be upset in front of the dictator and ends up smiling and frowning in a continuous loop...

 

I feel like everyone has that reaction when reading your posts.

lmao, trying to keep it real. There's definitely an air of CoG being looked at in a much more negative light now in hindsight than a lot of critics actually did when it was released. Generally when you're pretty middling on a movie to begin with, the pop culture consensus can sway you in that direction after more time has passed.

 

Pretty sure she's going for a 3.5-4/5 star review for SoD though, she definitely liked it.

[WeThrones]

I only care if Part 4 happens.

[ViewerAnon]

I'm very curious to see how things shake out critically. The reaction I've heard is pretty similar to WW84 but I don't have a large sample size and it's the follow-up to a disappointing sequel vs. a beloved original, which could help tip some of those ehhhhs into mildly fresh territory?

[Noctis]

5 minutes ago, ViewerAnon said:

I'm very curious to see how things shake out critically. The reaction I've heard is pretty similar to WW84 but I don't have a large sample size and it's the follow-up to a disappointing sequel vs. a beloved original, which could help tip some of those ehhhhs into mildly fresh territory?

 

You gave both FB1 and Crimes a 2.5/4 right? Have you seen the completed film (vfx done etc) or haven't seen it since the test screening?

[Lucas]

This has all the makings for a very exciting RT watch 

[Brainbug]

4 minutes ago, Lucas said:

This has all the makings for a very exciting RT watch 

 

It will probably get a nice 69%

Edited April 4, 2022 by Brainbug

[ViewerAnon]

18 minutes ago, Noctis said:

 

You gave both FB1 and Crimes a 2.5/4 right? Have you seen the completed film (vfx done etc) or haven't seen it since the test screening?

 

FB1 might be a 3/4? It's been awhile since I've seen it. I haven't seen TSOD yet - annoyingly I've had invites to screenings last week and this Wednesday, but I don't know if I'll make it due to life stuff. Very likely you'll see it before I do.

[Lucas]

Fittingly a screening is about to start in the UK right now.

[Noctis]

I live in the Middle East and due to Ramadan, they only release small movies during the month and won't see it until May 2/3.

 

A cruel twist of fate, but I'll be buying tickets for its US release. 

[Samwise the Brave]

Here we have previews on Tuesday and i'm attending on Wednesday. I hope it delivers

[Lucas]

 

Edited April 4, 2022 by Lucas

[Noiret Jak]

 

[Noctis]