That is largely what I was trying to get at. Sure, I can acknowledge that women falling in love with murderers isn’t exactly unrealistic, but the idea of this particular version of the Joker having an obsessed fangirl who he starts a relationship with comes across to me like it misses the point of the original. That was why I initially compared it to a Tumblr fanfic.
Of course, we know very little about the movie at this point, so we’ll have to wait and see how it goes. I just think that synopsis from a few weeks ago feels at odds with the general tone of the first film. Critics accused the first film of romanticizing incel culture, but I think giving Arthur Fleck a girlfriend would unironically validate those arguments.