Nolan's Batman Trilogy vs Marvel Phase One Movies. Super Fanboy Wars incoming.

[Phil in the Blank]

I've made this a multiple choice poll so people don't have to choose between the movies they consider truly excellent. Simply choose the movies that you feel deserve an A (- through +) and sit back and enjoy the results.

[CaptainJackSparrow]

Iron Man 2, Captain America, Avengers, Dark Knight.

[MrPink]

STOP STOP STOP STOP IT

 

WHAT ARE YOU DOING?

[Phil in the Blank]

STOP STOP STOP STOP IT

 

WHAT ARE YOU DOING?

 

If you can't beat them, join them

[CoolioD1]

1. Batman Begins - A

2. The Dark Knight - A

3. The Dark Knight Rises - A-

4. The Avengers - A-

5. Captain America - B+

6. Iron Man - B+

7. Thor - B

8. Iron Man 2 - C+

9. The Incredible Hulk - C

Edited December 31, 2013 by CoolioD1

[Empire]

Mine A Films from that list are:

 

- CA: TFA(A+)

- IM(A+)

- Avengers(A)

 

- BB(A-)

- TDK(A+)

[AdamKendall]

TDK A

BB A

IM A-

 

TDKR & The Avengers miss with a strong B+

 

After that ...

Captain America: The First Avenger B

Thor B

The Incredible Hulk C

Iron Man 2 C

Edited December 31, 2013 by Adam

[Lordmandeep]

TDK A+

TA A

BB A-

IM A-

TDKR A- 

[Punishment]

IM

TA

BB

TDKR

[rukaio101]

TA (A+)

TDK (A+)

BB (A)

CA (A)

IM (A-)

[4815162342]

Would only give an A to Batman Begins.

 

Iron Man, TDK, Avengers, and TDKR are A-

Edited December 31, 2013 by 4815162342

[ChD]

The Marvel movie I liked most was Captain America. I admit the villain was kind of meh (as are most Marvel villains, no offense), but I really liked it more than the others.

 

Batman Begins I'd say is a B+ whilst The Dark Knight is an A+ and The Dark Knight Rises A-.

 

The other marvel movies (apart from Iron Man 1 - A) are below B, with the last being Iron Man 3 with D+ (If I remember right... Not sure)

[Lordmandeep]

From my comments you think I would give TDKR a C+ buts its an A- film, however a big letdown compared to hype. 

[AdamKendall]

From my comments you think I would give TDKR a C+ buts its an A- film, however a big letdown compared to hype. 

It's very good, but it has a lot to live up to ... same thing Avengers 2 is going to face.

Edited December 31, 2013 by Adam

[Phil in the Blank]

As for me

 

Iron Man : A-

Incredible Hulk : B

Iron Man 2 : C-

Thor : C

Captain America : B+

Avengers : A-

Batman Begins : A

The Dark Knight : A-

The Dark Knight Rises : A+

[4815162342]

STOP STOP STOP STOP IT

 

WHAT ARE YOU DOING?

 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vmn9asN-8AE

[Fancyarcher]

The Dark Knight A+

 

The Dark Knight Rises A+

 

The Avengers A

 

Iron Man A

 

Batman Begins A-

 

Captain America: The First Avenger B+

 

The Incredible Hulk B+

 

Iron Man 2 B

 

Thor B

 

Honestly I really can't compare these movies, there trying to do entirely different things.

 

Nolans Batman trilogy works because Batman is an inherently dark character, and these movies are dark, at least to a point, in each movie there is a glimmer of hope, that something good will happen, that at the end all will be well.

 

The Marvel movies on the other hand embrace their goofiness, but still manage to have dark elements and dark themes, not talking down to the audience.

 

Both films do well considering the type of movie their trying to be.

Edited December 31, 2013 by Saintarcher

[Phil in the Blank]

I really can't compare these movies, there trying to do entirely different things.

 

Nolans Batman trilogy works because Batman is an inherently dark character, and these movies are dark, at least to a point, in each movie there is a glimmer of hope, that something good will happen, that at the end all will be well.

 

The Marvel movies on the other hand embrace their goofiness, but still manage to have dark elements and dark themes, not talking down to the audience

Both films do well considering the type of movie their trying to be.

 

Thats why I made it a multiple choice poll, so you don't have to compare them, just choose the ones that you really enjoyed.

[Goffe]

Batman Begin A+

The Dark Knight Rises A

The Dark Knight A-

Iron Man B (almost a B+)

The Avengers B

Thor B

The Incredible Hulk B-

Captain America C+

Edited December 31, 2013 by Goffe Luvs 1D

[Fancyarcher]

Thats why I made it a multiple choice poll, so you don't have to compare them, just choose the ones that you really enjoyed.

 

Works for me.