Jump to content

Shawn Robbins

The Official TASM Weekly Thread (6 Day EST-140m) (Warning: Whiten Out Spoilers/Spoiler Tags)

By Shawn Robbins, in Numbers and Data

Recommended Posts

druv10 Global Phenomenon

druv10

Posted
Posted

I don't think I ever said anything as dismissive as "Nobody can deny this". I made my points and argued them.

You're right, my tone was over the top and I apologize to Dark Alfred for that.
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites


The Dark Alfred Summer Tentpole

The Dark Alfred

Posted
Posted

SM3 might be okay but to say it is better than TASM is BLASPHEMY!

Not really. Garfield and Stone are the strong elements from TASM, but it fails in every other department. SM3 had a better story, funnier script, better score, better villain, better pace and better action.
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites
John Marston Global Phenomenon

John Marston

Posted
Posted

Not really. Garfield and Stone are the strong elements from TASM, but it fails in every other department. SM3 had a better story, funnier script, better score, better villain, better pace and better action.

don't agree at all. but whatever.
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites


Accursed Arachnid!™ Summer Tentpole

Accursed Arachnid!™

Posted
Posted

What pluses? I can give you minuses. Uncle Ben's death, Harry's amnesia, muddled plot, over the top cheese fest including Maguire's dancing, neutering of Venom, Raimi's reliance on MJ being stuck in danger in every movie, Maguire catching MJ in all 3 movies, mailed in performance by Maguire and that's top of my head. I haven't seen the movie since OW 2007.

I love when people try to convert me into hating SM3. You're just spinning your wheels. I have my reasons for liking it but I'm not gonna attempt to convert you into liking it. You hate it..I got it...I'm sure there are plenty of films you like that I hate. ;)
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites


druv10 Global Phenomenon

druv10

Posted
Posted

I love when people try to convert me into hating SM3. You're just spinning your wheels. I have my reasons for liking it but I'm not gonna attempt to convert you into liking it. You hate it..I got it...I'm sure there are plenty of films you like that I hate. ;)

Touche.
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites
JackO Blockbuster

JackO

Posted
Posted

Not really. Garfield and Stone are the strong elements from TASM, but it fails in every other department. SM3 had a better story, funnier script, better score, better villain, better pace and better action.

I'd rate them about even.SM3 slightly ahead since it didn't take itself so super seriously.
Link to comment
Share on other sites


The Dark Alfred Summer Tentpole

The Dark Alfred

Posted
Posted (edited)

don't agree at all. but whatever.

Let's break it down. Does anyone think that Elfman's score wasn't better? Does anyone think that Lizard was better villain than Green Goblin/Sandman (let's forget the Venom mess, that was just plain awful)? SM3 had some spectacular action scenes, TASM had 3 short action sequences, none of them were impressive. SM3 had a fair share of funny moments, it had Bruce Campbell and J.K. Simmons!!! TASM doesn't have much humor, it's best moment is the Stan Lee cameo. I can't get into the scripts without spoiling TASM, so skip that part. SM3 is an unbalanced film with a pathetic third act, but its main problem is that it followed the nearly perfect SM2, so that's why the major hatred towards it. It wasn't a bad film.SM - ASM2 - A+SM3 - B+TASM - B Edited by The Dark Alfred
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites


Adm56 Sleeper Hit

Adm56

Posted
Posted

First Class made me appreciate X-Men 3 (A filmed I hated after the first viewing) more. TASM did the same thing for Spidey 3. Neither Spidey 3 or X-Men 3 come anywhere near the quality of the previous films in their respective series, but at least they are 'quality by association' unlike the reboots.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites


JackO Blockbuster

JackO

Posted
Posted

Even if you loved it you would say it sucks. You've been hating for months, I don't expect you to change now.

Well I did already see half the movie through the clips Sony released. ;)
Link to comment
Share on other sites
ACCA Box Office Gold

ACCA

Posted
Posted

I also agree with others here that Venom or Carnage need to be done properly in another movie, to make up for the major screw up Raimi made with Venom. Everyone knows that Raimi had a personal hate against Venom, and when Sony forced him to use Venom in SM3, he screwed up the Venom portrayal big-time.If not Venom, then at the very least Carnage in some aspect.

For me, that would be like Christmas, Chanukuh, Kwanza, and Festivis all rolled into one.

I think that one of the BEST things ever to happen for Marvel on film would be for the film rights of Spiderman to rightfully come back to Marvel (and therefore Disney). Sony has no business making Spiderman films anymore.In conclusion, I am sick of Sony, and would love nothing more than to see Marvel rightfully take back the Spiderman rights and make proper Spiderman films.
  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites




druv10 Global Phenomenon

druv10

Posted
Posted (edited)

I also agree with others here that Venom or Carnage need to be done properly in another movie, to make up for the major screw up Raimi made with Venom. Everyone knows that Raimi had a personal hate against Venom, and when Sony forced him to use Venom in SM3, he screwed up the Venom portrayal big-time.If not Venom, then at the very least Carnage in some aspect.I think that one of the BEST things ever to happen for Marvel on film would be for the film rights of Spiderman to rightfully come back to Marvel (and therefore Disney). Sony has no business making Spiderman films anymore.In conclusion, I am sick of Sony, and would love nothing more than to see Marvel rightfully take back the Spiderman rights and make proper Spiderman films.

Funny thing is, at one point I wanted TASM to flop on John Carter level so Marvel could get the rights back but when haters went overboard; I changed my tone.Edit: I want FF back as well. Think of the possibilities including Galactus vs TA. :drool: Edited by druv10
Link to comment
Share on other sites


Adm56 Sleeper Hit

Adm56

Posted
Posted

BTW...I'd be interested to see a breakdown on how much time Spidey is in his suit during TASM and how it compares to the previous films. For a movie where I felt every minute of it's considerable /excessive length there seemed to be very little Spider-man on the screen during TASM. It might have been more genuine to call it The Powerful Peter Parker or something thing similar. But hey, at least we didn't get Peter Parker the Musical like we did with SM3.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites


JackO Blockbuster

JackO

Posted
Posted

When you post things like that, I hope you know you don't sound clever in any way. You just sound extremely stupid. Clips and trailer equal half a movie? Really?

Posted Image

20 of them, yes
Link to comment
Share on other sites


CloneWars Blockbuster

CloneWars

Posted
Posted

When you post things like that, I hope you know you don't sound clever in any way. You just sound extremely stupid. Clips and trailer equal half a movie? Really?

Posted Image

Personally, I felt all the clips and trailers I saw pretty much showed most of the movie, and I wasn't even trying to pay attention to them. Actually, I retract that, the trailers and clips remove all the excess crap and show what little good stuff the film has to offer, which is not much.
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites






Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Go to topic listing

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.


×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Guidelines. Feel free to read our Privacy Policy as well.

  I accept