The Avengers vs. The Amazing Spider-Man vs. DKR

[The Stingray]

I say TA & TDKR are pretty much on the same level. TA exceeded my expectations, TDKR was below my admittedly super high expectations. I give both films 8/10. A Twilight Spider-Man doesn't hold my interest. I'll catch it on TV in a year or two.

Edited August 5, 2012 by Don Niam The Stingray

[Webslinger]

To be fair to The Amazing Spider-Man, it's not very Twilight-esque. The Garfield/Stone romance actually has some heat to it, while I have never for a second bought the central relationship in the Twilight films. On top of that, credit must also be given to the fact that the filmmakers avoid making Gwen Stacy a damsel in distress. She's still not an especially well-developed character, but the third act isn't built around saving her from the clutches of evil.

[JackO]

Does TASM need to be defended in every thread? Especially when someone has a legitimate critique? This was a love story for tweenbots. "Oh itz da first date let me tell this girl in my class my super duper secret identity becuz i love her even though we only had one date that is not even over yet." Their relationship was a joke even if it was well acted.

[Goffe]

TDKR A+but compared to TA and TASMTDKR A+++TA BTASM B-

Edited August 8, 2012 by Goffe Recall

[Goffe]

I felt Avengers lacked heart and real danger.

fixed

100% agreed

Edited August 8, 2012 by Goffe Recall

[GamingFreak]

I thought TASM was decent. I enjoyed TA and loved TDKR.

[Lumos]

TDKR is probably the best film out of these three, but I found much more to enjoy with TASM...and frankly Batman and Nolan are both ridiculously over rated. So I voted for TASM.Also, the Avengers is one of the worst superhero films I have ever seen. Not a popular opinion, but there ya go....TDKR: BTASM: B-TA: D+

[cheesypoofs]

TDKR is probably the best film out of these three, but I found much more to enjoy with TASM...and frankly Batman and Nolan are both ridiculously over rated. So I voted for TASM.

Also, the Avengers is one of the worst superhero films I have ever seen. Not a popular opinion, but there ya go....

TDKR: B

TASM: B-

TA: D+

What, why? What's your reasoning behind this?

[Kalderic]

I love TAS... I sat in the theater like a five year old in a candy store! Hands down my favorite of the summer. TAS - ATA - A-TDKR - B

[Jessie]

TDKR is probably the best film out of these three, but I found much more to enjoy with TASM...and frankly Batman and Nolan are both ridiculously over rated. So I voted for TASM.Also, the Avengers is one of the worst superhero films I have ever seen. Not a popular opinion, but there ya go....TDKR: BTASM: B-TA: D+

What? Oh wait, I just released your a Potter fan, naturally you have bad taste in movies.

[Lumos]

^I'm not a fan of superhero movies. The only SH films that I thought were above average were Spiderman 1&2 (probably because they were a novelty at the time) and The Dark Knight. Recently the market share of superhero films have sky-rocketed, which has made me a little apathetic towards them. All they are is dumb fun, and simple crowd pleasers - with the odd exception of course. Obviously these type of films sell but I'd like to see Hollywood pump out a few more original blockbusters of higher quality.

[Noctis]

^I'm not a fan of superhero movies. The only SH films that I thought were above average were Spiderman 1&2 (probably because they were a novelty at the time) and The Dark Knight. Recently the market share of superhero films have sky-rocketed, which has made me a little apathetic towards them. All they are is dumb fun, and simple crowd pleasers - with the odd exception of course. Obviously these type of films sell but I'd like to see Hollywood pump out a few more original blockbusters of higher quality.

Why defend yourself against that idiot?

[Jessie]

^I'm not a fan of superhero movies. The only SH films that I thought were above average were Spiderman 1&2 (probably because they were a novelty at the time) and The Dark Knight. Recently the market share of superhero films have sky-rocketed, which has made me a little apathetic towards them. All they are is dumb fun, and simple crowd pleasers - with the odd exception of course. Obviously these type of films sell but I'd like to see Hollywood pump out a few more original blockbusters of higher quality.

SM1 was on T.V a few days ago. I used to think it was good until I watched it recently. Try watching it again now and see if you still find it any good.

[Jessie]

Why defend yourself against that idiot?

Uh oh, here come the cavalry