Arnold vs. Sly. Who has made the best movies?

[The Stingray]

Who's your favorite?

[The Toymaker]

I see why this was made. The overall poll result will be obvious.

I voted for Stallone, Commando and Rocky IV.

[CoolioD1]

Sly is the better actor and has done some great dramatic movies like Rocky, First Blood and Cop Land. But Arnie's movies are such magnificent entertainment that I have to vote for him.

Edited October 15, 2012 by CoolioD1

[Elessar]

Arnold, easily. Just the two Terminators trump everything Stallone has done by a mile. Then you still have Predator, True Lies, Total Recall etc.

[The Stingray]

Arnold, easily. Just the two Terminators trump everything Stallone has done by a mile. Then you still have Predator, True Lies, Total Recall etc.

What about First Blood & Rocky?

[chasmmi]

Personally I put Stallone's best as better than Arnie's.However I also put his worst far below Arnie's worst.

[Elessar]

What about First Blood & Rocky?

Not in the same league. Terminator 2 is one of my favorite movies ever. Rocky and Rambo are okay.

[The Toymaker]

Taken from my Top 100 ever:

1. Rocky IV

2. Rambo III

3. Rambo: First Blood Part II

5. Get Carter (2000)

7. Cliffhanger

9. First Blood

10. Predator

11. Copland

12. Rocky II

13. Terminator 2: Judgement Day

14. Rocky

15. Rocky III

16. Commando

17. Tango & Cash

18. Raw Deal

22. Rocky Balboa

23. Assassins

24. True Lies

25. Shade

27. The Terminator

31. Conan the Barbarian

35. Demolition Man

36. Rambo

38. The Specialist

47. Cobra

57. Over the Top

63. Daylight

64. Nighthawks

66. D-Tox

67. Lock Up

78. The Expendables

80. Bananas

84. Conan the Destroyer

86. The Expendables 2

95. Red Heat

Stallone in bold. Red Heat is graded A.

[baumer]

I appreciate the poll, but I think I'll mostly sit this one out. algren can speak for me pretty much.I love em both and it's literally like asking me which child I like best. Most of their films are fantastic and I'd put Terminator 2 and First Blood at pretty much even in terms of quality. I'm not going to get into it much more. Arnold rocks, Sly is iconic.

[Letsuseournoggin]

I think Arnold owns the best film out of the two with Judgment Day, but Sly is the much more talented man. His acting is superior, he is a writer, has played a vital role in directing and what he did with Rocky is fantastic. He literally built that movie from nothing. So even though T2 is the best film for me, I think Sly gets the overall edge when you factor in a lot of other things.

[75Live]

I appreciate the poll, but I think I'll mostly sit this one out. algren can speak for me pretty much.I love em both and it's literally like asking me which child I like best. Most of their films are fantastic and I'd put Terminator 2 and First Blood at pretty much even in terms of quality. I'm not going to get into it much more. Arnold rocks, Sly is iconic.

I'm with you baumer. I grew up with their movies and to pick one of them over the other is extremely difficult. So I choose both

[YoursTruly]

That top 100 list is comedic gold!Well, at least you didn't include "Judge Dredd."

[Jessie]

Stallone has made the best movies and Arnie has starred in the best.

[Punishment]

Arnold, Predator, Rocky IV

[efialtes76]

I like Stallone,but Arnold is the best!TerminatorTerminator 2PredatorTotall RecallTrue LiesCommandoEraserLast Action HeroConanRed HeatTwinsKindergarten Cop....My Stallone's top 5:1.First Blood2.Lock Up3.Over The Top4.Rocky 35.Demolition Man/Tango&Cash

Edited October 15, 2012 by efialtes76

[Caboose]

[vc2002]

Sly definitely is more talented. He can write (a great writer actually), direct and act. But Arnold had better luck, as he had himself in the hands of some of the best action directors ever.Me personally, I'm a huge Arnold fanboy and I love all his films (except Junior which I hate). And T2 is my fav film of all time. I was never a HUGE fan of Sly. I had a lot of respect for this guy tho.

Edited October 16, 2012 by vc2002

[Olive]

I like Arnold much more.

[Phil in the Blank]

Arnold made the more enjoyable movies in my mind.However as others have said, Sly is the much more talented individual.Funny how these things work.

Edited October 16, 2012 by Phil in the Rises

[The Toymaker]

Rotten Tomatoes Top 5:

Rocky 91%

First Blood 87%

Cliffhanger 82%

Rocky Balboa 76%

Cop Land 72%

The Terminator 100%

Terminator 2: Judgement Day 98%

Total Recall 84%

Predator 77%

Conan the Barbarian 77%