Fanboy Wars Thread: Personal Attacks not allowed | With Digital Fur Technology

[Jandrew]

My gf is one of the biggest Potterheads out there and she hated the Beasts trailer when I showed it to her. So I'ma go with Rogue One.

[Blankments]

Need Rogue One footage first, but as a non-Potter fan, the Beasts teaser was actually pretty neat for me. Good atmosphere

[James]

Beasts of course. The hype will be insane. OS and WW. DOM goes to RO.

Trimis de pe al meu SM-J100H folosind Tapatalk

[Lumos]

I think Fantastic Beasts is going to be a lot bigger than a lot of people on this board are predicting. That being said, I still see Rogue One coming out on top

 

FB: 370M

RO: 600m?

 

Not sure how things will shake up overseas. But they should both clear 1b WW with ease.....

[Olive]

Rogue One  185/550/1350

FB 100/300/950

[Akiraptor]

I think it could be close, though will go with Rogue One for now. I wouldn't judge the hype for FB until we actually see some fantastic beasts. 

[kitik]

1 hour ago, Noctis said:

The spin-offs to the two biggest franchises will be released next year.

 

 

MCU and Star Wars? I think Doctor Strange will be cool, but Rogue One is going to make at least double whatever Dr Strange does.

[Orestes]

Gonna go with Rogue One. If Vader is in it, and the advertising doesn't try to mystery box that shit, it could/should have the edge.

[Rogerio]

Rogue One, of course...

If it was Potter x Star Wars, I don´t know..

but Star Wars x Fantastic Beasts... of course the first will win, it has the name of the main saga... ( besides, everyone will be excited after The force awakens, so that will help a lot)...

[Ethan Hunt]

People are predicting 500M+ for Rogue One

 

[Warmaster506]

If Darth Vader is in RO it will win easily.  

[Durden]

Rogue One - 1.3b

Fantastic Beasts - 850m

[RyneOh1040]

Man, maybe i'm crazy but the RO predictions seems out of control to me!  I understand how big of a brand it truly is, but damn.  TFA is truly a perfect storm and regardless of whether or not it tops Avatar to take the domestic crown I don't see RO coming within 1/2 of it's DOM gross.  350-400 would be a fantastic result, in my opinion.  

 

Maybe I'm wrong but I just don't think the franchise can keep pushing out 500 million grosses every year, we've just been spoiled lately and lost a bit of our discernment.  

 

But back to the question, what's going to be make or break is whether Fantastic Beasts brings in GA.  The teaser was obviously not enough to do it, but I think a proper one does have the power.  Right now I see it along the lines of 300-315.  Rogue One seems more likely to break the 350 threshold to me, so I'll give the DOM crown to RO.  OS should be a tight race too, but I think FB might have the edge there.  RO probably still comes out on top overall.  

 

If FB can get DH2 reviews and an excellent trailer I think there's a legitimate rivalry.  If not I don't think it will even exist.

 

And I'm a huge potterhead.

Edited December 20, 2015 by RyneOh1040

[The Panda]

Rogue One should go over 400m, I'm skeptical about any higher because it's a spin-off.

 

Fantastic Beasts will be pushing for over 200m, under 300m is unlikely.

 

OS will be close, we have to see how well TFA will do.  Spin offs usually do better overseas than domestic.

 

WW, DOM will help Rogue One win out.

[Kalo]

Rogue One easily. 

[DAJK]

Easily Rogue One.

 

FB: 98/289/956

RO: 171/503/1125

[CaptainJackSparrow]

Rogue One for now, was super hyped for Fantastic Beasts until that teaser.

[John Marston]

Rogue One of course. Fantastic Beasts will likely appeal mostly to die hard Potter fans only.

[Michael Gary Scott]

Rogue One

[Box Office Hit]

Rogue One