Robin Williams or Bill Murray ?

[A Marvel Fanboy]

Whos comedies you like more ?

[DAR]

Bill Murray. Even Williams good ones tend to get a little sappy

[MagnetMan]

Probably Williams. And not because I prefer his comedy. He does better dramatic turns (esp. Good Will Hunting). And Murray's reputation in his personal life kinda works against him in my eyes.Edit: Well now that I've actually taken the time and read the first post (which comedies do you prefer) instead of simply reading the title of the thread....I'd have to go with Murray. Stripes, Groundhog Day, Ghostbusters... yeah, Murray.

Edited July 29, 2012 by MagnetMan

[CoolioD1]

Murray. I much prefer his deadpan style of humour.

[Jack Nevada]

I cant choose. Honestly

[Accursed Arachnid!™]

Murray will win this. His sarcastic humor is much more modern. Williams is my pick, his stand up routine is much more potent. He just picks movie roles that seem to leave his ability to be his maniacal self shackled.http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3wKkuhOcoxg

[Moviedweeb]

As Magnetman pointed out, it's hard to gauge exactly what this thread is asking.Both are brilliant in terms of their comedic talent but as far as film resumes go, I think Bill Murray has the stronger slate. Robin Williams does get a little "schmaltzy" and I really appreciate the direction Bill has taken in the last decade. I think his dramatic turns have been more successful.

[Ozymandias]

Bill Murray is hysterical. I never found Robin Williams very funny.

[tommycruise]

Bill Murray is hysterical. I never found Robin Williams very funny.

+1

[JackO]

Bill Murray by far. Robin Williams only has one shtick and it has been tired for the past decade.

[The Movie Man]

Overall Murray!

[Thrylos 7]

Robin Williams is one of the funniest actors ever , even in movies that are bad . I also had the pleasure of meeting him and taking pictures with him when i was in Manhattan last year and he is an amazing person , extremely kind (and he was great in the thetater in "Bengal Tiger" ). Bill Murray , i like his style but i don't like most of his movies (the newer ones are particularly horrible) .I vote Robin Williams (the guy even spoke greek to me , i would vote for him even if my opinion was different!!! )

Edited July 30, 2012 by Thrylos 7

[redfirebird2008]

Caddyshack. End of debate as far as I'm concerned. Murray FTMFW.

[rockNrollaDIM]

Between Mrs. Doubtfire, Jumanji, Jack, and Aladdin... I was a big Robin Williams fan as a kid. Weird.

[cozmeesah]

I cant choose. Honestly

Agreed. They are both hysterical but in totally different ways and I love them both. But I can't choose which one because I can't compare the two.One Robin Williams movie that I love that a lot of people hate is Death to Smoochy. He CRACKED me up in that.NSFW video:http-~~-//www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nj8-ATbUJ1Y

[Sims]

Murray is miles ahead in both comedy and drama. Williams is usually just annoying.

[TLK]

Bill Murray. Problem with Williams is that 90% of his movies are shit and he is one of the reasons why they are shit.

[baumer]

Williams is the funnier person but I'll take Murray's movie for sure. Stripes, Ghostbusters, Caddyshack and Meatballs are quite hilarious.

[Letsuseournoggin]

I guess I'm going with Robin Williams because I'm biased. He was a really swell guy when he visited a hotel I used to work at when I was younger. He wasn't a prick or anything like most celebrities I saw. For that, he wins my vote.To honestly answer the poll though, Murray.

Edited August 1, 2012 by Letsuseournoggin