Gravity | Re-released on 2D and 3D January 17 | IMAX 3D on January 31! | 100M+ WW IMAX

[dashrendar44]

Or according to you guys, only ideas like Aliens, Time Travel and Interstellar Space travel can be classified as sci-fi ? Even Cloning can not be sci-fi, because it is practicable.

 

?

Are we cloning people on a daily basis? Do you see human clones walk the earth today? What type of "cloning" are you talking about?

Edited September 6, 2013 by dashrendar44

[K1stpierre]

Are we cloning people on a daily basis? Do you see human clones walk the earth today? What type of "cloning" are you talking about?

Let's hope we aren't...o.O

[A Marvel Fanboy]

Are we cloning people on a daily basis? Do you see human clones walk the earth today? What type of "cloning" are you talking about?

Do you see people drifting in Space on a daily basis ?

[A Marvel Fanboy]

Anyway so Inception is not sci-fi because everbody dreams everyday.

 

I think I get it.

[DeeCee]

Apollo 13 was the Sci Fi film I've seen. It just felt so real.

[John Marston]

Gravity is Sci Fi? I don't think so.

[A Marvel Fanboy]

So please stop comparing Gravity with 2001 A Space Odyssey. Since Gravity is not even a sci-fi film.

Edited September 7, 2013 by firedeep

[Cairo]

Does it really matter whether this is classified as sci-fi or not? 

[Goffe]

So please stop comparing Gravity with 2001 A Space Odyssey. Since Gravity is not even a sci-fi film.

both set in the space, so yeah, they're comparable

[druv10]

This is the dumbest debate ever on BOF. Who cares whether it's Sci-fi or not, movie looks amazing and that's all I care.   

Edited September 7, 2013 by druv10

[Black Hawk]

Someone change the title please.'Gravity:Sci-Fi or not' sounds great. LOL

[Blankments]

Anyway so Inception is not sci-fi because everbody dreams everyday.

 

I think I get it.

 

If that was just it, yeah it wouldn't be sci-fi. However, Inception has people invading others' dreams, something that is currently impossible. Thus, it is sci-fi.

 

As for Gravity... this is probably the stupidest argument ever. I don't think it's sci-fi, but am I going to argue my point for 20 pages? Heck, no.

[A Marvel Fanboy]

If that was just it, yeah it wouldn't be sci-fi. However, Inception has people invading others' dreams, something that is currently impossible. Thus, it is sci-fi.

 

As for Gravity... this is probably the stupidest argument ever. I don't think it's sci-fi, but am I going to argue my point for 20 pages? Heck, no.

All what happens in Inception is just a dream as some people say, so yeah, not sci-fi.

[Kvikk Lunsj]

(You didn't even answer my exemple and didn't see the "science plays some major role in the plot" part.)

 

Imagine Gravity was actually about Clooney and Bullock falling in love with each other and then breaking up. So is it scifi or a romcom?

A movie can be more then genre. 

[A Marvel Fanboy]

Top Unsolved Mysteries in BOF history:

 

1. Gravity: Not a Sci-fi

 

2. STID: Nothing Went Wrong

 

3. The Unexpected Floppit

 

4. Michael Bay VS Nolan VS Cameron

[Jandrew]

This is the dumbest debate ever on BOF.

 

No. That title belongs to the Marvel vs DC arguments. This bottomless sci-fi argument will never reach the stfu level of that. Ever.

Edited September 7, 2013 by Twerkdrew

[StarSaber]

Top Unsolved Mysteries in BOF history:

 

1. Gravity: Not a Sci-fi

 

2. STID: Nothing Went Wrong

 

3. The Unexpected Floppit

 

4. Michael Bay VS Nolan VS Cameron

Oh Firedeep, you so silly.

[A Marvel Fanboy]

Oh Firedeep, you so silly.

Maybe you are the silly one if you think Gravity is surely not sci-fi.

[StarSaber]

Maybe you are the silly one if you think Gravity is surely not sci-fi.

Oh you.

[The Stingray]

This is the dumbest debate ever on BOF. Who cares whether it's Sci-fi or not, movie looks amazing and that's all I care.   

And its been going on for like a week.