Jackson's LOTR Triogy vs Nolans Batman Triolgy

[vc2002]

When we consider the competition objectively and compare the impact on the industry, the critical reception and the financial success, LOTR is obviously much ahead of Nolan's batman trilogy.

 

TDK is my fav among the six tho.

Edited December 25, 2014 by vc2002

[Jessie]

No, The Bourne trilogy is because it's the only one I can name without a weak instalment ( it's RotK for LotR)

Bourne is good but it's no LOTR

[lilmac]

Both are great but LOTR is 2nd to Star Wars OT as far as trilogies go.

[RobinHood26]

Pretty equal to me but I gotta say Batman. It's more embedded into my childhood. I had wonderful theater experiences with all 3 (6th,9th, and freshman in college) I grew up anticipating them. With LOTR however I was too young 8,9,10 when they came out and I never saw them in theaters. It wasn't until later that I grew fond of them.

[peludo]

I love both trilogies, but LOTR wins.

 

1. Fellowship of the Ring: 10/10

2. Two Towers: 9.5/10

3. Dark Knight: 9.5/10

4. Return of the King: 9.5/10

5. Batman Begins: 9/10

6. Dark Knight Rises: 8.5/10

[tong kosong]

Abstain. It's equal to me.

LOTR and TDK trilogy are my most favorite trilogies of all time. The 6 films are my most favorite films of all time.

[TServo2049]

TDK is excellent, Batman Begins is very good, TDKR is...well, TDKR...but I'm going to have to cast my vote for LOTR. I was a couple weeks away from my 14th birthday when I saw FOTR, and this trilogy was a major part of my cinematic coming-of-age.

Back in '99, before The Phantom Menace actually came out, I had thought the Star Wars prequel trilogy would become my generation's Star Wars trilogy. But even just after seeing FOTR, it became clear to me that LOTR was destined to assume that mantle.

Edited December 26, 2014 by TServo2049

[MrPink]

I abstain

[Leyla]

pleasantly surprised by the results 

 

 

LOTR trilogy easily, and I'm honestly surprised it's leading in this poll given the Nolan bukkake that goes on in this forum.

same same

I thought it would be like the opposite in %

Edited December 26, 2014 by Lady of Lorien

[Omario]

I absolutely love TDK trilogy. As a whole i consider it a masterpiece. As separate films i only consider TDK as such. LOTR trilogy as a whole AND each film  individually is a masterpiece. 

 

LOTR all the way

[The47th]

The thing is, I enjoy the Batman films more individually, but I think LOTR is stronger as a trilogy.

[luna]

It won't if you don't look for politics that aren't there. 

 

it isn't what is made explicit that is important in determining the moral value of popular entertainment. in fact, the reproduction of mainstream ideology will always be more invisible than clear-cut evil, which makes it all the more insidious.

[4815162342]

Nice to see Nolan lose something for a change.

[MrPink]

Nice to see Nolan lose something for a change.

Tele's club wasn't enough for you? Screw you!

[Jake Gittes]

it isn't what is made explicit that is important in determining the moral value of popular entertainment. in fact, the reproduction of mainstream ideology will always be more invisible than clear-cut evil, which makes it all the more insidious.

 

You can see evil lurking anywhere if you only look hard enough. Doesn't mean it's actually there.

[Midz13]

LOTR

[4815162342]

Tele's club wasn't enough for you? Screw you!

I can honestly say I haven't watched half of Nolan's films half as much as you would like and I like less than half of them half as much as you feel they deserve.

[MrPink]

I can honestly say I haven't watched half of Nolan's films half as much as you would like and I like less than half of them half as much as you feel they deserve.

BILBO BAGGINS. DO NOT TAKE ME AS SOME CONJUROR OF CHEAP OPINIONS. I'm trying to help you

[CaptainJackSparrow]

Two great films (FOTR, ROTK) VS one great film (TDK). LOTR for me.

Edited December 26, 2014 by Captain Jack Sparrow

[Ozymandias]

Nice to see Nolan lose something for a change.

 

Even the Nolanites know better with this one. #nodisrespect