LOTR: Return of the King or Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part 2?

[John Marston]

which of these two is better and why do you think so?

Edited December 1, 2012 by John Marston

[peludo]

Easily ROTK. That is not my favorite movie of the trilogy, but it is enough to beat DH2. The epic of final chapter is enormous. Harry Potter does not have it at the same level. In my opinon, a very easy battle.

[Olive]

ROTK>>>>>>>>>>>DH2.

[Lumos]

RotK is in a completely different league than DH2. It's a cinematic masterpiece incomparable to any other fantasy film. Possibly the greatest film ever made. DH2 is fun and entertaining but it has too many flaws and does not reach the same level of emotional intensity and monumental epicness that RotK delivered.

[Jake Gittes]

Is that even a question?

[CoolioD1]

Return of the King. Easily.

[Noctis]

DH2. Easily.RoTK was disappointing.

[Jessie]

DH2 is a fun little chapter, but ROTK is grande, epic, emotional and cinematic. They aren't even close, matter of fact there isn't a single potter movie better than any LOTR film.

[The Stingray]

How about both are sucky bloated messes..

[Jessie]

How about both are sucky bloated messes..

Lol, but which is the suckiest of messes?

[Jessie]

ROTK has killer elephants, 2 massive battles, gollum, trolls and a massive Spider.Dh2 has a shitty looking Dragon that couldn't top the dragons in Reign of fire with over twice the budget and better technology.Basically from an entertainment POV, ROTK still wins.

[The Stingray]

Lol, but which is the suckiest of messes?

I don't know. I have seen neither.

[ddddeeee]

DH2. RotK is just a big letdown after the first two.

[Jessie]

DH2 is more comparable to Narnia/twilight than LOTR

Edited December 1, 2012 by Jessie

[4815162342]

ROTK

[DAR]

Personally I love both but if I had to choose I'd say ROTK.

[Noctis]

ROTK has killer elephants, 2 massive battles, gollum, trolls and a massive Spider.Dh2 has a shitty looking Dragon that couldn't top the dragons in Reign of fire with over twice the budget and better technology.Basically from an entertainment POV, ROTK still wins.

I respect your opinion, but the dragon looked bad? Are you serious? It was stunning.

[75Live]

^{ROTK for me} Edited December 1, 2012 by 75live

[fishstick]

DH2 for me because I hate Shriekapoo for reasons you are all too familiar with. And i`m happy that LOTR actors didn`t become stars, that Blanchett has no way in hell of catching up with Streep`s oscars (Next Streep my ass) and that PJ`s non-ME movies disappointed and flopped. LOTR ammassed the most annoying overrated people on the planet so serves them right they didn`t go big like RDJ and Depp. Oh, and Viggo Mortensen`s face lift is an embarrassment. hahahahaha, now that one was ridiculous. His PR tried to sell him as genuine manly man, sleeps in the woods with a sword prop, roasts roadkills...and than it turns out he`s as vain as any pampered Hollywood type, hence face lift. Wet fart that one.

Edited December 1, 2012 by fishnets

[Ozymandias]

Return of the King. The extended edition makes it way better and more organic. I can't believe Saruman's scene and a handfull of others were cut out of the theatrical release. Was never a fan of Harry Potter.

Edited December 1, 2012 by Shpongle